Each Thursday for the remainder of summer, Post-Gazette columnist Joe Starkey will break down the quarter century in Pittsburgh sports. This week’s category is five best comebacks.

Few things in sports stir the soul like an epic comeback. America loves comeback stories. Hollywood lives for them.

I’m a sucker for ’em, too, and I still wonder if we were deprived one in that horrifying Steelers-Browns playoff game five years ago.

The Steelers, who trailed 28-0 after a quarter and 35-10 at the half, had pulled to within 35-23 with a 4th-and-1 at their 46 on the first play of the fourth quarter. Surely, they would not live in their fears. This was their best shot, and Mike Tomlin had often said that if you can’t get a yard, you’re not a championship team.

Advertise with us

He didn’t even try. The Steelers punted! I still think about it. I’m convinced the Browns would have folded at 35-30. It would have been legendary — and I know I’m not the only one captivated by incredible comebacks.

I could stumble across a cornhole game on ESPN, and if I see a big comeback brewing, I’m hooked.

Comeback memories stick. I was covering a game at Mountaineer Field in 2005 when Pat White took his first star turn, rallying West Virginia from a 24-7, fourth-quarter deficit to beat Louisville, 46-44, in triple-overtime. Unbelievable.

All of which brings us to the comeback category of our quarter-century series in Pittsburgh sports. Keep in mind that comebacks take many forms — a player returning from injury, illness or perhaps retirement (hint, hint), or a team digging out of a huge hole in a series, is just as viable as a team erasing an impossible in-game deficit.

The only point of contention here is what constitutes a bona fide in-game “comeback” and what doesn’t.

Advertise with us

Remember when Max Talbot scored that last-second goal in Detroit in Game 5 of the 2008 Stanley Cup Final, and the Penguins won in multiple overtimes? Iconic. But that’s not quite what I’m talking about. It wasn’t a large enough deficit. Same goes for the Steelers mounting a heroic two-minute drive to wipe out a brief Arizona lead in the Super Bowl.

Those fall into the amazing late-win category, not the huge-comeback category. I trust that you recognize the difference.

As ever, apologies are in order before we get to our top five.

To the Pirates team that wiped out an early 9-0 deficit against the Cincinnati Reds in 2023, I can only say I’m sorry. I know it was a franchise record. I feel horrible.

To the Pitt women’s basketball team that tied an NCAA record (regulation game) with a 32-point comeback against SMU last season, I apologize — and I wonder: How on earth did you outscore the Mustangs 28-0 in the third quarter? Incrinculent!

Advertise with us

I also regret to inform the Penguins of a few years ago, the team that trailed Columbus 4-0 in the second period and stormed back to win, that they did not make the cut.

Don’t worry, though, Penguins fans, you’ll be happy with the following list. A lot of you, in the media and outside of it, were quite upset with my list two weeks ago because you did not think Russell Martin’s home run off Johnny Cueto was a top-five Pittsburgh sports moment since 2000.

You’re out of your minds.

If you’re unable or unwilling to contextualize that event — the entire city frothing at the end of a 20-year losing streak and celebrating that moment and that game like it was Mardis Gras — I can’t help you. You’re probably letting your understandably blind rage for the Pirates obscure the significance. Retired Post-Gazette columnist Ron Cook, who covered sports for roughly 100 years, has often referred to that game as the single greatest event he covered.

Many of you claim it couldn’t have meant that much because it didn’t lead to a championship. I’m sorry. I didn’t know a moment had to lead to something else to be profoundly — and perhaps eternally — impactful.

Advertise with us

Please tell me more. A future topic in this series is best individual performances. Mario Lemieux’s comeback game in 2000 didn’t precipitate a title. May I still include it? Le’Veon Bell had a franchise-record 236 yards rushing and 298 total yards on a snowy day in Buffalo. Should I discount it because the season didn’t end in the Super Bowl?

Preposterous.

Anyway, the Steelers have had three 17-point comeback wins in regular season games since 2000 — including one where they trailed the Colts 24-7 with four minutes left in the third quarter — but none appear here. And I do not feel great about that.

I’m sure I have forgotten other comebacks, both individual and team-wise. One I will never forget was the Penguins climbing out of a two-games-to-none hole and winning four of five against the mighty Red Wings to capture the 2009 Stanley Cup. But if not for another amazing comeback along the way, that one never happens (see below).

I included both individual and team comebacks. One I weighed heavily was Sidney Crosby returning from a 10-month absence to torch the New York Islanders on Nov. 21, 2011.

Advertise with us

Crosby, 24, hadn’t played a game in 319 days. That’s why a Stanley Cup Final-sized fleet of seven TV trucks (normally two) found their way to the loading docks outside Consol Energy Center. No fewer than 251 media credentials were issued. All three major Canadian TV networks made the trip. CNN commissioned yours truly to cover the event.

The arena practically took off like a rocket ship when Crosby scored on a vintage backhander just 5 minutes, 24 seconds into the game. He finished with two goals and two assists in a 5-0 win.

Any other town, that might be No. 1. But the comebacks on this list? You had to be here to believe them.

As always, we’ll go five to one. Envelopes, please ...

5. James Conner outruns cancer (Sept. 3, 2016, Heinz Field).

I trekked down to the Pitt player tunnel for this moment. Next to me sat renowned Pittsburgh oncologist Dr. Stanley Marks. He was with about a dozen Hillman Cancer Center colleagues, all wearing symbolic surgical masks and “Conner's Corner” T-shirts.

Advertise with us

Soon enough, James Conner — who had endured 12 chemotherapy treatments (Hodgkin lymphoma) over six months and hadn’t carried a football in a real game in 364 days — came charging through. He let out a primal scream, raced through a cloud of smoke at the tunnel entrance with nearly 100 teammates behind him and proceeded to score twice in a 28-7 victory over Villanova. That memory lives forever.

Random memory: One person sitting near me was Kris Connelly, Conner’s primary nurse. This is what she said about him: “When he would walk into a room [at the hospital], there was always a smile on his face, a twinkle in his eye. He was so engaging with other patients, always very positive. Anyone who can withstand a multi-drug regimen and then go get on a treadmill? That just speaks to his competitive spirit. It's an honor to care for him.”

4. Max Talbot shushes the Flyers and their obnoxious fans (April 25, 2009, Wachovia Center)

The Penguins probably should have inscribed Daniel Carcillo’s name on the Stanley Cup. He’s the one who accepted Talbot’s challenge to fight early in the second period of Game 6, with the Penguins trailing 3-0. It looked for all the world like we were headed for a Game 7, but Carcillo couldn’t help himself.

As NBC analyst Eddie Olczyk chastised him, Carcillo beat the snot out of Talbot, who then made his iconic “Shhhhh” gesture to the Philly crowd.

“If you’re Dan Carcillo, there’s really no reason to engage,” Olczyk said as the fight raged. “You know the Flyers fans love it, but there’s no reason [to fight]. Do not give the Penguins any opportunity to build some momentum off a scrap.

Advertise with us

Sure enough, Ruslan Fedotenko scored 29 seconds later — the first of five unanswered goals in an all-time win.

Random memory: We won’t mention the part where Talbot eventually played for the Flyers. Rather, this: The Penguins brilliantly turned the Talbot “Shhhh” into a bobblehead they gave away this past Feb. 27 before a game against the Flyers. Unbelievably, history repeated itself, as the Penguins stormed back from a 3-0 second-period deficit to win 5-4 in overtime. The two guys who combined on the winner — Evgeni Malkin and Kris Letang — also played in the Talbot game 16 years earlier.

3. Tommy Gun buries the Browns (Jan. 5, 2003, Heinz Field)

The Steelers trailed 24-7 in the third quarter of this unusually wild wild card game and 33-21 with just over three minutes left in regulation. Tommy Maddox, a one-time John Elway protege, tossed three touchdown passes in the final 19 minutes to make it an extraordinary 36-33 win.

With snow falling like ticker tape, the Steelers needed a Dennis Northcutt drop to make it happen. Chris Fuamatu-Ma’afala's 3-yard touchdown run with 54 seconds secured what might have been the team’s most unlikely playoff win since the Immaculate Reception.

The Browns? Well, this just added to their litany of soul-crushing postseason losses.

Advertise with us

"I can't believe this,” linebacker Earl Little said. “I just can't believe this happened to us.”

I can.

Random memory: I have two. One, Steelers linebacker Kendrell Bell playing a phenomenal game on a bum ankle. He should always be remembered fondly here. He sure is by teammates and coaches. Two, I recall entering the locker room and offensive coordinator Mike Mularkey telling me that running backs coach Dick Hoak kicked him the leg and told him to call that delayed shotgun draw for Ma’afala.

2. Brian Giles slams Billy Wagner (July 28, 2001, PNC Park)

No matter what Lanny Frattare might say, there was plenty of doubt about it. The Houston Astros were going to win. That much was certain. FanGraphs later put the Pirates’ chance of winning at precisely 0%.

Here’s why: They trailed the Astros 8-2 with two out and nobody on in the bottom of the ninth. Only one team — the 1961 Red Sox (against the Washington Senators) — had ever overcome a bigger ninth-inning deficit. Boston trailed 12-5 — but at least they had a man on base with one out.

Advertise with us

Kevin Young began the miracle rally with a double. Pat Meares homered to make it 8-4. Pirates manager Lloyd McClendon then used Adam Hyzdu to pinch-hit for pitcher Omar Olivares. Hyzdu singled. Tike Redman walked. Jack Wilson singled in Hyzdu to make it 8-5.

That’s when Astros manager Larry Dierker summoned Wagner, one of the best closers of all-time. He proceeded to hit Jason Kendall in the leg. Up came Giles with the bases loaded, lefty on lefty, to face Wagner’s 100 mph heat.

Lanny?

This was the call: “And a one-ball pitch … Giles swings … drive to right field! Buccos win by way of a grand slam! Brian Giles with a line-drive grand slam into the right field seats! Count em — six, seven, eight, Giles makes nine! Brian Giles grand slam off Billy Wagner! Bucs win 9-8 and there was nooooooo doubt about it!”

Random memory: Has to be Giles raising his left fist in triumph, as if thanking the baseball gods, as he ran up the first-base line. The ball left the park in a split second, reminiscent of the kinds of home runs the great Dave Parker used to smash. Only nobody ever hit one quite like the one Giles hit that day.

Advertise with us

1 — Mario’s back! (Dec. 27, 2000, Mellon Arena)

We have all witnessed banner-raising ceremonies. On this night, the opposite happened: They lowered Mario Lemieux’s No. 66 from the rafters in a goosebump-inducing pregame ceremony — with Lemieux’s 4-year-old son, Austin, looking on — because he wasn’t retired anymore. He was back.

Like an apparition, Mario appeared, more than three years after hanging up his skates. Few comebacks in sports history — Michael Jordan’s return from baseball springs to mind — have generated as much enthusiasm. Lemieux hadn’t played a game in 44 months.

As always, he rose to the occasion. He assisted on a goal 33 seconds into the game — the place positively exploded — and scored a short time later on an assist from old pal Jaromir Jagr in a 5-0 victory over the Toronto Maple Leafs.

This was a pretty obvious choice for No. 1.

Random memory: I remember the bustle in the press box that night and public-address announcer John Barbero introducing “No. 66, Mario Lemieuuuuxxxxx” as Mario skated onto the ice. I also remember this: The ridiculous season Mario put together after eight weeks of, as Sports Illustrated writer Michael Farber put it, “sweating out three-plus years of cigars, fine French reds and golf.” The man had 76 points in 43 games. It was one of the top five individual seasons in hockey history. He finished second to Joe Sakic in Hart Trophy voting. He should have finished first.