I loved Justin Thomas' proposal from the U.S. Open on Tuesday — and I’m guessing a good number of the 4.3 million who have viewed his tweet share my opinion.

Thomas had been asked earlier what score an 18-handicapper might achieve at Oakmont, which the No. 1 player in the world, Scottie Scheffler, says “might be the hardest course we’ll play, ever.”

With so many people asking the pros what a recreational player would score, Thomas, the No. 5 player, responded with a challenge.

His post from Tuesday: “So much talk about ‘what would X handicap shoot at Oakmont’… Why don’t we find a way to make it happen? Have a 5, 10, 18 whatever handicap play Monday after the @usopengolf. Back tees full rules of golf, and see what happens? May have to let a few groups thru and allow for 6-7 hours but I think we’re all here for it, no??”

Advertise with us

Yes!

In fact, I was there for it, kind of, two months ago, when I was invited to play Oakmont. Myself and radio partner Bob Pompeani (he had the connection, of course) joined Oakmont member Greg Sipos to play 18 holes on a course on which legendary golf writer Charles Price said, “a player can have the time of his life — or spend four hours of torture.”

Bob Pompeani (left) and Joe Starkey at Oakmont Country Club before a high-scoring round. (Courtesy of Bob Pompeani)

I dabbled in both, mostly the former.

First, a few caveats. We played from the white tees, not the back tees. And that’s a BIG difference. Like, 1,157 yards worth of difference. In some cases, the back tee seemed to be a football field away from where we stood.

Also, I only took up golf four years ago and am currently in crisis. I had a 16.3 handicap on this day one year ago but subsequently succumbed to Steve Blass Disease. The difference is that when Blass, the heroic Pirates pitcher, lost his control in the 1970’s, he had already accomplished great things.

Advertise with us

I had accomplished nothing besides a career-best 83 at Cranberry-Highlands. And then I forgot how to play. I am currently unable to use a driver because I can no longer get the ball airborne with it. I hit more grounders than Ke’Bryan Hayes. I arrived at Oakmont a broken man, a 20-handicap, but still beyond thrilled for the opportunity to test my “skills.”

I then proceeded to score more touchdowns than the Steelers on opening drives last season — three straight 7’s to open my day. But I also got to walk across the iconic bridge over the Turnpike. I doffed my cap to an imaginary crowd as I crossed.

And of course I stopped for a photo at the magnificent Church Pews bunker (109 yards long, 42 yards wide, 3 feet tall, made with 550 tons of sand) between the third and fourth fairways. It was probably the only bunker I didn’t hit all day.

Post-Gazette columnist Joe Starkey hits out of Oakmont Country Club's Church Pews bunkers ahead of the 2025 U.S. Open. (Courtesy of Bob Pompeani)

That was followed by a TD with a two-point conversion before I finished the front 9 with three bogeys, another 7 and a horrific 9 on hole No. 9 — an evil par 5 (for members, anyway; par 4 for Thomas & Co.) where I pulled a rather remarkable hat trick. I wound up in a ditch, a bunker and rough that was taller than Victor Wembanyama.

The malevolent hole design and my frustrating journey toward it was offset by the majestic Oakmont clubhouse sitting right off the green. I was able to stop and breathe and appreciate where I was.

Advertise with us
The scorecard from Post-Gazette columnist Joe Starkey's round at Oakmont Country Club ahead of the 2025 U.S. Open. (Joe Starkey / Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

I realized how watching the U.S. Open will be a radically different experience this year because I actually walked in the very spots and took some of the very same shots the greatest players on earth will take over the next four days. (I also had the finest golf-course hot dog I’ve ever eaten at the turn. Something about the griddle effect; slightly burnt. I could have eaten 20 of them.)

And then I started playing better. Sort of. I melted down on No. 12, where the course literally brought me to my knees. I fell emerging uphill from yet another monstrous bunker (see photo above).

At that point, I was hoping the fourth member of our group, AI expert Brad Martineau, could somehow use his expertise to create a different version of me. But I only scored one touchdown on the back and had a respectable 50 — including a par on No. 13!

As Pomp is my witness, I hit a pitching wedge about 140 yards between two bunkers to the right of the hole, then chipped to within maybe 4 feet on what has been described as a “wildly sloping green.” With some help from Greg on the break (there wasn’t much, actually), I made the putt and celebrated like Tiger winning the Masters.

I followed that with more sixes than a Mario Lemieux jersey rack and finished with a 108. Probably a generous 108, as I was awarded a few putts that I might have missed.

Advertise with us

So yes, I guess you could say I took the Thomas challenge. I’ll give my new friend Greg the last word.

“I always tell my guests to enjoy the day,” he said, “and take your beating like a man.”