Welcome to Joe Starkey's mailbag, where the Post-Gazette columnist and 93.7 The Fan radio host answers your questions about sports, life, Lawrence McCutcheon and everything in between. If you want to ask Joe a question, tweet him at @JoeStarkey1 or email him at jstarkey@post-gazette.com. On to the questions ...
BB, @ayeechief: Can someone PLEASE for the love of god ask Shelton tomorrow why the hell Connor Joe is batting clean up?? Dude is batting .226 with 35 RBI’s in 360 AB’s. He’s had 5 RBI’s in the last 2 months. Like, what are we doing??
Starkey: Incredible and infuriating, isn’t it, Dr. BB? Here you have Paul Skenes making a valiant run for NL Rookie of the Year, with some serious competition in frontrunner Jackson Merrill, and the Pirates are putting out a lineup with Connor Joe as the cleanup guy?
Not surprisingly, they failed to score in a 4-0 loss. Yes, the opposing pitcher (Andre Pallante) was good. But that’s not the point. The point is giving yourself every opportunity to win a game with your ace on the mound, chasing a prestigious award. Every win is precious in that pursuit.
Not that this was anything new. Here are games, among Skenes’ 21 starts, that he either lost or got a no-decision:
• Monday: 6 innings, four hits, one run, seven Ks.
Read More
• July 29: 6 innings, one earned run, six Ks vs. Astros
• July 23: 8.1 innings, two runs, eight Ks vs. Cards
• June 29: 6 innings, one run, nine Ks vs. Braves
• June 23: 6 innings, one run, eight Ks vs. Rays
• June 11: 6.1 innings, no runs, eight Ks vs. Cards
• May 23: 6 innings, one run vs. Giants
I’m not blaming Joe for the loss, obviously. It’s the principle of the thing. Joe has done some good things here, but he is way closer to a DFA candidate than a cleanup hitter. You could picture a tanking team, one trying to improve its draft position, using him in the cleanup role. But the Pirates are allegedly trying to win.
It’s actually unfair to put Joe in the cleanup role, given his struggles of the past four months. These are his monthly batting averages since the end of May:
June: .169
July: .212
August: .175
September: .091
Now, if he was giving you Kyle Schwarber-like power, you could live with that. Instead, he is giving you Alika Williams-like power. In 179 at-bats across those four months, Joe has three home runs. He goes weeks at a time without an extra-base hit. He has eight RBIs since June 12th! I’d bet that Skenes, who was a very good college hitter, could give you better power across four months if you gave him a few weeks to ramp up.
Just mind-boggling.
Coach C, @BigTeeCee21: Bonjour, Monsieur Starkey: Sidney Crosby took the usual hometown discount to stay in Pittsburgh.Good news for us and it’s certainly commendable. But in terms of winning another Cup, do you think he made the right decision staying here? And could you have done it?
Starkey: A lot there, Dr. Tee, but let’s start with this: Sidney Crosby might be the most unselfish athlete in sports history. He is the 42nd-highest-paid player in the NHL and obviously is OK with that as long as he trusts that his team is trying to win and will use the money saved in the pursuit of winning.
I’m guessing he wasn’t thrilled with the failure to sign his longtime linemate, Jake Guentzel, but he clearly still has faith that GM Kyle Dubas is largely in win-now mode. Dubas better be — his best player just made a loud statement that he believes in this GM.
Could I have taken another discount like that? I doubt it! I can’t think of too many other people in sports history who have left more money on the table than Sid. I'd guess it's around $50 million. It’s unreal, actually. Tom Brady might be the only other one, and he had a very rich wife.
Obviously, Sid would have a better chance to win another Cup in other places, but he has prioritized his legacy — he clearly wants to be a one-city guy — and I happen to believe this roster is not nearly as bad as many make it out to be. They need certain players to play to their pedigree. Erik Karlsson (who is the sixth-highest paid player in the league), Tristan Jarry, Rickard Rakell, Kris Letang, Evgeni Malkin and Ryan Graves have a combined cap hit of nearly $40 million this season. They are being paid on pedigree. They need to live up to it, and if they do, the Penguins should be pretty good.
Listen, if the Penguins merely go from historically hideous to bad on the power play and in overtime, they will easily make the playoffs. If they become good or great at those aspects of the game, they will challenge for a division title.
You read it here first.
Barry Sherry, @TrekRef: Greetings Joe. I hope you’re doing well. Is the starting QB for the 2025 Pittsburgh Steelers currently on their roster?
Starkey: Thank you, Dr. Sherry. Yes, and I think his name is Justin Fields. I just happen to believe that Mike Tomlin is enamored with the possibilities there. He has long coveted a quarterback who can run around and make plays. It hasn’t always been pretty through two games, but I’m guessing Fields has done enough to keep Tomlin as infatuated with him as he was when Fields was entering the draft. I don’t think that’s going to change. By the way, Fields was 10-28 as the Bears starter. He’s 2-0 with the Steelers. That is an interesting little fact, not an editorial.
WATTBURGH, @TJWattBurgh: Any rationale behind what might be behind these terrible offensive performances across the league?
Starkey: You referenced the passing numbers put out by Steve Palazollo of “Check the Mic,” formerly of PFF, and they were eye-opening, Dr. Burgh:
“Passing touchdowns through two weeks (before MNF):
2019: 105
2020: 110
2021: 110
2022: 105
2023: 86
2024: 66”
Those are startling numbers. My first guess is that defensive coordinators have simply caught up and passed their offensive counterparts (again). It happens across sports. Coaches spend their lives trying to squelch offense because that’s the best way to win. That is why every league is constantly trying to find ways to increase offense. The NFL hasn’t been shy about changing rules to favor offense. I’m curious to see what their next move is because that is an astounding drop in TD passes.
Jay, @Crossland895: Bless you, Joe. The (Steelers) offense in the second half of that game put on a performance that Bishop Sycamore would’ve been embarrassed by. Is it more of a symptom of the head coaches conservative approach? Or do they just not have the talent to get it done? Should I be optimistic?
Starkey: Well, as we see from the graphic above, the Steelers aren’t alone, Dr. Jay. But that is no excuse for a second half in which they produced all of three first downs and 62 total yards. They made Matt Canada look like Bill Walsh for those 30 minutes. I do believe the idea was simply to not screw it up with the defense playing so well, but that kind of approach will eventually get you beat. I also think Justin Fields spent too much time in the pocket in the second half. He’s not a pocket kind of guy. Finally, I found it curious that offensive coordinator Arthur Smith went to Cordarrelle Patterson as his lead running back at a key point in the second half. That seemed like Najee time. Or maybe Jaylen time. But definitely not Cordarrelle time.
Angerman, @_Angerman_: The old adage of good pitching beats good hitting in mind: Does good DL play beat good OL play? I ask because my all-time DL of Bruce Smith, Mean Joe, Aaron Donald and Reggie White would be unblockable.
Starkey: Yes, it does, Dr. Man, and that is because defensive linemen are the superior athletes. We see that every week in the NFL, more and more. Offensive linemen just cannot hang with the best past rushers, and that is why they are allowed to get away with so much holding. You can’t call it every play.
Brian Bresnehan, @icecold_brez: Dr Starkey, never thought I would be a fan of Bill Belichick, but his appearances on the ManningCast are must watch TV. Is the ManningCast the best sports broadcast going right now? - Lawrence from Lawrenceville.
Starkey: Thank you Lawrence. And you are 100% correct. The Manning Cast is awesome. I watched it again Monday night. I don’t need all the X’s and O’s as I’m watching a football game, although those two, and often their guests, are quite capable of delivering on that front. I’d rather be entertained. Maybe more importantly, I don’t need a play-by-play guy telling me what’s happening. I’m watching the game! Belichick has been great. Never shy with an opinion. Totally different than his coaching persona.
Thomas W Listwak, @DeputyTDawg: Should Pitt go on a run, do they have the NIL resources to retain Holstein? Or to add weapons around him?
Starkey: Oh man, is that a great question, Dr. W. It has become like coaches — as soon as one starts having success anywhere but a blue-blood program, you can’t help but ask, will he move on?
Always remember, it was coaches who started the merry go-round in college sports. Making all kinds of promises to recruits, telling players to be loyal to one another, and then taking off before bowl games for whoever offered the most money. And then complaining when players started doing the same!
Quite a group, those guys.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.