Welcome to Joe Starkey’s mailbag, where the Post-Gazette columnist and 93.7 The Fan radio host answers your questions about sports, life, Lee Flowers and everything in between. If you want to ask Joe a question, tweet him @JoeStarkey1 or email him at jstarkey@post-gazette.com. On to the questions …
Chris G, @STAHPS_: What would you say to Steelers fans who think the only way back to the Super Bowl is to lose enough to get a Top 5 QB in the draft?
Starkey: I’d say they’re not crazy, Dr. G, but it depends on how deep a given draft might be — and it doesn’t appear as if this one is rife with 5-star studs.
I’d also say there are many ways to find a quarterback, and the quarterback carousel is always spinning. I have to laugh when I hear people talk about “succession plans” at the position. How many franchises, ever, have had such a thing during a star quarterback’s final years?
Might the Steelers find a quarterback already in the NFL, whose potential is yet untapped?
That’s possible, if not likely. I threw out some names to former Steelers offensive coordinator Todd Haley on 93.7 The Fan recently and wondered who stood out to him as possible candidates for the Steelers. I mentioned Jameis Winston, San Darnold, Nick Foles (even if he doesn’t fit our criterion) and Mitch Trubisky.
Read More
“Mitch Trubisky … it’s so important to put these guys in a position to succeed, and I don’t know that he was given that in Chicago,” Haley said. “He was a young quarterback to begin with, hadn’t played a lot (one year as a starter at North Carolina), but his size, his athletic ability, his ability to throw the football. You need to have a characteristic that allows you to survive while you learn to be a real quarterback. What I saw in the preseason with the Bills, I was pretty impressed. I mean, he looked like a different guy.”
I’ve used this space to endorse Trubisky, not because I believe he’s the definite answer but because I’m intrigued with the talent and the numbers he put up in Chicago (29-21 record, 64 touchdowns against a still-too-high 37 interceptions), despite working under Matt Nagy.
I asked Haley to elaborate.
“In Chicago, how they were making him play — I mean, no disrespect to any coaches. I would watch that tape. Kurt Warner and I would do a Zoom call and watch it and sometimes it didn’t make a lot of sense. And some of the positions they were putting him in just weren’t fair. On top of (that), being in Chicago … not a fun place to be as a young quarterback. I think Mitch has a chance. I just think he needs to be in the right place with the right coaches that are able to nurture him and allow him to grow and develop.”
The coaching issue is for another day, but I remain intrigued. Which is more than I could ever say for the possibility of starting Mason Rudolph.
Imagine being the alleged starter-in-waiting — the guy the Steelers put a “first-round grade” on — finally getting your chance and hearing your coach say “all options are on the table” for the position next season.
Have you heard anybody in the organization say, “Mason’s the guy now, obviously, and we can’t wait to ride with him.”
Me neither.
Steve G, @StG0331: Who is more likely to make the playoffs next year - the Steelers or the Pirates — assuming for the sake of simplifying the question that Mason Rudolph is the QB.
Starkey: The Steelers by a trillion miles, Dr. G. (and what’s with all the Dr. Gs today?). The Pirates have a real chance to lose 100 games again, although they are going to win the World Series in 2027.
Have you seen the Steelers’ schedule? I wouldn’t be the least bit surprised if they went 9-8 and snuck into the third wild card spot again. That’s about where they are as a franchise these days — and it’s more than good enough for many.
I always look at quarterbacks first when I analyze future schedules. This season, the Steelers figured to have nine games against elite quarterbacks, if you include Lamar Jackson in that category. They got lucky by missing Russell Wilson and Jackson (once). They were 2-5 in their other games against elite quarterbacks (Joe Burrow twice, Josh Allen, Justin Herbert, Patrick Mahomes, Aaron Rodgers and Jackson).
Next season, I see Burrow, Jackson, Allen and maybe Tom Brady. After that, I see a whole bunch of Cleveland, Carolina, Miami, New Orleans, Indy, Philly, Jets, Atlanta and New England, although Derek Carr and the Raiders could again be a problem (if the Steelers don’t trade for him).
Obviously, then, the Steelers could find their to way to around .500 — 17 teams won between seven and 10 games — and another blowout playoff loss.
I’ll bet you can’t wait.
Kurt Williams, @KurtWilliams66: Does Tomlin have too much power as a Head Coach? It appears that he has to be the smartest man in the room and wants pawns to be in the Coordinator positions. He needs to swallow his pride and bring in some fresh ideas from known names. I.e. Whisenhunt and Martindale.
Starkey: The interesting part of your question, Dr. Williams, is whether Tomlin prefers “pawns” as coordinators, as opposed to strong-minded outsiders with NFL reputations and different ideas. It’s a fair question. I’m hoping some of these defensive-coordinator candidates they are interviewing are actual possibilities.
Keith Butler just let it be known what was long suspected — that Tomlin has been the de facto defensive coordinator here for several years.
Tomlin’s defenses have been good at times and have produced some big numbers. Unfortunately, one of them is being the only team in NFL history to give up 40 or more points in three straight playoff games.
Nate Kanuch, @njkanuch: Is there any reason for Keith Butler not to be telling the truth? Does what he said change anything about how we should view the last few years of LeBeau’s tenure as the defense crumbled? Was it scheme, not age?
Starkey: It’s not like the Steelers haven’t had any good defenses lately, Dr. Kanuch. They did rank in the top six in total defense from 2017 through 2020. It’s just that in the biggest games they have failed miserably and their run defense hit bottom this season (and yes, one could point to injuries as a huge reason for that).
As to your question, I do believe the final years (let’s say, 2013-14) of LeBeau could be judged differently, though I also wonder when it was that Tomlin took over the play-calling.
Could it have been right after the 55-31 debacle against New England in 2013? If so, could you blame him?
Also note that LeBeau went on to a couple of unremarkable seasons as the Titans’ defensive coordinator before Mike Vrabel arrived.
Jeff Stoyanoff, @jeffgstoyanoff: What’s more important for the Steelers: offensive line or quarterback?
Starkey: I can find offensive linemen anywhere, Dr. Stoyanoff, even if the Steelers apparently can’t. Quarterbacks are a different story.
Latest Infatuation, @_exfoliant: Do the Steelers need another running back to spell Najee? Seems like the running game always stalled out whenever he wasn't there.
Starkey: It stalled plenty when he was in there, too, Dr. Latest, although it certainly wasn’t Najee’s fault. He made all kinds of yards after contact and had a fabulous rookie season. I happen to believe Benny Snell Jr. is fine as a backup, even if he put up some paltry numbers this season. But would I be opposed to bringing in somebody else? Absolutely not. Anthony McFarland hasn’t worked out, and Kalen Ballage, while one of my heroes, isn’t that guy, either.
Adam Morgante, @AdamMorgante: Would you like to see the NFL change its overtime rules? If so, what would you like the new format to be?
Starkey: Yes I would, Dr. Morgante, at least for the playoffs. Make it like every other sport on earth, where both teams get a chance in overtime no matter what. I hear the “just play defense” argument, and my response is, “Why should I have to play it first based on a coin flip?”
People also say the coin flip wasn’t the reason the Bills lost the other day — it was their inability to stop the Chiefs with 13 seconds left. My response: The coin flip had nothing to do with either the Bills failing to stop the Chiefs or the Chiefs failing to stop the Bills (twice in the final 2 minutes). It was a completely separate entity, independent of anything that had transpired in the previous 60 minutes.
I also hear all these people complaining about “gimmicky” overtimes in other sports. What is more gimmicky than FLIPPING A COIN?!?!?
And if you don’t think the flip matters that much, consider this: Eleven playoff games have gone to overtime under the current rules, and the coin-flip winner has won 10 of them — including seven on opening-drive touchdowns.
The first of those was engineered by one Tim Tebow (you might remember it). Among the quarterbacks who never received an overtime chance in those 11 games: Ben Roethlisberger, Patrick Mahomes, Drew Brees, Aaron Rodgers (twice) and Josh Allen.
Way to go, NFL!
Thank you, kiddies. Also, send me questions (tweet @JoeStarkey1 or email at jstarkey@post-gazette.com). And subscribe to our FREE daily all-sports newsletter, PG Sports Feed.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.