The Steelers allowed 41 points to the Los Angeles Chargers, 41 to Cincinnati, 36 to Minnesota, 36 to Kansas City and, most recently, 42 to Kansas City in the playoff loss. They had the worst run defense in the league. They gave up 229 rushing yards to then-winless Detroit, 198 to Cincinnati, 242 to Minnesota (176 in the first half alone), 201 to Cincinnati and 249 to Baltimore.
You should be happy Keith Butler retired as defensive coordinator.
Or maybe not.
Butler confirmed Saturday during an interview with the Post-Gazette what everyone long has believed:
Mike Tomlin calls all of the defensive signals.
“I would have liked to do them myself, sure I would,” Butler said. “I think everybody would. But Mike’s the head coach. He can do what he wants to do.”
Read More
You can’t fire Tomlin, right?
Of course you can’t.
But you can force Tomlin to turn over control of the defense to his next coordinator and become more of a CEO of the entire team.
At least you can do that if you are Art Rooney II.
It’s time. Tomlin’s way with the Steelers defense isn’t working. Yes, there were a few mitigating factors that sabotaged his defense this season. Stephon Tuitt’s yearlong absence and Tyson Alualu’s ankle injury early in the second game left Cam Heyward as a one-man defensive line. Devin Bush and Joe Schobert also were major disappointments.
But the Steelers’ defensive problems began long before this season. The team hasn’t won a postseason game in five years. It is 0-4 in its past four playoff games, giving up 42 points to Kansas City, 48 to Cleveland, 45 to Jacksonville and 36 to New England.
That’s embarrassing.
It is fine if Tomlin wants to continue with his belief and tradition of promoting from inside, as he did with Butler when Dick LeBeau wasn’t retained after the 2014 season. Senior defensive assistant/secondary coach Teryl Austin is a logical candidate to be the next coordinator, and many people around the Steelers believe he will get the job. He has experience as a coordinator with Detroit and Cincinnati.
“T.A. is a great coach,” Minkah Fitzpatrick said last week before heading into the off-season. “I’m not going to talk about him too much because I want him to stay in Pittsburgh and I know everyone is trying to pick [up] on him. His attention to detail. His way of approaching the game. The way he lets the players express themselves. I appreciate that.”
If Tomlin gives the job to Austin, he needs to allow Austin to do his thing. Sure, Tomlin will continue to have heavy input in the game plan. But he needs to allow Austin to call the defensive signals on game day. It’s hard to believe Austin would take the job without that assurance.
It’s also possible Tomlin could go outside for his next defensive coordinator. That might be a better way to go, actually. Fired Minnesota head coach Mike Zimmer was highly regarded as a defensive coordinator with Dallas, Atlanta and Cincinnati. Don “Wink” Martindale also is well-respected despite being fired by Baltimore last week in a surprising move. You don’t think Martindale would love to stick it to the Ravens if he was hired by the Steelers, do you?
One final thought about Butler:
People loved to ridicule the way he talked with his southern accent. Radio shows did bits about him and tried to predict how many times he would say “dadgumit” during an interview. Even Tomlin had a good laugh about that.
But Butler is a good man and was a really good coach. He did fine work with Steelers linebackers Joey Porter, James Farrior, Lawrence Timmons, LaMarr Woodley and James Harrison before being promoted to coordinator. He helped Bud Dupree and T.J. Watt significantly after adding outside linebackers responsibility to his coordinator duties in 2019. He even coaxed some production this season from Taco Charlton and Derrek Tuszka.
If anything, Tomlin underutilized Butler.
Tomlin can’t make that same mistake with his next coordinator.
Ron Cook: rcook@post-gazette.com and Twitter @RonCookPG. Ron Cook can be heard on the “Cook and Joe” show weekdays from 10 a.m. to 2 p.m. on 93.7 The Fan.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.