Welcome to Joe Starkey’s mailbag, where the Post-Gazette columnist and 93.7 The Fan radio host answers your questions about sports, life, Lee Flowers and everything in between. If you want to ask Joe a question, tweet him @JoeStarkey1 or email him at jstarkey@post-gazette.com. On to the questions …
Nick Comport, @Capn_Comport: Has the failure to plan for a future beyond Ben and continual overestimating of Mason Rudolph been the biggest mistake of the Colbert/Tomlin era?
Starkey: Good morning, Nick. And good question. But we won’t know the answer until we actually see who replaces Ben, right?
Clearly, the Steelers misevaluated Rudolph. Kevin Colbert said they had him graded as a first-round talent, and the minute he said it, it became clear Rudolph was going to be groomed as Ben’s eventual replacement.
Unless you’ve lost your mind, you cannot think that’s a good idea now. The Steelers can tell people behind the scenes they believe in Rudolph. That’s nice of them. The fact of the matter is they chose Duck Hodges over him for big games a few years back, and they chose a declining, 39-year-old Ben over him this year, still not deeming Rudolph ready to cash in on that “first-round” pedigree.
On Sunday, we saw what we have mostly seen from Rudolph: some good, some bad and precious few trips to the end zone. He threw a bunch of balloon balls on simple outs. He threw high-risk passes over the middle. He butchered an easy TD throw. He could have been intercepted five times (James Washington broke up one in the end zone, Detroit dropped one in overtime, etc.). He made some decent throws late. He showed some mobility and toughness.
Read More
Rudolph also had all day to throw against a terrible team and managed to lead his team to one touchdown. He’s a decent backup quarterback.
But I must ask: How many teams actually formulate and execute a long-term succession plan at quarterback? How many go from one franchise QB to the next in a smooth, well-thought-out transition?
Your question reminded me of Ryan Clark’s rant from earlier this season, when he labeled the Steelers’ quarterback situation “total organizational failure.”
“They needed that pick [from the Minkah Fitzpatrick trade] because they needed a succession plan for Ben Roethlisberger. And they didn’t [have one], and they still don’t,” Clark said. “The best teams are able to move right into the next quarterback. The best teams that can keep competing can do that.”
Really?
Which teams were able to move “right into the next quarterback” on account of meticulous planning, rather than by way of blind luck or total incompetence?
Precious few, I would say. Green Bay went from Brett Favre to Aaron Rodgers and have apparently planned for Jordan Love next. Who else ya got? Indianapolis went from Peyton Manning to Andrew Luck, but I’m pretty sure they didn’t plan Manning’s neck injury and sudden drop to 2-14.
The Chargers went from Philip Rivers to Justin Herbert, but I'm pretty sure the plan wasn’t to massively fail under Anthony Lynn, drop to 5-11 and basically get Lynn fired (a year later).
If the Steelers’ biggest failure is trying to win — and when they were 11-0 last season and Fitzpatrick was flourishing, I wasn’t hearing too many complaints about that trade — then it’s forgivable.
Meanwhile, quarterbacks can come from all kinds of places. Several will hit the open market, as always, next offseason, and several will be available beyond the top five picks of the draft. The Ravens got Lamar Jackson at the bottom of the first round. The Patriots found Mac Jones in the middle of the first. The Cowboys found Dak Prescott in the fourth.
The Bucs stumbled into Tom Brady — and who knows if a similar scenario with another star quarterback presents itself this offseason?
The Rams traded for Matthew Stafford (yes, I know, that might not be something to brag about after the past two weeks). The Colts traded for Carson Wentz, who is coming around nicely (17 TDs, 3 INTs, 98 passer rating).
Point is, it’s a little early to call the Ben succession situation a “total organizational failure.”
Let’s see what happens.
Bob Hogan, @TailgateGuruBob: Winning, scrapping, trying to stay in the fight is a badge of honor for the Steelers. But at what point does the organization look at what most of us see, recognize that the door for championships has closed, and that a near complete reset from top to bottom is necessary?
Starkey: Good morning, Dr. Hogan. And good question. I’m not with you that a total reset is necessary. First, they are in playoff position at the moment — although I would agree that the notion of them winning a championship in their current state seems far-fetched, to put it mildly.
However, they still have some young talent on both sides of the ball. They still have the makings of a very good defense, I would say, and have shown flashes of that amid gross ineptness this season.
I’m not nearly ready to scrap it and start over. Let’s see what happens with Ben the rest of the season and then the “succession plan.”
Yinzersaurus, @jbfrompgh: Who is in worse shape right now: the Penguins or the Steelers?
Starkey: Good morning, Yinzersaurus. And good question. The standings say the Penguins, at least at the moment. They are not in playoff position. The Steelers are.
The Penguins are also reeling because of injuries, COVID issues, etc. — the Steelers have issues on both fronts, as well — but I still believe they will make the playoffs. They are just three points back of the eighth-place team, New Jersey, 14 games into the season.
I actually believe both teams — Steelers and Penguins — will make the playoffs. Am I crazy?
Wait, did I answer your question?
If you meant it in a global sense, I would say the Penguins are in worse shape because they are surrounded by better teams in their conference. The reality is that the two franchises are in similar positions. They have faded from regular championship favorites to borderline playoff teams, in part because of star players getting older.
Manko, @MikeDaFicus: Given an unlimited number of tries, what do you think you could do in the fewest attempts: make a save in a shootout against prime Sidney Crosby or get a hit in a full at-bat with fielders against prime Nolan Ryan?
Starkey: Good morning, Michael. And good question. Sort of.
I think the obvious answer here is a shootout save. Eventually a shot would hit me. It might take 2,000 shots, but one would hit me.
Getting a hit off prime Nolan Ryan — with fielders, no less — would just never happen. Not 100 mph with a wicked curveball. I could stand there for a year, and I would not get a hit.
Ryan Knee, @Elbowuindagut: At this point, which is better, or maybe which is worse, the Steelers offense or the Steelers defense? It may be better to ask which one needs to improve more instead.
Starkey: Good morning, Ryan. And good question.
The reflexive answer would be the offense. It ranks 26th in points scored. The defense ranks eighth in points allowed. So the defense, I would say, has been the objectively better unit.
But what if we graded on a curve, and the question became: Which unit is performing worse based on expectations?
The defense has a real shot there, especially coming off a game in which it allowed 229 rushing yards to a team with a broken quarterback.
Nobody, @BigTeeCee21: I don’t like 3-on-3 hockey (Yes, I know. I’m in the minority.) But if the NHL wants to make it more interesting, I say treat the blue line like the half-court line in basketball: Once the puck crosses, you can’t carry it back over. I hate when they circle back. Thoughts?
Starkey: Good morning, Nobody. And good question. I like the way you think. The constant regrouping is bothersome to me, as well.
jon montag, @JonMontag: Was the tie yesterday the way to guarantee a .500 season? Asking for a friend.
Starkey: Good morning, Dr. Jon. And good question. Yes, it’s going to be tough to finish under .500 now. The Steelers would have to go 2-6 over the final eight games (of course, they do specialize in late-season collapses) to finish under .500.
Is it a big deal to you that neither Ben Roethlisberger nor Mike Tomlin has ever had a losing season?
It’s really not to me. What’s the difference between 7-9 and 8-8, when you get right down to it? This team might miss the playoffs for the third time in four years. It also might fail to win a playoff game for a fifth straight year, something that hasn't happened since the Bill Austin era (and early Chuck Noll years).
Who really cares about the difference between 7-9-1 and 8-8-1?
chadgiron, @chadgiron: Isn’t it true that Duck Hodges always was — and probably still is — better than Rudolph? Livelier arm. More mobile. Throws with better anticipation. And if so, why not bring him back?
Starkey: Good morning, chadgiron. And good question. I thought Duck was better than Mason two years ago, and so did Mike Tomlin. Why else would he have chosen Duck over Mason for a huge game against the Browns, or pulled Mason for Duck in a huge game against the Bengals? Or started Duck over a healthy Mason against the Bills?
That being said, Duck faded badly and was eventually replaced by Mason against the Jets. I think the Duck story pretty much played itself out. I would not bring him back, though I appreciate the thought.
Then again, are we sure Duck wouldn’t have beaten the Lions?
Thank you, kiddies. Also, send me questions (tweet @JoeStarkey1 or email at jstarkey@post-gazette.com). And subscribe to our FREE daily all-sports newsletter, PG Sports Feed.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.