Welcome to Joe Starkey’s mailbag, where the Post-Gazette columnist and 93.7 The Fan radio host answers your questions about sports, life, Lee Lacy and everything in between. If you want to ask Joe a question, tweet him @JoeStarkey1 or email him at jstarkey@post-gazette.com. On to the questions …

Bobby, @BuStA607: What’s your opinion on Gerrit Cole struggling since the crack down on Spider Tack? Do you think his success since leaving Pittsburgh is from cheating?

Starkey: I have many thoughts on this topic, Dr. Bob.

1 — Cole basically admitted to cheating when he did not answer a direct question posed to him less than a month ago: Have you used Spider Tack while pitching? Spider Tack is a super sticky paste. It is an illegal, and highly effective, way for pitchers to make the ball spin faster and become exponentially more difficult to square up.

Advertise with us

2 — If you’re part of the “What’s-the-big-deal-they’ve-been-doing-this-forever” crowd, I’m not going to try to convince you otherwise. I’ll let recently retired MLB reliever Jerry Blevins do that.

Blevins had a stellar career in which he went 30-13 with a 3.54 earned-run average and 508 strikeouts in 495 innings. His tweet, as the crackdown approached: “Pitchers used sunscreen & rosin every day (myself included) for control of the baseball. Other pitchers used foreign substances to enhance the spin rate. The old, ‘give an inch, take a mile.’ It went too far. This is why we can’t have nice things.”

3 — Cole was a very good pitcher for much of his time here. He was a legit Cy Young candidate in 2015, when he went 19-8. But he was by no means a dominant strikeout pitcher. Not once in his Pirates career did he record more strikeouts than innings pitched.

4 — Almost the minute he left for Houston, Cole not only became a dominant strikeout pitcher but one of the most dominant strikeout pitchers of all time. His 326 strikeouts two years ago were the most of the 21st century by anyone not named Randy Johnson. The only modern-day pitchers who ever recorded more were Johnson, Nolan Ryan and Sandy Koufax.

5 — Any rational being would look at that transformation and wonder, how did it happen? It reminds me in some ways of the Barry Bonds story. Bonds was great when he was in Pittsburgh — a better position player than Cole was a pitcher — but he wasn’t 73-home-run great. Something very strange happened with Bonds. Something very strange happened with Cole.

Advertise with us

6 — Now look: Cole’s numbers before and after MLB’s recent crackdown on pitcher substances is just a little eye-opening.

BEFORE: 2.31 ERA, .198 opponent batting average, .554 opponent OPS

AFTER: 6.46, .274, .884.

Small sample size, for sure, but if you’re asking me if I think his success since leaving Pittsburgh was from cheating — and you very literally asked me that — I’m leaning hard toward yes.

Yinzersaurus, @jbfrompgh: If you had to take a drink for every time a player’s name ended up in your mailbox this summer, who is giving you alcohol poisoning? (I’m guessing it started out as Jarry, but Bush is going to give him a run for his money).

Advertise with us

Starkey: You’re forgetting the guy who wears No. 7 for the Steelers, Dr. Yinzersaurus, but Jarry is a good call. I don’t know what to say about the Devin Bush situation, other than I watched part of the video he seemed to light-heartedly retweet — the one with a terrified cat falling several stories to its death (some have said it’s still alive but severely injured) — and was disgusted by it. Is there something I’m missing there? If his account was hacked, Bush has not said so.

To underscore your point, the next two questions:

Brandon Cleary, @BrandonCleary1: Does Devin Bush have CTE or is his account hacked?

Ryan Dischner@Dischmeister33: Is Devin Bush doing this nonsense on purpose in hopes of leaving the Steelers and pursuing a super bowl ring like ab did?

Starkey: I honestly have no idea what Bush is doing — but if you read the comments under the cat video, I’m not sure I’ve seen that type of anger directed at a Steelers player since the last days of A.B.

Advertise with us

Maybe somebody should take up Bush on the offer he tweeted: “Seriously pay me off. I’ll delete my page and all”

St. John Smythe, @StJohnSmythe6: We were told Kramer, Tucker, Newman, Craig, Keller, Glasnow, Polanco, etc. would be the next contender. What makes the next crop of players any different and why continue to trade actual major leaguers for a lottery ticket? I don’t have the room to cite 40 years of this not working.

Starkey: Somebody told you Will Craig would be part of the next contender? I do actually hear you, Dr. Smythe — and please tell me your nickname is “Conn” — when it comes to the perpetual rebuilding program, although it should be pointed out that it worked the last time they started from scratch (McCutchen, Walker, Alvarez, Marte, Cole, etc.), at least for a while.

The problem here has been identifying young talent and developing it, to the point where it can be replenished when needed. Neal Huntington did not do a good enough job of that, which is why when the first wave declined, he had nothing left.

Now it’s Ben Cherington’s turn. I’m willing to give him a chance. This is Phase I — accumulating young talent. I don’t blame you if you’ve lost patience for this kind of thing and don’t want to stick around for Phase 2 (which presumably is trying to win). I just don’t have an alternative for you. If you think they’re going to spend like the Los Angeles Dodgers, you’re out of luck.

Advertise with us

Tony Anastos, @TonyAnastos: Name the starting 8 position players and the number 1 starting pitcher for the opening day 2024 Pirates?

Starkey: This is a question better left for our beat writer, Jason Mackey, Dr. Anastos, and here is what he texted me (you’re really putting a crimp in my morning):

Mackey: “I think there’s probably a 12-15 player pool, but to say who exactly will start, it’s darn hard. In the mix, depending on development and who stays healthy: Hayes 3B, Gonzalez 2B, Cruz SS/OF, 1-1 this year, Castro INF (other than SS), Bae SS/2B/OF, Peguero SS, Reynolds CF, Smith-Njigba maybe Swaggerty, Hudson Head (prob too soon), Mason Martin all OF, catcher a question mark.”

I have no idea what that means, Dr. A. I’ll let you interpret it. He added that Quinn Priester would be the pitcher, in his humble opinion. ...

You know what? I’m not letting Mackey get away with this. I want a 2024 batting order right now (this should be an interesting text exchange) …

Advertise with us

Starkey text: “I’m not letting you get away with this. I would like a batting order for opening day 2024.”

Mackey text: “There’s no way. We don’t know the position of 1-1. We don’t know high school or college. Davis is here. Mayer is not. It’s a silly exercise.”

Starkey text: “Ty sir.”

I’m just the messenger, Tony, and cannot account for Mackey’s morning crankiness.

Nate Kanuch, @njkanuch: Best beard in Pirates’ history?

Advertise with us

Starkey: Great question, Dr. Kanuch. Dave Parker springs to mind.

Did you know a story has actually been written on this topic?

Mike Eros, @BigErosM: Will Crosby and Malkin win another cup together in Pittsburgh?

Starkey: No, although I wouldn’t rule it out. Maybe a 20% chance, Dr. Eros. Might need a goalie.

Matt H, @PGH_Matt724: Will any Pittsburgh team win a championship before 2050?

Advertise with us

Starkey: This is getting increasingly morbid. The reflexive response is, “Yes, of course. Are you nuts?” But if Cleveland can go 52 years without a championship, we could certainly go 30 (or 29).

I’ll be sure to ask Mackey if he can give us the 2050 opening day lineup.

Thank you, kiddies. Also, send me questions (tweet @JoeStarkey1 or email at jstarkey@post-gazette.com). And subscribe to our FREE daily all-sports newsletter, PG Sports Feed.