I’m not really a Colin Cowherd guy, but I accidentally stumbled onto whatever channel he’s on around 2:30 p.m. Thursday — amazed there wasn’t a live NFL game to watch — and couldn’t help but wonder if what he said reflected wider-held opinions about the 11-0 Steelers.
I tend to believe so.
“Six of the 11 Pittsburgh wins are one-possession, and that is with the second-easiest schedule in the league and facing four backups (at quarterback),” Cowherd said. “I don’t care what their record is. ... This is not a Super Bowl team. Every bit of the skepticism on the Steelers is completely earned.”
He’s almost right about the last part. Some of the skepticism is earned, especially after whatever it was we witnessed Wednesday at Heinz Field, and especially now that Bud Dupree is lost for the season.
But let me ask you: Which team, at this particular moment, is beyond skepticism?
Cowherd seems to think it’s the Kansas City Chiefs.
Read More
“Kansas City’s doing virtually everything well,” he said.
I’m sorry. Could you repeat that?
Are we talking about the same Kansas City Chiefs who’ve allowed a combined 992 yards and 10 touchdown passes to the past three quarterbacks they’ve faced (Tom Brady, Teddy Bridgewater and Derek Carr)?
If by “everything,” Cowherd is including defense, notably pass defense, he’s either not watching or delusional. Or both. The Chiefs didn’t exactly harass those quarterbacks, either. They had three sacks.
The Steelers absolutely have the goods to spread the Chiefs and dice them up. Ben Roethlisberger can do what Carr and Bridgewater can do, and better. And despite a lousy game from his receivers Wednesday — I thought Diontae Johnson might change his name to Diontae Moncrief by halftime — the Steelers could present the Chiefs with some impossible matchups.
Listen, the Chiefs are 10-1. They’re the defending Super Bowl champs. They’re obviously very good. I would rate them a favorite over the Steelers if they played next Sunday. Or Tuesday. Or Friday morning. (And at this rate, who’d be surprised if the AFC title game is played at 7:30 on a Friday morning in Roger Goodell’s backyard?)
But the reason Kansas City deserves favorite status isn’t because “they do everything well.” It’s because of the miracle that is Patrick Mahomes. If anybody’s going to beat that guy, they better get the last shot. Mahomes is Michael Jordan. Last time he lost a big game, it was Brady, on the last shot, in the 2018 AFC championship.
Still, the Steelers, even without Dupree, have a better chance than any team to combat Mahomes. Doesn’t mean I think they’d beat him. Just means they’d have the best chance, with at least one star at every level of their defense, led by T.J. Watt, who has to be the frontrunner for NFL Defensive Player of the Year now that he ranks first in sacks and tackles for loss.
If Cowherd and who knows how many others use the Steelers’ schedule against them, what about Kansas City’s? Like the Steelers, the Chiefs have beaten only two teams currently in the playoff field: Buffalo and Tampa Bay (for the Steelers, it’s Tennessee and Cleveland).
The Steelers have won six one-score games, the Chiefs four — including three in row. Cowherd makes its sound as if they’re shredding people like the 2007 Patriots. Truth is, they’re just getting by.
It’s true, too, that the Steelers have feasted on several backup quarterbacks. But it’s not like the Chiefs are missing meals. Could I interest you in the Brian Hoyer bisque? How about the Sam Darnold souffle? This team twice made David Carr’s brother look like Dan Marino.
“Seattle now looks like they’re starting to put things together. Green Bay (too),” Cowherd said. “What is Pittsburgh doing well?”
They’re winning. That’s what. They’re turning teams over and terrorizing quarterbacks and finding ways to win, sometimes convincingly, sometimes against good teams — as when they won back-to-back road games against the 5-0 Titans and 5-1 Ravens.
And yet, the Steelers are unlike nearly all of the other 11 teams that have started 11-0 in the Super Bowl era. You don’t watch them and go, “Wow!” like you did with the ’85 Bears, the ’07 Patriots, even the 2011 Packers.
These Steelers are more like the 2015 Carolina Panthers, who started 14-0 but were not universally recognized as a juggernaut.
Indeed, this team has earned some of the skepticism coming its way.
But which team hasn’t?
Joe Starkey: jstarkey@post-gazette.com and Twitter @joestarkey1. Joe Starkey can be heard on the “Cook and Joe” show weekdays from 10 a.m. to 2 p.m. on 93.7 The Fan.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.