We all have two sides, sometimes extreme, and I’m no different.

The Mr. Negative in me hates the Patric Hornqvist-for-Mike-Matheson deal, which was completed Thursday afternoon with forward Colton Sceviour thrown in from Florida.

The Mr. Positive in me loves it, even if Hornqvist will always have a special place in Penguins lore.

The truth probably resides somewhere in between, as the man called “Horny” and his $5.3 million cap hit heads to Florida. (Hopefully somebody told him.)

Advertise with us

Let’s give each side its say …

Mr. Positive (he likes the deal): “Listen, I realize Mike Matheson isn’t Bobby Orr. In his current form, he might not even be Bobby Dollas. But he is undeniably an elite skater with untapped potential — and he’s only 26. The Penguins have some history rehabbing underachieving defensemen (Trevor Daley, Jamie Oleksiak, Justin Schultz, etc,), even if some relapsed later. Matheson’s a perfect project for Todd Reirden.

“Meanwhile, the Penguins are moving on from a rapidly aging, soon-to-be 34-year-old winger with a giant cap hit, a concussion history and a third-line pedigree. Do you really want to pay a third-liner $5.3 million for three more years? The Penguins have no desire to play Hornqvist in their top six. Panthers GM (and Pittsburgh native) Bill Zito was perfectly justified, too, in worrying about an insurance policy on Hornqvist’s contract. The concussions are a concern.

“As for the power play, Hornqvist’s net-front mojo seems to be waning. It just doesn’t rattle teams the way it used to. Hornqvist is like the Abominable Snowman after he lost his teeth. Love the guy, but, really, it’s time to move on.

“In Matheson you’re adding youth, speed and a legit puck lugger. Sure, a lot of his passes go to the other team. That’s where Reirden comes in. He’ll fix him. Take a guy like Matheson, put him in a different environment — a championship environment — build his confidence and watch him bloom. Joel Quenneville didn’t like him, but Daley didn’t flourish under Quenneville, either. For better or worse, Quenneville doesn’t love defensemen lugging the puck.

Advertise with us

“The more I talk, the more I adore this deal. The only way it’d be better is if Jack Johnson had been thrown in.”

Mr. Negative (he hates the deal): “You’ve lost it, snowflake. Every time the Penguins lose to an inferior playoff opponent, which is every year, Jim Rutherford rips his players for their lack of effort, energy and leadership. So you’re going to trade your most spirited, energetic player?

“Hornqvist has missed a few games, sure, but his goals- and points-per-game numbers remain steady. He can still play an important role on your third line and power play — and he’s irreplaceable in the room.

“I like Reirden as much as the next guy, but he’s not a magician. If they’re interested in producing the next Justin Schultz (early Penguins version), maybe they should bring back Sergei Gonchar and make him a consultant.

“Don’t blame Horny for this year’s playoff loss, even if the third line stunk. Those guys were saddled with a Johnson-Schultz 2.0 pairing. Mike Sullivan might as well have taped rocks to their feet and tossed them in the Mon.

Advertise with us

“Horny can still rattle goalies on the power play, by the way. I still can’t believe Sully complained after Game 1 of the Montreal series that his top unit needed a ‘net-front presence.’ Did he not watch the game? Hornqvist, relegated to the second unit, made the only goal happen by his 'net-front presence.' He is who he always was — a leader, a disturber, a 20-goal scorer and a playoff guy (if he’s put in the right situation).

“As for Matheson, please. He’s precisely the kind of player Sullivan hates — a reckless, risk-taking turnover machine who manages the puck like a live hand grenade. He’s the last thing the Penguins need.”

Thank you gentlemen. This is Mr. Man in the Middle here, and I must say, I’m leaning toward Mr. Negative's argument, with an important caveat: If the Penguins could maximize Matheson’s high-end skill over the final six years of his contract — and man, that contract has A-L-B-A-T-R-O-S-S written all over it — they’d look like geniuses.

Big if.

Joe Star­key: jstar­key@post-ga­zette.com and Twit­ter @jo­e­star­key1. Joe Star­key can be heard on the “Cook and Joe” show week­days from 10 a.m. to 2 p.m. on 93.7 The Fan.

Advertise with us