Welcome to Joe Starkey’s mailbag, where the Post-Gazette columnist and 93.7 The Fan radio host answers your questions about sports, life, Princell Brockenbrough and everything in between. If you want to ask Joe a question, tweet him @JoeStarkey1 or email him at jstarkey@post-gazette.com. On to the questions …
Au Contraire. We instead begin with our intergalactically popular Twitter Poll. I posted a two-hour poll Monday night, asking my loyal readers to grade the Jason Zucker trade (from the Penguins’ perspective, obviously). Precisely 1,000 people voted. Some of them were angry that we are already grading the trade. They are boring.
Envelopes, please, on the grades …
A: 36.8%
B: 50.4%
C: 7.8%
Read More
Worse: 5%
What we learned: Most people like the trade but maybe don’t love it. I’m in the same boat, for now. I do love the fact that Jim Rutherford is willing to do whatever it takes to get his man — and in this case that meant finding a goal scorer to help augment the loss of Jake Guentzel. Rutherford not only found one, he found one with term on his contract.
Doing “whatever it takes” might mean putting an extra year in the Brandon Tanev deal or delivering a top prospect and a first-round pick to Minnesota for Jason Zucker. Oftentimes, Rutherford is right. Sometimes, he is wrong. He has won two Stanley Cups in the past four years, three overall. Most GMs never win one.
And let’s quit pretending Rutherford has “mortgaged the future.” First-round picks guarantee nothing, especially late in the first round, and if you’re among those who suffer from prospect-derangement syndrome and find yourself up at night worried Calen Addison will one day win eight Norris trophies, take a pill. The rise of 22-year-old John Marino made Addison expendable, and the Penguins spent nothing on Marino (except a sixth-round pick).
Just pretend Marino is Addison, or vice versa, except Marino is already a really good NHL player and Addison isn’t.
In the meantime, Zucker is fast and can score goals in a variety of ways — one-timers, deflections, breakaways, etc. He draws penalties. He’s tough.
He also had some trouble, apparently, cashing in on golden chances with the Wild this season and sustained a broken leg in December. Plus, one never knows how a player will fit into a given system and how a given winger will mesh with Sidney Crosby’s game.
On balance, though, I like Zucker’s chances to succeed — and I love Rutherford’s fearlessness.
Paully D, @YaBoyPD: What year’s Pro Football Hall of Fame class had the most talent?
Starkey: I adore this question, Paully, and it sent me down a rabbit hole from which I nearly did not emerge.
I will rank the top-five classes of all time, excluding the first one (which was almost as bloated as this latest one, thanks to the special Centennial Class). I am including all members of the class, including coaches and executives ….
5. Class of 1985: Joe Namath, Pete Rozelle, O.J. Simpson, Roger Staubach, Frank Gatski. No offense to Frank Gatski, but if we played a game of “Which One Does Not Belong,” I’m pretty sure he’s the one.
4. Class of 1987: Larry Csonka, Len Dawson, Joe Greene, John Henry Johnson, Jim Langer, Don Maynard, Gene Upshaw. I’m probably biased, because I love Joe Greene and my dad loved Larry Csonka.
3. Class of 2009: Bob Hayes, Bruce Smith, Rod Woodson, Derrick Thomas, Randall McDaniel, Ralph Wilson. Dear God, look at the five athletes on the list — and yes, I absolutely include McDaniel, a guard, who, at 6-foot-4, 287 pounds, ran the 40 in 4.6 seconds and delivered a 37-inch vertical leap at the NFL Combine (and then made 12 straight Pro Bowls).
2. Class of 1971: Jim Brown, Vince Lombardi, Bill Hewitt, Frank (Bruiser) Kinard, Andy Robustelli, Y.A. Tittle. Maybe a little top-heavy, but that’s OK when the top comprises Jim Brown and Vince Lombardi.
1. Class of 1993: Walter Payton, Chuck Noll, Bill Walsh, Larry Little. Legends, legends everywhere. A combined 10-1 in Super Bowls. And I like the smaller classes.
Bobby Cole, @sniffafart: What’s one rule change in any major sport you’d love to see? Mine is offsides removed and make the two-line pass illegal again.
Starkey: Your Twitter handle is most unfortunate, Bobby, but I’ll answer anyway. I’d like to see a cap on timeouts in the final two minutes of NBA and college games. Each team gets one. If you don’t use your allotment before then, too bad. You are reduced to one. I can’t tell you how many games I watch and suddenly lose interest in during the final two minutes — no matter how riveting until then — because of all the timeouts. It’s maddening.
not a pirate, @RevD98: Are you jealous of Bob?
Starkey: Yes. Isn’t everyone?
the Pittsuation, @el_conundrum: Will the @pirates sweep one series this year? And if so, who and how?
Starkey: Yes, Mr. Pittsuation, they will sweep the Orioles April 10-12 at PNC Park. They will do so by scoring more runs than the Orioles on each of those nights.
Robert Covington, @GreenShelMagic: Joe, I find that I’m less angry when my teams lose now (in my late 30s) than I was in, say, my early 20s. Probably because I’m better able to recognize the importance of family, friends, health, etc., which I’m lucky to have. Do you agree?
Starkey: Love the question, Dr. Covington, and my fervent hope is that more people find some form of sports serenity in their 30s (if not sooner). Like, if you’re 38 and walking around Heinz Field’s parking lots drunk wearing a Steelers helmet on game days, you are probably not in a good place.
Other signs of unhealthy sports fandom past your 30th birthday:
• You feel an incessant need to protect Pittsburgh sports media personalities from all criticism — real or perceived — on social media.
• You spend more time tending to your fantasy team than your spiritual life.
• You become rageful when the Steelers fail to push a leather ball over a white line painted on a North Shore lawn.
FlyingMicrotonalBanana, @stm712: Will Mike Sullivan ever get the national recognition he deserves for the job he’s doing? Star-studded roster buries his truly brilliant coaching job IMO
Starkey: I hate to break this to you, Mr. FlyingMicrotonalBanana, but every single media outlet in North America — at least the ones I saw — had Sullivan first or second on their midseason Jack Adams Award list. The Professional Hockey Writers Association listed the candidates this way:
1. Mike Sullivan, Pittsburgh Penguins
2. John Tortorella, Columbus Blue Jackets
3. Craig Berube, St. Louis Blues
Also, be careful what you wish for, as the Jack Adams Award isn’t always a sign of good things to come. Look at the winners in the 2000s ….
2019: Barry Trotz, New York Islanders
2018: Gerard Gallant, Vegas Golden Knights
2017: John Tortorella, Columbus Blue Jackets
2016: Barry Trotz, Washington Capitals
2015: Bob Hartley, Calgary Flames
2014: Patrick Roy, Colorado Avalanche
2013: Paul MacLean, Ottawa Senators
2012: Ken Hitchcock, St. Louis Blues
2011: Dan Bylsma, Pittsburgh Penguins
2010: Dave Tippett, Phoenix Coyotes
2009: Claude Julien, Boston Bruins
2008: Bruce Boudreau, Washington Capitals
2007: Alain Vigneault, Vancouver Canucks
2006: Lindy Ruff, Buffalo Sabres
2004: John Tortorella, Tampa Bay Lightning
Accion Labs, @JobsAccion: You have to share close quarters with a Pittsburgh sports media personality for two weeks as you spread, proselytize even, the word of Pittsburgh Sports in neglected areas ... who is it?
Starkey: Jim Colony.
Ed Christy, @EdChristy1: From AZ, it looks like Pitt MBB attendance is still poor. Win and fans will be back or has it “passed” and will never be back?
Starkey: Win big games. Fans will return. I like the direction of this program under Jeff Capel. Assuming he sticks around, I predict the Pete will be packed again on a regular basis.
Christopher Burner: Do you take any meds for your quirks?
Starkey: Yes.
Thank you, kiddies. Also, send me questions (tweet @JoeStarkey1 or email at jstarkey@post-gazette.com). Sign up for our daily all-sports newsletter, PG Sports Feed, for free.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.