The instant Ben Roethlisberger was declared out for the season, any realistic Super Bowl hopes vanished.

In that respect, the Steelers' season was cooked.

But a .500 record, give or take a game, hardly seemed out of the question. It actually seemed like a great bet, given the forgiving schedule and the talent still available.

It’s not like the Steelers suddenly had an expansion team on their hands. They still had eight first-round picks starting on defense — four top-10 picks — and would shockingly add a ninth first-rounder in safety Minkah Fitzpatrick.

Advertise with us

They still had a highly pedigreed and highly paid offensive line. They still had a Pro Bowl wide receiver, a Pro Bowl running back and a backup quarterback who’d spent a year in the system and was, by the Steelers’ account, a first-round talent.

Meanwhile, they were about to play the pathetic Cincinnati Bengals and soon enough the pathetic Miami Dolphins, mixed in with the middling Los Angeles Chargers. What they didn’t know was they would also get a home game against Brian Hoyer.

All of that, combined with a second-half schedule sprinkled with Browns and Bengals and Jets and Cardinals, hardly screamed 4-12. More like anywhere from 7-9 to 9-7. Mediocrity. And their playoff chances would then depend on the quality of the rest of the bubble teams.

Well, the rest of the bubble teams stink. The Buffalo Bills lead the wild-card pack, for goodness sake. They barely beat Cincinnati and Miami, and their six wins are against teams with a cumulative record of 9-42.

The Steelers aren’t the only team to survive injury to a franchise quarterback, either. The New Orleans Saints, Carolina Panthers and Indianapolis Colts have all thrived. The Jacksonville Jaguars stayed plenty competitive.

Advertise with us

So yes, this is about where the Steelers should be. How they got here, however, is quite the story.

That was one wild first half.

A quick recap:

MVP: T.J. Watt. Legit candidate for NFL Defensive Player of the Year.

Biggest surprise: Bud Dupree, finally looking like a first-round draft pick — and pricing himself right out of town.

Advertise with us

Biggest disappointment: Donte Moncrief, by a wide margin. Steelers spent millions, only to see him forget how to catch a football.

Comeback player of the year: Chris Boswell, whose only miss was from 54 yards. Steelers look smart for sticking with him.

Best moment: Adam Vinatieri kick sails wide.

Worst moment: Roethlisberger grabs right elbow in pain.

Best play: Fitzpatrick goes 96 yards with a Hoyer pass (Honorable mention: Devin Bush somehow snags — we think — flying interception against the Ravens).

Advertise with us

Worst play: JuJu Smith-Schuster fumbles the Ravens game away.

Best hit: James Washington on Nik Needham at the goal line (You can still see the chalk outline of Needham at Heinz Field).

Worst hit: Earl Thomas on Mason Rudolph.

Best decisions

  • Trading a first-round pick for Fitzpatrick.
  • Wildcat against Bengals.
  • As it turned out, kicking off to the Ravens in overtime, though we’d be having a different discussion if Lamar Jackson had gone 75 yards down the right sideline two plays later.

Worst decision

Advertise with us
  • Wildcat against the Ravens.
  • Letting Rudolph go for a long walk after sustaining a head injury.
  • Keeping Ryan Switzer over Diontae Spencer.

And some special awards...

Al Riveron blindfold review award

Riveron overturns a non-call on the field and rewards Pete Carroll’s challenge with a critical interference penalty on Terrell Edmunds, who barely touched Tyler Lockett.

Gary Yapremian bad pass award

Jaylen Samuels, throwing a duck out of the Wildcat.

Advertise with us

Charlie Batch moment’s notice award

Duck Hodges. Who would have thought the Steelers would need him? And who would have thought he’d head straight from his victory on “Sunday Night Football” to Saskatchewan to go duck hunting with his dad?

Worst play call in history award

Dolphins decide cover zero an excellent idea on 3rd-and-20.

Most quotable

Advertise with us
  • “Please don’t ever ask me about him again.” — Ramon Foster, on Antonio Brown
  • “I don’t drive carts and things of that nature.” — Mike Tomlin, asked about the medical cart malfunction in the wake of Rudolph’s injury
  • “I mean, the whole week, even up in Canada, I was just like, ‘Man, I literally played an NFL game last Sunday and now this Sunday I’m shootin’ ducks.’ Honestly, still kind of just speechless.” — Devlin “Duck” Hodges
  • “It's good to be sitting at 4-4. I never thought I'd hear myself say that.” — Tomlin
  • “Hell, we lost our franchise quarterback. I know that’s not an excuse, but at the end of the day, it’s adversity.” — Maurkice Pouncey

Joe Star­key: jstar­key@post-ga­zette.com and Twit­ter @jo­e­star­key1. Joe Star­key can be heard on the “Cook and Joe” show week­days from 10 a.m. to 2 p.m. on 93.7 The Fan.