Welcome to Paul Zeise’s weekly mailbag, where the Post-Gazette columnist and 93.7 The Fan radio host answers your questions about sports, life and everything in between. You can also chat Steelers with Paul at noon Thursdays. If you want to ask a question, tweet him @PaulZeise or email him at pzeise@post-gazette.com. Let’s get started:
Jordan: Are you starting to think that James Conner may not be durable enough to be the Steelers long-term answer at running back?
Paul: I definitely think it is a fair question, but only framed like this: Should the Steelers commit to him with a long-term deal? I think that answer is still to be determined, but I would say not at this point. He hasn’t stayed healthy for an entire season. Teams are shying away from giving long-term deals to players at the running back position, in general. There is just too much uncertainty, and those guys take so many hits. Conner has been very productive when healthy, but as they say, a player’s best ability is availability, and he just hasn’t been available enough to warrant a long-term deal.
Greg: Given everything that has happened, the injuries, the defections, the early losses, is this shaping up to be Mike Tomlin’s best season as the Steelers coach? Could he win the NFL Coach of the Year award?
Paul: The season is only halfway over, and that’s important in this discussion. That being said, Tomlin has done a great job of keeping this team together and making sure they compete every week. That’s a good start. He has tried to adapt to life without Ben Roethlisberger and Antonio Brown, and the defense is playing at a high level. I think if the Steelers have a winning record, it would certainly qualify as one of his best seasons. If they have a winning record and make the playoffs, then it definitely would be his finest work. And if he gets to 10 wins and then wins a playoff game, it will be one of the best coaching jobs we’ve seen in quite some time.
Tracy: Do you hate Randy Fichtner’s offense as much as I do?
Read More
Paul: I don’t like the play-calling inside the red zone that I’ve seen so far. I also think he tries too hard to get cute with some of these formations and misdirection plays. But given what he has had to work with and all the adjustments he has had to make personnel-wise, I don’t think he has been as awful as some people think. He has done a reasonably good job of trying to match play-calling and game-planning to a young quarterback and a lot of new skill position players.
Marty: Now I read the Pirates are hiring a search firm to help with their general manager search? Given what a disaster that was when Pitt did it to find Kevin Stallings, is this a good idea? And why do they need a search firm? Is this a bad sign that maybe Travis Williams is in way over his head already?
Paul: This town is certainly scorned to the whole idea of a search firm, no doubt. The Kevin Stallings hiring debacle has forever made the idea of a search firm an evil one in these parts. But this is how organizations hire people these days. It is too big of a job to gather all the data and background information and vet candidates, so they hire these firms to do it all for them. And it also helps because it creates a buffer between the candidates and the organizations. It isn’t uncommon, and it isn’t a bad thing. In fact, I’d say the fact that they have hired one suggests Williams knows what he is doing.
Jason: The Pirates picked up Chris Archer’s option? C’mon, why would they do that? I thought this new regime was going to erase the mistakes of the old regime. This is a bad, bad sign.
Paul: They had no choice, that’s why. They are not going to get a better pitcher for the money they are going to pay Archer. Let me rephrase that — they are not going to get a pitcher with the same kind of upside as Archer. He hasn’t pitched well in recent years, but he is an experienced starter who has proven he can be successful. He is better than just about any option the Pirates could realistically pursue to fill in the back end of their rotation.
Thomas: Is the failed Donte Moncrief experiment a good enough reason to get rid of Colbert and Tomlin? He was a huge waste of money and time, just a very bad gamble.
Paul: It is a big failure. It is the kind of failure that could get a general manager fired if he had no track record of success. Colbert and Tomlin, though, have had plenty of success, so it isn’t going to be enough to put their job in jeopardy. They just better not make many more of those kinds of mistakes because they could add up and lead to their seats getting hot.
Joe: Do you think this is Matt Murray's last season with the Pens? He has slowly gone downhill the past few years.
Paul: This is an excellent question, and my gut would say no, he will be in Pittsburgh for the long term. He is a restricted free agent, so it will pretty much be up to the Penguins to decide if he is their goalie of the future. And there is no reason to believe he isn’t. The only issue will be how much money it will take to get the deal done. My guess is the Penguins will sign him to a deal worth about $8.5 million a year or so.
Chad: Is Booger McFarland the worst announcer in all of sports right now?
Paul: Why qualify it with “right now”? I think he may be the worst of all time. He just makes the “Monday Night Football” broadcasts not enjoyable to listen to.
Paul Zeise: pzeise@post-gazette.com and Twitter @PaulZeise






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.