It will be quite the news conference Monday introducing new Pirates president Travis Williams, won’t it?
Bob Nutting, perhaps the most reviled figure in the history of Pittsburgh sports, is finally expected to speak for his towering inferno of a franchise.
The Pirates burst into flames in July and the fire kept spreading, incinerating everything in sight, and the franchise caretaker never put himself in front of a camera to provide any kind of reassurance, to let everyone know it would be OK.
Instead, he chose to hide.
Monday, apparently, Nutting will take questions, and here is the only one that matters, as far as I’m concerned: “Bob, does Travis Williams have the authority to change general managers — and to do so as soon as he sees fit?”
It’s a yes-or-no question, the kind Nutting never seems to answer with a “yes” or a “no.” And there is only one right answer.
Read More
Sure, you could also ask, “Bob, given the billion-dollar sales of the Marlins and Royals, would you consider selling?” That might be interesting, if futile.
You could also lob this one out there: “Bob, will you significantly increase payroll next season?” But we all know how that'll go: Nutting will filibuster and ultimately provide the kind of answer sure to confuse and infuriate every single member of the Pirates’ dwindling fan base.
Do you remember what he said in spring training, when asked why payroll went down?
“We need to focus on the things we believe are controllable,” he said.
Then came the natural follow-up: “Is payroll not controllable?”
Then came the typically muddled answer, in which Bob again said Nutting: “I think payroll scale and range, broadly, is not controllable. We’re going to have certain resources that we have, and I think that that’s the reality of a marketplace.”
Maybe Williams’ first order of business should be to teach Nutting how to answer questions without pouring gasoline on fires.
But forget that. I want to know if Williams has the freedom to try to do what David Morehouse did for the Penguins. Namely, to identify the right person to run the sports side of the business and let that person do his job.
This isn’t all about payroll. Other franchises (Athletics, Rays) have proven that even under-funded teams can have repeated windows of winning.
Morehouse had the guts and foresight to hire Jim Rutherford as general manager. The move was not greeted kindly. Remember? The two Stanley Cups sure were, though. Morehouse chose the right guy.
Without a doubt, Williams knows his way around town. He spent years running the Penguins’ day-to-day business operations and reporting to Morehouse, so he already has relationships with the city’s movers and shakers, for whatever that is worth.
He will undoubtedly have more power than at his previous two stops, including with the New York Islanders, where Lou Lamoriello’s presence looms large.
Also certain: Williams will arrive with eyes wide open. He raised his family here. He can’t help but have a feel for the rage of a typical Pirates fan. He has to know, too, that his budget will be about the size of a rosin bag.
Part of his job, clearly, will be running interference for Nutting; to somehow spin everything positively. And that will be nigh impossible with Huntington around.
It’s hard to believe Williams would have taken the job without the authority to change GMs, but we need to hear that from Nutting.
The prudent move, from this vantage point, would be to hire a new GM as soon as possible. That would give the new guy freedom to choose a manager and set about the critical task of offseason roster building.
Also, let the new GM assemble his staff and begin preparations for next year’s draft. Surely, you can’t allow Huntington to preside over another draft. You might as well re-sign Lonnie Chisenhall.
Williams should have a working list of GM candidates already formed, and a list of interview questions for those people.
Such as:
- What are Tampa Bay and Oakland doing that this franchise is not?
- What happened with Gerrit Cole, Charlie Morton and Tyler Glasnow that didn’t happen here? How do we bridge the gap in pitching development?
I always viewed Clint Hurdle, Frank Coonelly and Huntington as a single entity. A triumvirate. They did some wonderful work earlier this decade. Now is the time to make a total break.
Against all odds, the Pirates could actually create some momentum and positive feeling this offseason, setting this franchise on a new path.
But only if Bob Nutting has the right answer.
Should be quite the day.
Joe Starkey: jstarkey@post-gazette.com and Twitter @joestarkey1. Joe Starkey can be heard on the “Cook and Joe” show weekdays from 10 a.m. to 2 p.m. on 93.7 The Fan.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.