Let’s rewind to March 27, the eve of the Pirates’ opener in Cincinnati. I will tell you all the bad things in store for this team. You will tell me its record at the 40-game mark.
Me first …
• Jameson Taillon will pitch below expectations and be shut down May 4, destined for the 60-day injured list.
• Corey Dickerson will start three games, pinch hit in one and miss the other 36.
• Jung Ho Kang will hit .133 in 31 games before going to the injured list.
• Chris Archer will miss multiple starts with a bad thumb and post a 5.58 ERA.
Read More
• Keone Kela will be limited to 11⅔ innings and have a 4.63 ERA.
• Starling Marte will hit .203 in the first 17 games and then miss nine because of injury.
• Francisco Cervelli will hit .179 with four extra-base hits.
• Kyle Crick will miss nine games.
• Gregory Polanco will miss 23 games (fewer than projected, actually).
• Richard Rodriguez will give up seven home runs in 18⅔ innings (the bright spot could be him getting invited to pitch to Josh Bell at the Home Run Derby).
• Lonnie Chisenhall will exist as nothing more than a figment of our imaginations.
• Nick Burdi will establish himself as an electric late-inning option only to crumple in pain against Arizona on April 23 and head to the long-term injured list.
• The catchers will combine to hit .176 (second worst in the National League) with one home run.
• The shortstops will combine to hit .213 (third worst in the NL) with two home runs.
• The third basemen will combine to hit .192 (second worst) with four home runs.
• The bullpen will disintegrate, blowing seven leads when leading after six innings, four when leading after seven.
• The club’s run differential will be minus-47, second-worst in the NL and fifth-worst in all of baseball. It will lose games by scores of 17-4, 14-1, 12-4, 10-0, 11-2, 9-3 — and fittingly, 11-1 in the season’s 40th game.
OK, your turn: What’s the record gonna be after 40 games —11-29? 13-27? 15-25? Be more optimistic. 17-23?
Wrong, wrong, wrong and wrong.
The Pirates, believe it or not my friend, are 21-19. Not exactly a 2001 Seattle Mariners pace. Also nothing short of a miracle.
This team has stayed afloat on account of some intermittently excellent starting pitching, some timely hits, a lights-out closer, a few major surprises (Jordan Lyles, Melky Cabrera) and Josh Freakin’ Bell, who is so hot he triggers smoke alarms every time he enters a clubhouse. He's a legitimate MVP candidate a quarter of the way into the season.
Sprinkle all of the above — the good and the bad — with a touch of joy, and you have the 2019 Pirates. They’re a fun team to watch, a team that clearly enjoys playing together. And a team whose immediate future could go one of two ways …
• South, on account of presumed ace Taillon missing so much time and the run differential proving the Pirates to have been more lucky than anything else so far.
• North, on account of reinforcements such as Dickerson arriving and individual performances inevitably improving (paging a Mr. Cervelli).
Or maybe they stay right here all year, hovering around .500.
The sobering reality is that even if the Pirates start winning more, they remain mired in the best division in baseball.
Going into Wednesday’s games, NL Central teams had four of the best six records in the National League. It was the only division to feature four winning teams last season. It’s the only division with four winning teams this season. Even the last-place Cincinnati Reds were plus-28 in run differential with the third-best rotation (based on ERA) in the NL.
The Pirates could win 90 games and still finish fourth. Ninety-four would have gotten you third place in this division last year. It’s gonna be brutal again.
You know what, though? This team looks like it wants to stick around for a bit.
All of that in mind, a quick peek at the first quarter:
MVP: Josh Bell. Stargell-like thus far.
Runner-up: Felipe Vazquez. Been pretty much perfect.
Biggest surprise: Jordan Lyles. How did this happen?
Runner-up: Melky Cabrera. How did this happen?
Biggest disappointment: Jung Ho Kang. Completely lost.
Runner-up: Keone Kela. Partially lost.
Best moment: Starling Marte home run beats Oakland in 13th.
Runner-up: Cole Tucker smashes home run in MLB debut.
Worst moment: Burdi goes down in agony. Now dealing with nerve damage in his arm.
Runner-up: Hunter Pence smashes tying, pinch-hit grand slam off Michael Feliz as the Pirates blow another late lead.
Joe Starkey: jstarkey@post-gazette.com and Twitter @joestarkey1. Joe Starkey can be heard on the “Cook and Joe” show weekdays from 10 a.m. to 2 p.m. on 93.7 The Fan.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.