Welcome to Joe Starkey’s mailbag, where the Post-Gazette columnist and 93.7 The Fan radio host answers your questions about sports, life, Lonnie Smith and everything in between. If you want to ask Joe a question, tweet him @JoeStarkey1 or email him at jstarkey@post-gazette.com. On to the questions …

Steve Small, @SteverS813: What should the @Pirates do as far as a starter now that Taillon is on the 60-day DL? Sign a FA or bring Keller up?

Starkey: I know what they shouldn’t do, Mr. Small. They shouldn’t let Nick Kingham or Steven Brault near the mound again, certainly not in a starting role. Their combined ERA is now 16.66 (yes, I have the decimal point in the right place).

In four emergency starts, Brault and Kingham have combined to throw 15⅔ innings and surrender 24 hits, 17 runs, nine walks and five home runs.

Advertise with us

Where is JB Shuck when you need him?.

The Pirates cannot in good conscience allow either to make another start. It simply wouldn’t be fair to the rest of the team. This club has somehow scrapped its way to a 20-18 record. It deserves better.

Chris Archer is scheduled to return to the rotation Wednesday, so that leaves one spot. I would literally use anyone available, in the majors or at Class AAA Indianapolis.

Actually, I would sign free agent Dallas Keuchel, but he is tied to draft-pick compensation until after the June 2 draft, and then he would cost, you know, money.

In the meantime, the options aren’t exactly plentiful. Bill Brink wrote about them today. The obvious one would be top prospect Mitch Keller, who has a 3.97 ERA at Class AAA Indy with 42 strikeouts in 34 innings.

Advertise with us

However, there are issues of service time (which would mean a June call-up), the fact Keller is working on a slider (work on it here), and the fact he hasn’t been all that great. He went just three innings in his past start, allowing three runs and three walks (so I guess he’d fit right in!).

The rest of the Indy rotation doesn’t exactly sound like the Class AAA version of the ’97 Atlanta Braves. Brink writes, “In addition to Keller, Indy’s rotation includes Eduardo Vera (5.35 ERA in his first Class AAA exposure), Alex McRae (5.40, though he’s been much better in his past two starts), Rookie Davis (6.30 ERA) and Dario Agrazal, who just reached Triple-A at the end of April. None of them, besides Keller, are on the 40-man roster. JT Brubaker is hurt. Brandon Waddell is a reliever now.”

OK, then use Brandon Knight. Or JT Snow. Or Hal McRae. Use Chris Stratton (even if he was beyond shaky in five starts with the Angels). See if Francisco Liriano can give you four innings. See if Brink will come out of the press box.

Anyone, and anything, is preferable to what has transpired over the past week.

Slim Charles, @SlimCha94465598: Why do the Penguins get a free pass (nearly) when they underachieve as opposed to the Steelers? Race? Local media’s good relationship with the players and team? Anything else?

Advertise with us

Starkey: ’Cause they won two Stanley Cups in four years?

Also, they don’t get a free pass. Not here. Their playoff exit was a massive embarrassment. Everyone was culpable, including the coach and GM.

Also, “local media” isn’t a single entity. It is several different personalities, many different outlets. Each with very different takes on and relationships to the Penguins. I can’t speak for others.

Nathan Kanuch, @njkanuch: Will Josh Bell’s career in Pittsburgh be seen as a success if he puts up the same numbers over the same period of time as Brian Giles did while here?

Starkey: You mean if he hits .308 with a 1.018 OPS, 165 home runs and 506 RBIs in five years? Yeah, I think any team in baseball history would take that from any player. The only issue there would be just five years. The Pirates will need to have Bell longer than that.

Advertise with us

By the way, I haven’t done an in-depth study, but if any Pirate ever had a better five-year offensive stretch than Giles, I’d love to see the proof.

Matt dicicco, @DiciccoMatt: What is your most prized sports memorabilia item?

Starkey: A piece of Three Rivers Stadium turf, given to me by my friend “The Maestro” (you might remember him from the early days of the radio station). One of my most cherished sports memories is making a pilgrimage from Buffalo to Pittsburgh with my dad in the late 1970s to see the Pirates.

Ian. Moran, @IMHockeyskills: If you could form a band with any former Pittsburgh athletes who would you choose? And would you let me sing?

Starkey: Good morning, Ian. Yes, of course you can sing. I just don’t want Jagr involved in this, in any way, shape or form. I’m sure you understand.

Advertise with us

Lead singer: Ian Moran

Backup singer: Jiri Slegr

Drums: Kasparaitis

Lead guitar: Steven Brault

Backup guitar: Jerricho Cotchery (he took guitar lessons in Mt. Lebanon while he was here, so he must be pretty good by now)

Advertise with us

Bass: Troy Polamalu

Keyboard: Lastings Milledge

What should we call ourselves?

Rick Gay, @rickgaygolf: PGA Championship pick? Tiger, Brooks, Francisco?

Starkey: Cervelli? If it involves hitting a ball, I’ll take Tiger or Brooks.

Advertise with us

Dick Flinnga, @BigHate1981: If you could travel back in time to one sporting event, what game would that be?

Starkey: Game 7, 1960 World Series.

Connie McGinley, @StanceLey: Of all the assignments you’ve had as a sportscaster which fan base impressed you the most?

Starkey: Great question, Connie. Probably the Montreal hockey crowd. There’s just a certain buzz in the air, a feeling of all the hockey history in that city. A sacredness to it all.

As a bonus, the hot dogs on toast in Montreal are absolutely incredible. Colby Armstrong once told me players would leave the locker room early after games so they could stash a half-dozen of them for the ride home.

Thank you, kiddies. Send me questions (tweet @JoeStarkey1 or email at jstarkey@post-gazette.com).