Welcome to Joe Starkey’s mailbag, where the Post-Gazette columnist and 93.7 The Fan radio host answers your questions about sports, life, former Alcorn State star Larry Smith (aka “Mr. Mean”) and everything in between. If you want to ask Joe a question, tweet him @JoeStarkey1 or email him at jstarkey@post-gazette.com. On to the questions …

Zach Hough, @Hoagie7187: How smart do you feel that you picked Glasnow to win the Cy Young and he is putting up the numbers that he is this season?

Starkey: I feel very smart, and thank you for asking, Mr. Hoagie.

I actually made that prediction half-kiddingly on our “Cook & Joe” season preview show, only because I didn’t want to make yet another obvious pick. That said, I spoke in-person with Glasnow late last season in Tampa and saw a difference in his demeanor. He seemed more relaxed, more confident. He didn’t have that wide-eyed look. And his numbers were improving rapidly.

Advertise with us

Glasnow spoke of that difference in demeanor and why it came about. He was not critical of the Pirates. He was just complimentary of the Rays.

“I’m able to just go out and pitch instead of thinking why I feel so weird mechanically,” Glasnow said. “[In Pittsburgh] I kind of lost who I was. At some point, the confidence was gone.”

Hearing that the Rays thought of him as a starter — one they were willing to stick with through ups and downs — made a huge impression immediately.

“I was like, ‘OK, cool, you guys believe in me,’” he said.

Did I think he’d be 6-0 with a 1.47 ERA, 46 strikeouts and seven walks in 43 innings? Not exactly. But looking at his work late last season in Tampa, I thought he would have a very good year.

Advertise with us

In his first month there, Glasnow had a 3.23 ERA, 38 strikeouts and 10 walks in just over 30 innings. A blowup start in Toronto (two-thirds of an inning, seven earned runs) wrecked his overall numbers, but the reality is that most of his starts were good — including the start after Toronto when he went seven innings and allowed two earned runs against Corey Kluber and the Cleveland Indians.

Glasnow spoke of trusting his fastball high in the zone more in Tampa and using his changeup — a pitch he “never” used in Pittsburgh.

“I want to be a starter, so I need to have another pitch,” he said.

All of which raises the question of whether the Pirates handled Glasnow properly. Maybe a simple change of scenery did the trick. Or maybe it was something more. Clint Hurdle spoke the truth the other day when he said the Pirates should probably evaluate whether they missed something with Glasnow.

The trade — no matter what any of us thought at the time — is careening toward disaster. Especially if Austin Meadows continues raking when he returns to the lineup.

Advertise with us

Steve G, @STG0331: It’s two months from now ... All Pirates outfielders are fully healthy and they are in real contention for the division. Who should the regular three outfielders be (based on what we know right now) and who should they be considering moving at the deadline for another piece?

Starkey: This will become the equivalent of the “Who should play when all the Penguins defensemen are healthy?” question, so I congratulate you there, Mr. Steve.

If they are indeed in contention and if Bryan Reynolds (the Tyler Glasnow of hitters so far this season) helps put them there, he should play. I don’t care who sits. Not that I expect him to continue hitting .405.

George K, @GeorgeK67: Why is Pittsburgh media on board with trading Malkin and not going after Rutherford for abandoning what made the Pens successful in 2016 and 2017— team speed. He turned them into a slow physical team with Johnson and Gudbranson and Wilson over Hags, Sheary etc.

Starkey: “Pittsburgh media” is not a single, like-thinking entity, Mr. George. I’m not on board with trading Malkin, though I understand the logic. I believe he is a legacy Penguin whose worst season (this one, in many ways) still has him at over a point a game. Just last season, he was arguably the team’s best player and had 98 points. He’ll be a star again.

Advertise with us

By the way, “Pittsburgh media” isn’t trying to run Malkin out of town. They didn’t make up any trade rumors. The Penguins themselves (Rutherford, specifically) created this story. The story being that Malkin is not untouchable in trade talks.

BIGKAT, @CKinnard4: Should the NFL support the XFL in creating a developmental program for UDFA and practice squad players? With the NFL being a year-round league, is it possible?

Starkey: I tried for the longest time to care about this question, BIGKAT. I never got there.

G. Alan, @JTown50: If Tucker hits around .200, do you keep him up to work through and get experience or send him down to boost his confidence?

Starkey: Cole Tucker doesn’t strike me as a guy who loses confidence too easily, Dr. @JTown50. He has scuffled at the plate, but it’s not like Erik Gonzalez was Cal Ripken Jr.

Advertise with us

What’s more, this is a real small sample size, as they say (and could Gene Collier please include “sample size” in this year’s Trite Trophy column?). It’s only 48 at-bats. He goes 3-for-4 Tuesday, and he’s hitting .254.

Peter F., @petefrompitt: Cole Tucker has two first names. Who are the best athletes of all time — either Pittsburgh or in general — with two first names?

Starkey: Let’s stick with Pittsburgh, and let’s say you have to be a fairly noteworthy player. I will name several and also list the name that comes to mind based on the last name that is actually a first name. Or something.

Just follow along. You’ll get it.

Start with Dave and Willie Parker (Stevenson), Franco Harris (Barton) and Hines Ward (Cleaver), shall we Mr. @petefrompitt?

Advertise with us

Then let’s go with Mike Webster (Slaughter), James Harrison (Ford), Greg Lloyd (Bridges), Heath Miller (Lite), Ike Taylor (Swift), Andy Russell (Erxleben), Larry Murphy (Brown), John Cullen (Bryant), Bob “Battleship” Kelly (Stouffer), James Neal (Huntington), Matt Murray (Hamilton), Jason Kendall (Simmons), Al Oliver (Onion), Larry Fitzgerald (Touissant) and Aaron Donald (Sutherland).

Thank you.

And thank you, kiddies. Send me questions (tweet @JoeStarkey1 or email at jstarkey@post-gazette.com) for next week’s mailbag.