Welcome to Joe Starkey’s mailbag, where the Post-Gazette columnist and 93.7 The Fan radio host answers your questions about sports, life, former Alcorn State star Larry Smith (aka “Mr. Mean”) and everything in between. If you want to ask Joe a question, tweet him @JoeStarkey1 or email him at jstarkey@post-gazette.com. On to the questions …

Just1Opinion, @ThePoint_iswhat: How bad is this going to get for the Buccos? I know they have injuries, but is this going to get better?

Chris Hawthorne, @Hawthornee: Which team is the real Pirates team? The 12-6 team or the 12-14 team?

Starkey: You mean the 12-6 team or the 0-8 team, right Mr. @Hawthornee? Quite clearly, it’s somewhere in between. And hello to you, as well, Mr. Just1Opinion.

Advertise with us

Listen, I had the fighting JB Shucks pegged for 83 wins. A few weeks ago, I began to wonder if I was low. Now I wonder if I was high (maybe literally).

So let’s analyze this soberly.

First, the Pirates have endured a devastating string of injuries. That’s not what anybody wants to hear. It’s just true. They have been mostly without a Gold Glove left fielder who hit .300 last season. Right fielder Gregory Polanco — among the more productive outfielders in the National League last season — has missed most of the year. Starling Marte was injured. I’m beginning to wonder if Lonnie Chisenhall actually exists. Nick Burdi was largely lights-out before he was injured. Now Chris Archer is out, and before his last start (where he was pitching hurt, it would appear), he had a 2.74 ERA.

Yet, if they win Tuesday (a win, lest you’ve forgotten, is defined as a game in which you score at least one more run than your opponent), the Pirates will finish April one game under .500, which isn’t all that bad considering their injury mess. It is bad considering they were once 12-6.

Injuries aside, too many players are under-performing. Notable on that list is Francisco Cervelli and Jung Ho Kang, whose combined batting average of .335 would rank just sixth in the National League, two points ahead of the great Melky Cabrera (clearly the team MVP). Adam Frazier hasn’t been great (12th among NL second basemen in slugging percentage). Marte was hitting .203 when he got hurt. Jameson Taillon has been just OK. Cole Tucker cooled off after a magical start.

Advertise with us

It ain’t good at the moment. I didn’t think a team with this kind of starting pitching would have a losing streak this long, injuries or not. I was wrong. So when I tell you I don’t think it’ll go completely off the rails, take that for what it’s worth. I think they survive, get some players back, get improved performance from others and hover around .500 most of the year.

Yippee!

Bobby Reese, @BuStA607: Heard your discussion regarding the Selke and Hart trophies. How do you feel about the Norris Trophy always being awarded to offensive defenseman? Should they make a separate award for true defensemen who block shots, hit, and do the dirty work?

Starkey: The last thing we need is another bogus hockey award, Dr. @BuStA607. They already have one for the “most gentlemanly” player. You know it as the Lady Byng Memorial Trophy. Does anyone honestly want to win that thing?

The Norris, ideally, is awarded to the best all-around defenseman — and I rarely have an issue with the winner. Nicklas Lidstrom won it seven times. Victor Hedman won it last year. Brent Burns, Mark Giordano and Hedman are finalists this year.

Advertise with us

I guess that’s a long-winded way of saying I don’t really care who blocks the most shots or does the “dirty work.” I respect that you do.

Ron Matthews, @RonMatthews82: Who was the biggest reach in the Steelers’ draft?

Starkey: I’ll tell you who wasn’t, Ron: Diontae Johnson. I love this kid. I think he’ll contribute immediately. The Steelers have earned our doubt when choosing cornerbacks; they have earned our trust when choosing wide receivers. Even if many believed this was a “reach,” I’m going to trust this pick, especially when I see some of the favorable reviews and watch the tape. Kid gets open in tight spaces.

C. Brooks T, @CBrooksT: In hindsight, is the Archer trade a good one? Methinks the answer is either it is too early to tell or no, but “yes” isn’t in the equation.

Starkey: I like the way you phrased that, Mr. @CBrooksT. “Yes” is not in the equation at the moment. That’s for sure. The only way this deal will ever be justified, it would appear, is if Archer helps the Pirates reach the playoffs. This is the kind of trade a legit contender makes in order to push itself over the top. The Pirates were a contender when they made the deal — and Archer promptly produced a 5-something ERA as the team fell apart in August. He was good in September and then had a pretty good start this season before a terrible outing that may have been caused by a bum thumb.

Advertise with us

Meanwhile, Tyler Glasnow has turned into Roger Clemens and Austin Meadows is Mickey Mantle. We’ll see how this ends on both sides of the deal — but, yes, at the moment it looks terrible.

Haus, @greg_holsinger: Joe, my question is if there is a leader on the Pirates? I know everyone is trying as hard as they can but A.J. Burnett came in and demanded a winning team. We don’t have that leader right now. Archer was the person to do it, but he is struggling. We need Melky to do it. He is MVP.

Starkey: I don’t think the Pirates’ problem is leadership, Mr. Haus. It’s offense and defense and injuries. Joe Musgrove, in fact, has brought a bit of an A.J. Burnett attitude here and looks like a pretty good pitcher, too.

Katiekelly, @ktCakes_: Which Pittsburgh athlete is Arya Stark and why?

Starkey: I don’t know who Arya Stark is, and I’m not going to look on the internet to find out, Ms. @ktCakes_. I’m guessing it’s a “Game of Thrones” character or somebody from “Avengers.” However, your question evokes thoughts of Rhon Stark, the old punter, and I shall therefore list my five favorite punters of all time.

Advertise with us

5. Reggie Roby: Unbelievable height on follow-through.

4. Russell Erxleben: Loved his name. Was 11th overall pick in draft — ahead of Kellen Winslow!

3. Dan Pastorini: Yeah, he was the punter early in his career. Punted 316 times, including a 74-yarder.

2. Andy Lee: Pitt man. Good dude. Great punter.

1. Josh Miller: Did a show with him.

Advertise with us

KS, @K_Sed_814: Do the Penguins have time for a rebuild to get another cup for Sid?

Starkey: A rebuild? There is no time for that, KS. A “re-work” around younger players? Yes, I could see that, although I’m strongly against the idea of trading Evgeni Malkin. I believe Malkin at his worst (which was this season) is still a point-per-game player — and he is just one year removed from leading the team with 98 points.

bucco backer, @BackerBucco: My Question to you is….Why

Starkey: Why not?

Thank you, kiddies. Send me questions (tweet @JoeStarkey1 or email at jstarkey@post-gazette.com). Sign up for our free Monday-Friday all-sports newsletter, PG Feed.