LOS ANGELES — Welcome to this week’s Pirates mailbag. You can submit questions to our mailbags via email, at bbrink@post-gazette.com and nwilborn@post-gazette.com or on Twitter, @BrinkPG and @nwilborn19. This week we’ll discuss Cole Tucker, Chris Archer and Corey Dickerson.
Q: Why does Hurdle always have short stops batting 8th?
— @pirates24_7
Q: why is cole tucker batting 8th? it doesn’t make sense to bat a rookie there in my opinion.
— @kaylatuckfraz
A: Hurdle was asked about this Sunday morning, and here was his response: “I do think there’s some times we make more of it than it is, because they’re throwing him strikes. So I don’t think you need to overcook it, and that’s one thing that we do share with him. Don’t overcook this. Be ready to hit.”
Read More
Hurdle batted Jordy Mercer there for years because Mercer was comfortable there and knew what he was looking for. This season, he hit Erik Gonzalez and Kevin Newman there because they are not strong hitters, at least at the major league level. It’s important to remember that as impressive as Tucker’s debut was, he’s got a .273 OBP and is hitting .226 with 12 strikeouts in 31 at-bats. He’s talented and will adjust, but right now there’s a lot of swing and miss.
Q: What is the plan for Kingham? With so much potential, how is he benefiting by pitching ~2 innings in a week, always when the game is out of hand.. that’s how Glassnow was used and look how he’s doing when given a chance..
— @cerpsu721
A: The comparison between Tyler Glasnow and Nick Kingham holds up regarding their usage out of the bullpen, but breaks down when factoring in their potential. For all of Glasnow’s problems in Pittsburgh, he showed why he was so highly thought of at times, with a high-90s fastball and a great curveball. Kingham is very talented but doesn’t have the weaponry Glasnow did.
There isn’t a starter in the rotation that Kingham is above on the depth chart, and he’s out of minor league options, so the bullpen is his immediate future.
Q: If Dickerson can't play this season, and assuming Marte returns, who is more likely to stay up between Martin and Reynolds.?
— @cpawfan
A: First, thus far there has been no indication that Dickerson won’t play again this season. So far we know he felt tightness in his right shoulder while throwing from 110 feet, and he will meet the team in Texas for their two-game series against the Rangers. We will know more Wednesday, when director of sports medicine Todd Tomczyk meets with the media.
Assuming Marte returns, my guess would be Reynolds stays, for two reasons. One, he can play center field. Two, he’s performed better. He has a hit in every game and he’s 9 for 21 with a .619 slugging percentage. He’s also a switch-hitter.
“He’s a student of the game,” Hurdle said. “He’s got his own inner fire. He wants to do well. I think he’s managed his at-bats very, very professionally, both sides of the plate.”
Q: OK, here's one. Will the trade in which the Pirates acquired Archer go down as the worst one they ever made or the 2nd worst one?
— @pmojh3
A: MLB Network was on in the Pirates’ clubhouse recently, and a couple players were watching Glasnow face the Red Sox, his fastball cutting in on the hands of lefties at 99 mph. I don’t love wins as a stat, but he’s 5-0, which in six starts is hard to ignore, with a 1.75 ERA, and 38 strikeouts and seven walks (SEVEN WALKS!) in 36 innings, and a 0.94 WHIP.
It’s remarkable.
There’s no defending the trade in light of the way Glasnow and Austin Meadows (.351/.422/.676, six homers) have performed since joining Tampa Bay. Archer has been a mixed bag: He was bad last August and good last September; his past two starts have not equaled his first three.
If you evaluate the trade at the time it was made, when Glasnow was a middle reliever, it makes more sense. Glasnow had a crack at the rotation in 2017 and it didn’t work. He had a 4.34 ERA with the Pirates before the trade in 2018 and walked 5.5 batters per nine innings (when I looked up his stats for this mailbag and saw seven walks I almost spit my beer all over the keyboard).
I also believe the Pirates thought (and still do think) they can help Archer return to his previous form, or close to it, with less reliance on the slider and a four-pitch arsenal, not to mention getting him out of the AL East. He’s shown, in September and his first three starts, that that remains a possibility.
Meadows was always going to hurt to lose; he’s talented and would have succeeded regardless of whether he was in Pittsburgh or elsewhere. I don’t think anyone saw that Glasnow would do this after the way he pitched in Pittsburgh, and I think rather than the trade being the issue this is more of an indictment of the Pirates’ pitching development. I can’t help but think of Gerrit Cole, who, while he pitched well in Pittsburgh and had a great 2015, flourished upon joining the Astros. You wonder if more flexibility, or a different method of imparting information, or new voices (not saying fire Ray, just maybe trying something different because what they were doing wasn’t unlocking his talent).
As I write this, it’s Sunday evening and I’m enjoying a Pizza Port Swami’s IPA in the hotel bar in L.A., and I glanced up at the TV to see ESPN showing highlights of Glasnow’s start: Fastballs up in the zone for swing and miss, 84-mph curveballs for called strike three, etc. I get it. The trade looks bad. My argument is that I think the process that resulted in making the trade at the time was a good one.
Bill Brink: bbrink@post-gazette.com and Twitter @BrinkPG.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.