Welcome to Joe Starkey’s mailbag, where the Post-Gazette columnist and 93.7 The Fan radio host answers your questions about sports, life, former Alcorn State star Larry Smith (aka “Mr. Mean”) and everything in between. If you want to ask Joe a question, tweet him @JoeStarkey1 or email him at jstarkey@post-gazette.com. On to the questions …

Jeff Brown, @J_M_B_: Why, oh why, did we make that terrible trade?

Joe, @JW8771: Time for Jim Rutherford to retire?

Starkey: Easy now, fellas. Let’s remove the emotion and look at this rationally.

Advertise with us

First of all, the fact that Rutherford was able to rid himself of the Missing Pearson and get a breathing mammal of any kind was akin to the Miracle on Ice. Somebody took Pearson. SOMEBODY TOOK PEARSON!

Secondly, it is entirely possible (and perhaps advisable) that Gudbranson will be an emergency fill-in and then an extra defenseman once (if) everyone is healthy. I’m assuming, perhaps mistakenly, that the top six ultimately will be Kris Letang, Brian Dumoulin, Justin Schultz, Olli Maatta, Jack Johnson and Marcus Pettersson — although the Penguins might want to balance that last pair with a right-handed shot, which might mean Gudbranson instead of Pettersson.

Meanwhile, I’m willing to keep an open mind here based on the Penguins’ recent track record in rehabbing underachieving defensemen such as Schultz, Ian Cole, Jamie Oleksiak and Pettersson, to name four. The Johnson Project still is pending.

The good news is that Gudbranson is just 27. I kind of liked his game in Florida, at least when he played the Penguins. The bad news is he turned into Erik Bad-branson in Vancouver. Really bad. And I don’t quite understand Rutherford’s obsession with tough guys of late.

Didn’t the Penguins win two Cups basically turning the other cheek? Wasn’t that, in fact, part of their strategy after playoff meltdowns against the Flyers and Bruins?

Advertise with us

I’m in favor of a sleeker, get-back-and-get-it-out kind of defense. That has changed — and the idea of a Johnson-Gudbranson pairing is somewhat terrifying.

In the end, gentlemen, losing Pearson is a win. We’ll see if Sergei Gonchar and Jacques Martin can help Gudbranson. If not, oh well.

Eric, @ThePittsburgher: Is Dominik Simon the same or better than Tyler Kennedy?

Starkey: Eternal shame on you and your entire family tree, Mr. @ThePittsburgher, for you have blasphemed The Great Tyler Kennedy.

I mean, I’m sure there’s a Corsi rating somewhere that looks upon Simon favorably in this comparison, and I know Kennedy’s career did not end well here (it more than likely ended with him firing another puck directly at a goalie’s logo). But make no mistake: Tyler Kennedy played big in big games. He was a huge reason the Penguins won the Stanley Cup in 2009 and does not deserve to be compared to Dominik Simon, who’s next memorable playoff moment (besides an offensive-zone tripping penalty in Game 5 at Washington) will be his first.

Advertise with us

Kennedy?

Kennedy scored three game-winning goals on the Penguins’ march to the Cup in ’09 and had six playoff game-winners overall. Kennedy had seven goals and 14 points in his final 22 playoff games here. Kennedy was the rarest of Penguins at the time he departed — one who consistently earned his keep in the postseason.

So please do not compare him ever again to Dominik Simon — although I will say this: We should all love someone as deeply and passionately as Mike Sullivan loves Simon.

Ken Laird, @KenLairdWEEI: More important piece in bubble hockey, centerman or Dr. Longstick?

Starkey: Hello, Bruce! Yes, I remember our days at 1250 ESPN and how when it came to bubble hockey, you were Dominik Simon and I was Tyler Kennedy.

Advertise with us

And this is a great question. The centerman scores the most goals, right? And he wins faceoffs. And once he has the puck he cannot be poke-checked if you stick-handle deftly enough (which I always did). He can also backcheck the neutral zone, but only about a millimeter of it.

That being said, Dr. Longstick on the right side controls games like Gretzky. He is the only player on the ice who can backcheck beyond the opposing blue line and forecheck beyond the goal line. He sets the pace with his passing — including the back-handed bounce pass off the boards to the centerman that you could never stop. He creates one-timers. He is unstoppable if used correctly.

I used him correctly. You did not.

Patrick Moxinchalk, @moxie1959: What was your longest field goal in electric football?.....for the record mine was 56 yards ... I tried but couldn't break Dempsey’s 63-yarder.

Starkey: Field goals? The only thing you could do with that tiny pellet ball was flick it with your finger through the always-bent goal posts. I did away with field goals, as the NFL should do, Mr. Moxie, and went with a game of goal-line stands only.

Advertise with us

None of the players ran straight after 10 yards, so in what was something of a precursor to college football’s overtime, I played entire games trading 5-yard goal-line stands. Each team had four cracks at it. And to spice things up, I would turn off all the lights except a mounted flashlight above the action and sprinkle the field with flour for a snow-game effect.

I was not well.

Runnin’ Ref Rick, @PadreRico: Joe, what’s the story with the Pens’ sub-par OT record. All that space three-on-three, all our offense ... and we lose more of them than we win. What gives?

Starkey: Great question, Runnin’ Ref. I tend to think it’s more luck than anything else. Last year, the Penguins were an amazing 12-4 in overtime, but the year before that — Sullivan’s first full year behind the bench — they were 6-6. This year they are 4-6. The first year of three-on-three overtime (2015-16), they were 6-4.

In other words, putting last season aside, the Penguins are 16-16 in three years of three-on-three overtime. So maybe it comes back to this: When you’re trading chances in a wide-open game — and what is three-on-three hockey but that? — winning is a 50/50 proposition more often than not. Which is why Sullivan (and every other coach in NHL history) talks about avoiding those kinds of games, despite the Penguins’ top-end talent.

Advertise with us

Look at Philly the other night. Phil Kessel had two great chances to win it in overtime. He didn’t. Matt Murray let in a questionable goal. Game.

Linden Arden, @lindenarden7: Dylan's Street-Legal: overblown mess or underrated masterpiece?

Starkey: “I think … we better talk this over. Maybe … when we both get sober.” This is a miraculous album, Dr. Arden. Absolutely miraculous.“Where are you tonight (Journey Through Dark Heat)?” is a top-10 Dylan song. Yes, I said it. The energy, the backup singers, the imagery. It’s all there.

Top three songs on Street Legal …

3. Changing of the Guards

Advertise with us

2. We Better Talk This Over

1. Journey Through Dark Heat

Top Three Dylan Albums …

3. Blonde on Blonde

2. Another Side of Bob Dylan

Advertise with us

1. Blood on the Tracks

Three Most Underrated Dylan Albums

3. Infidels

2. Street Legal

1. Slow Train Comin’ (which includes the all-time most underrated Dylan Song: “Precious Angel.”)

Advertise with us

Dan Guevara, @DanGuevara1: Why did the Penguins send Blueger down when he was actually producing more than Simon and Wilson?

Starkey: Rutherford basically said it was so the team could stay under the 23-man roster limit before the deadline hit and not have to put Kris Letang or Brian Dumoulin on injured reserve. The better question is, why was Blueger a healthy scratch the past three games?

Too productive? Too passionate? Too not-Dominik Simon?

The infatuation with Simon has reached comical proportions. He can be useful in your top six from time to time — he doesn’t look totally out of place next to top players — but he is a complete misfit as a fourth-liner.

David Whipkey, @DavidWhipkey5: Does this exquisite run of UB Bulls basketball success make you happy?

Advertise with us

Starkey: Very happy, Mr. Whipkey.

Very happy.

Thank you, kiddies. Be sure to insult Sean Gentille — who no longer returns my texts — this week. Also, send me questions (tweet @JoeStarkey1 or email at jstarkey@post-gazette.com).