Welcome to Joe Starkey’s mailbag, where the Post-Gazette columnist and 93.7 The Fan radio host answers your questions about sports, life, Lanny McDonald and everything in between. If you want to ask Joe a question, tweet him @JoeStarkey1 or email him at jstarkey@post-gazette.com. On to the questions …
Connie McGinley, @StanceLey: How likely is it that Geno will get suspended after that match penalty? I am not saying whether or not I think he deserves it, but am surprised about the lack of concern.
Starkey: I’m not sure when you posted this question, Connie, but the concern grew quickly. Malkin technically is “suspended” until a ruling by the commissioner, according to NHL rules regarding match penalties. He has a phone hearing Tuesday, which means any suspension will be five or fewer games.
Will he be officially suspended?
I would guess for a game.
Should he be?
Read More
Yes, if for nothing else than sheer stupidity.
Evgeni Malkin was ejected for swinging his stick at the head of a Philadelphia Fleyers player 🏒👀 pic.twitter.com/k7m53nNsop
— Listen2This1✌️ (@Listen2ThisOne) February 12, 2019
Your team is up 3-0 late in a gigantic game, you can’t be taking retaliatory baseball swings at people’s heads. Michael Raffl deserved a penalty, too, either for cross-checking Malkin in the back or punching him in the back of the head. But Malkin’s response was beyond mindless and could have been catastrophic both to Raffl’s well-being and to the Penguins’ chance of winning.
In a sane hockey world, such an act would merit at least a 10-game suspension — imagine somebody swinging at Sidney Crosby’s head like it was a pinata — but this is a league that has long based punishments on whether the victim is injured or not. Which never made sense to me.
Are you punishing the act or the result of the act?
It should be the act itself, and I’ve often used this theoretical example: What if a guy takes a baseball swing at somebody’s head and misses?
Well, Geno has turned theory into practice — and if the league goes by precedent, he will receive either no suspension or a short one. One game seems about right.
PaperFootballHallOfFame, @PaperFBHOF: If AB is traded or cut, do the Browns have a better roster than the Steelers?
Starkey: I would have to look at position-by-position, which is saying something in itself, Mr. PaperFootballHallOfFame. It’s awfully close — and it should be, really, because the Browns have been drafting about 20 spots higher than the Steelers for how many years?
Carlo Gambino, @Gambino: What is the best non-football sporting event you have ever attended? Please rank these events in your order of preference ... Big East Tournament, Stanley Cup Final, NCAA tTurnament, MLB playoffs, NFL draft.
Starkey: Very well. Here we go:
1. Cup final. If you’re asking me to pick a game, then Game 7 against the Red Wings in 2009. Never felt such angst inside a sporting venue. Max Talbot turned 35 on Monday, by the way.
2. Big East Tournament. Sitting courtside all day watching intense basketball games is my idea of heaven. I spent several years in Madison Square Garden heaven. If you’re asking me for a game, seeing Pitt beat Georgetown in the title game one year was the highlight — with Sam Young playing in borrowed sneakers (he either forgot his or somebody stole them, I can’t remember which).
3. MLB playoffs. I mean, for one event, I’d put the wild-card game against Cincinnati first in my entire career. But in general, I’d put baseball playoffs third — and I wonder if I’ll ever see a playoff game again.
4. NCAA Tournament. I’ve never been to a Final Four (thanks a lot, Scottie Reynolds).
5. NFL draft. Never covered one. God willing, I never will.
PatrikPatsko, @Steelfrmblawnox: Will Capel top last year’s recruiting class?
Starkey: I’m not going to bet against Capel when it comes to recruiting. The last-second class he cobbled together last year was remarkable, but I’d be willing to wager this one will be stocked with even more talent.
Matt Krisnosky, @MattKriz: The Islanders are first in the Metro. I can’t name anyone on their team besides Barzal. Seriously what is going on?
Starkey: Here’s what’s going on, Mr. @MattKriz: The Islanders are first in the Metro — and Barry Trotz is a miracle worker.
This is all you need to know: The Isles gave up the most goals last season; they’ve given up the fewest this season.
Nathan, @bigknuterockne: If the Steelers had the No. 1 overall pick up this year, who would you take?
Starkey: Great question. Nick Bosa. Consider this take from Pro Football Weekly: “Nick Bosa is a natural 4-3 defensive end, but with his athleticism, he can easily play as an outside linebacker in a base 3-4 scheme. Regardless, on pass downs, his hand is going to be in the dirt as a pass rusher.
Yes. Yes it is. With T.J. Watt on the other side.
PGH Mike, @ThePGHMike: Estimate how many times you went to Century III Mall before its bankruptcy
Starkey: If it happened once, I do not remember. And that is no knock on Century III Mall, a respectable mall that could beat you on any given day.
Chainman1, @Chainman110: Did any Pens reporter ask Sully about Blueger not playing? Guessing not. Has Sully ever been asked an “edgy” question? One that he might snarl at? Serious question, perhaps I miss them.
Starkey: Try asking him about Daniel Sprong. Actually, reporters ask Sully plenty of edgy questions. I think the people covering that team do a really good job.
John Petro, @JohnPet64499720: Phil had his speed [Monday] but no shots on goal. Horny on the fourth line played little over 9 minutes. Murray exceptional.
Starkey: Your question, sir?
Thank you, kiddies. Be sure to insult Sean Gentille this week. Also, send me questions (tweet @JoeStarkey1 or email at jstarkey@post-gazette.com).






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.