There was a time, not long ago, when I believed the Pirates’ plummeting attendance must be causing sleepless nights for team owner Bob Nutting.
I don’t believe that anymore. I don’t believe it was ever true.
What does attendance matter when money pours in from so many other sources?
What does attendance matter when franchise values are rising like LeBron James on a breakaway dunk?
Business is boomin’ in Major League Baseball, which, according to Forbes, hauled in a record $10.3 billion in revenue in 2018. That marked the 16th straight year MLB topped its previous record, and that has created a situation where winning has become disincentivized.
A story by Craig Calcaterra on NBCSports.com ought to open your eyes. It opened mine.
Read More
“If you own a team and you (as a league) are getting billions from TV over the next couple of decades, and billions in random windfalls from gambling and internet side businesses and by making such-and-such a company an official partner of Major League Baseball — and if actually drawing fans to the ballpark is less important than ever — why put any money into your team?” Calcaterra writes. “Why pay ballplayers? Why try to even compete? To do so is to take money out of your own pocket for very little financial reward, relatively speaking.”
Don’t get me wrong. I’m sure Nutting isn’t thrilled his team has lost more than a million fans over the past three years (a million!). He’d prefer the place be packed, just as he’d prefer to have a contending team, just as I’d prefer a Lamborghini to whatever I’m driving now.
We can all wish.
The question is, what are we actually doing?
In Nutting’s case, not much. If you as a fan are trying to send him a message by refusing to buy tickets, it’s not working.
He’s not listening.

With spring training about to begin, the Pirates apparently will field a team on a payroll just north of $70 million. If it were a Lamborghini, Nutting, in broad daylight, has stripped it down to a steering wheel, seat cushions (any loose change back there?) and bald tires.
Fans have been crying out in pain and protest. They have basically stopped going to games and don’t watch as much on TV anymore. And the Pirates have responded with a payroll that apparently will be some $30 million lower than just three years ago.
Their official explanation goes something like this: We have a bunch of wonderful young players we’ll need to pay over the next few years; what do you expect?
Yes, well, we’ll see how many of them pan out, and if they do, how many are retained. And let’s not forget: If any or all of the three most-expensive players (Francisco Cervelli, Corey Dickerson, Starling Marte) are jettisoned, it would help offset anticipated raises for others.
This business will purr along per usual, whether people show up or not.
The Pirates are not unique, by the way.
“As MLB rakes in the corporate partner and the TV money, other sources of revenue become less-and-less important. Attendance, primarily,” Calcaterra writes. “For most of baseball’s history, revenues depended upon attendance more than anything else. Now, not nearly as much.”
The Pirates do have some pieces. I like their pitching. If the rotation stays intact, they could surprise people as they shoot for their first division title since 1992. They stepped way out of character to acquire Chris Archer last season.
But if that was aimed at recapturing the lost portion of the fan base, it’s going to take a whole lot more. The rest of the NL Central looks formidable. Other teams made big moves this offseason, not the least of which was the St. Louis Cardinals — the Pirates haven’t finished ahead of them one time in the 21st century — landing Paul Goldschmidt.
I would say this is a huge year for the Pirates in terms of drawing fans back to PNC Park. I would say Nutting must be worried sick over the catastrophic drop in attendance.
But I’d be lying.
Joe Starkey: jstarkey@post-gazette.com and Twitter @joestarkey1. Joe Starkey can be heard on the “Cook and Joe” show weekdays from 10 a.m. to 2 p.m. on 93.7 The Fan.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.