I was thinking along these lines, anyway, but the topic crystallized when a reader tweeted me the following question: “Is Tony Romo already the GOAT?”
Greatest of All Time, in year two?
Well, yes. Yes, he is, although I wouldn’t expect Romo to splurge on a $20,000 GOAT ring, a la Antonio Brown, anytime soon.
I don’t take this proclamation lightly. Like a lot of you, I’ve been watching football obsessively since birth (or soon after), so I almost feel overqualified here.
John Madden was entertaining. Jon Gruden was fun for a while. Merlin Olsen and Dan Dierdorf were comforting. “Dandy” Don Meredith was hilarious. Phil Simms was infuriating. Paul Maguire was engaging.
Tom Brookshier made an excellent pair with Pat Summerall — together a study in the axiom “less is more.” Nobody wants obnoxious loud mouths talking over every play. I don’t, anyway.
Read More
Who else?
Troy Aikman — bland. Cris Collinsworth — knowledgable but grating (maybe it’s the voice, and trust me, I know a grating voice when I hear one). Dan Fouts — decent.
So yes: With all due respect to those and others (except Dennis Miller), Tony Romo, who went straight from the locker room to the television booth about five minutes ago, is already the GOAT. And by that I mean I’d want Summerall on play-by-play and Romo doing color in a game to save the planet. Not just because he is “Romodamus” before plays, either.
But let’s start with that. The man is uncanny, advising viewers in quick, edible sound bites not only what is about to happen but why.
Real clip from late in Sunday’s AFC title game …
Gronk is out wide. Watch the top of your screen. Watch this safety (circles him). If he comes down, there’s a good chance (Tom Brady) is throwing out there.
.@TonyRomo was calling plays before they happened! 🔮 pic.twitter.com/4jdm9I8Pl5
— NFL (@NFL) January 22, 2019
He came down. Brady threw out there. It was part of a Romo hot streak that made him — rather than Brady or Patrick Mahomes — the most talked-about quarterback in America that night.
Romo routinely offers such clairvoyance to the point where Bryce Harper was moved to tweet the following:
@Bharper3407: “Confirmed: Just called Tony Romo to see where I’m going to play next year. #YoureAWizardTony”
That hashtag launched a trillion responses, such as these:
• Lisa Steimer, @decomag:Tony Romo will you be my financial advisor? #YoureAWizardTony
• Daron K. Roberts, @CoachDKR: Tony, when will the government shutdown end? #YoureAWizardTony
• Michael McLachlan, @MikeMcLachlan: Wikipedia needs to update @TonyRomo page. He didn’t go to Eastern Illinois, he went to Hogwarts. #YoureAWizardTony
• raven, @ribcageraven: Tony, where did I leave my phone charger? #YoureAWizardTony
• Alex Serrano, @TheDr1zz1e: You think Tony Romo knew he would never win a super bowl? #YoureAWizardTony
Romo can’t be the only ex-player capable of predicting plays. A huge part of the profession, on both sides of the ball, is learning to do just that. But he is the only one who’s willing and able to predict them consistently and effectively.
His appeal, however, extends far beyond telepathy. He has a knack for engaging both the lifelong football fan and the novice. You feel like you’re saddled up to the bar, beer in hand (preferably a Genny Cream), watching the game with a guy who knows way too much but isn’t going to club you over the head with Cover 3 jargon. Romo also has just the right touch in puncturing partner Jim Nantz’s next-level sophistication.
He’s fun. He seems excited to be there. He’s not afraid to be critical. And like the best ex-jocks-turned-analysts, Romo can translate complicated X’s and O’s into digestible nuggets.
In short, he’s an easy listen. I never find myself yelling “Shut up!” at the TV, which separates him from pretty much every other sports analyst on the planet.
Romo’s games have become an event — and lucky for us, he will be calling his first Super Bowl when the Patriots play the Rams. People are talking about him as a head coaching candidate (seems a bit much) and wondering what his immediate future holds. Besides palm reading, of course.
The New York Post provided a clue, reporting next season will be the last of Romo’s three-year deal with CBS and that the network plans to offer a “substantial raise” from the nearly $4 million he is currently making.
That’s a lot of money.
And not nearly enough.
Joe Starkey: jstarkey@post-gazette.com and Twitter @joestarkey1. Joe Starkey can be heard on the “Cook and Joe” show weekdays from 10 a.m. to 2 p.m. on 93.7 The Fan.







Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.