This feels like one of those major-implication games, and nobody is more majorly implicated than Steelers defensive coordinator Keith Butler.
Butler’s first day on the job came against the New England Patriots. It’s entirely possible one of his last days on the job will come against them, too, Sunday at Heinz Field.
That’s the bleak outlook, anyway. And perhaps the realistic one. Art Rooney II put this defense on blast after The Blake Bortles Incident last January. He cannot be pleased that even though the unit is marginally improved against the run (don’t tell Phillip Lindsay that), it is significantly worse overall.
The major issues are a recurring inability to finish games and a deadly allergy to turnovers — although that didn’t stop the fellas from posing for a mock photo in the end zone Sunday when Derek Carr gifted them a fumble (they must have figured no one would believe them without photographic evidence).
If the Steelers miss the playoffs, and if Tom Brady gives them a swift kick in that direction, I could easily see sweeping changes to the defensive staff.
The optimistic outlook? Well, who better than the Patriots to provide Butler with a shot at redemption? Should he finally slay the Brady dragon, the narrative changes, at least until a visit to New Orleans a week later.
Read More
Butler’s tenure has been a curious one, to say the least. It’s not hard to find people who’ll tell you Mike Tomlin has commandeered the defense over the past year.
True or not, it’s a bad look for Butler. Either his coach doesn’t trust him or Butler himself is responsible for a defense that takes two steps backward for every step forward.
Ed Bouchette and Gerry Dulac break down Steelers-Patriots
It was less than four years ago that Butler, the longtime Dick LeBeau protege — and one the Steelers went to great lengths to keep in the organization — worked his first game as coordinator, a nationally televised disaster in Foxborough.
You might remember it for the Steelers periodically opting to deploy 10 defenders. Or for them using a ghost against Rob Gronkowski. They literally covered him with nobody on a touchdown pass in a 28-21 loss that wasn’t that close.
Brady would have inflicted way more damage if the Patriots hadn’t gone into clock-kill mode in the rain. He settled for 25-of-32 with four touchdowns and no interceptions (that’s a play where the other team catches the ball) against a blitzing Steelers defense.
Brady did inflict more damage in the AFC championship 16 months later, shredding what this time was a passive Tomlin/Butler scheme.
Once again, we saw confusion and coverage failures and Brady identifying juicy matchups (linebackers on receivers, Mike Mitchell on anyone) all over the place. Once again, the Steelers decided to employ a ghost, this time leaving Chris Hogan completely alone.
Brady went 32-of-42 for three touchdowns and no interceptions (that’s a play where the defense, rather than the offense, catches the ball).
There is no shame in losing to Brady, of course. Everybody does it. But the way the Steelers have lost to him is an ugly stain on a franchise resume bursting with examples of defensive brilliance. He has humiliated them. Going into last year’s matchup, he had 22 touchdowns and no interceptions against Tomlin defenses.
The Steelers actually picked off Brady in last year’s game — I can’t remember if they posed for a photo — and played pretty well until they really needed a stop. That’s when Gronkowski went crazy on a 73-yard touchdown drive. And you better believe that even if the Jesse James play had counted, Brady had enough time to make things interesting.
Afterward, Butler spoke of how Gronk was supposed to be double-teamed but wasn’t. More confusion. More blown assignments.
Tomlin was asked the other day if any coverages work against Gronk.
“Yes,” he said. “But we haven’t been a part of it.”
This past Sunday, Carr executed two long fourth-quarter touchdown drives. The game before that, one player (Keenan Allen) beat the Steelers’ “smoke and mirrors” defense time and again.
It hasn’t all been bad under Butler. His first year went fairly well after the Gronk disaster. But it finished with linguine-armed Peyton Manning converting a third-and-12 on a 65-yard touchdown drive in the fourth quarter (sound familiar?).
The Steelers have rediscovered their pass rush the past two years — but so many of those sacks feel empty. They don’t result in fumbles. They don’t happen often enough in the clutch. The pass rush itself isn’t causing any interceptions. The team is on pace to set a franchise record for fewest in a season.
Rooney didn’t like what he saw last year, especially the “soft” run defense, to borrow his word.
“That’s not Steeler football,” he said.
What must he think of this?
Joe Starkey: jstarkey@post-gazette.com and Twitter @joestarkey1. Joe Starkey can be heard on the “Cook and Joe” show weekdays from 10 a.m. to 2 p.m. on 93.7 The Fan
Do you appreciate good journalism? If you do, consider subscribing.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.