Clint Hurdle isn’t getting a ton of credit these days, what with his team mired in yet another late-season death spiral.
But he deserves credit for this: He wrested from the Pirates an unfathomably lavish — some would say ridiculous — contract extension late last season.
That much became clear earlier this week, when a USA Today report revealed Hurdle is the third-highest paid manager in the National League and the seventh-highest in all of baseball with a salary of $3 million this season.
That’s right. The mom-and-pop Pirates, who once fought over every nickel with Neil Walker in arbitration (and I didn’t blame them), and who routinely possess one of the lowest payrolls in the majors, wildly overpaid for a manager coming off two bad years. This is the area in which Bob Nutting chose to outspend most of the industry.
And this is how you get a manager so steeped in security that he has no reservations putting a .160 hitter in his lineup all the time.
In an age where managers are rightfully being devalued, their average salary plummeting, the Pirates way overvalued theirs. Hurdle went into this season with a salary 58 percent higher than that of his St. Louis Cardinals’ counterpart, for goodness sake.
Read More
Here’s the punch line: The Pirates gave Hurdle FOUR YEARS on his extension.
No, here’s the punch line: The Cardinals have since fired that manager (Mike Matheny), won just about every game, established themselves as a solid bet to make the playoffs and will finish ahead of the Pirates for the 19th consecutive season.
No, no. Here’s the punch line: The Cardinals took the interim tag off Mike Shildt (.692 winning percentage) and signed him to a deal that is half as long as Hurdle’s. Shildt essentially agreed to a two-year contract, which means the rest of this year plus the 2019 and ’20 seasons. Hurdle is the only manager in the NL Central with a contract that takes him all the way through 2021.
So, good for him.
But is it good for the Pirates?
A little more than two weeks ago, I was making a case for Hurdle having done a decent job this season. His team seemed to be playing slightly above its talent level at three games over .500 and was still alive in the wild-card race. I reserved the right to change my mind, however, based on the final month-and-a-half. The Pirates are 3-10 since that day.
Not all collapses are created equal, but it’s kind of hard to ignore the fact that Hurdle’s club is mired in one for the fifth time in his eight years as manager.
A closer look …
• Last year, the Pirates played at a .421 clip (24-33) over the final two months.
• In 2016, they finished 26-32, including 11-17 in September.
• In 2012, they went 20-39 over the final two months.
• In 2011, they went 18-38.
• This season, they were 8-16 in August going into Wednesday’s game and 11-19 since their 11-game winning streak.
They aren’t collapsing. They are disintegrating, thanks largely to a nonexistent offense (and it’s worth mentioning here that Hurdle cut his teeth as a hitting coach).
The Pirates are paying Hurdle as if he is a major difference-maker, a cut above the rest. That creates a higher standard, one the Pirates surely are not achieving now that they are on track to finish with the kind of miserable record most baseball observers predicted (though there is yet time to apply some lipstick to this pig of a season).
I would never begrudge Hurdle the good years here. He was the toast of the town — abso-Buc’n-lutely he was — back in 2013. And for good reason. His booming personality was just what this meager little doormat of a franchise needed. He kept winning, too, although not the important September games that could have won him his first career division title. Not the playoff games, either.
Cue your best Jim Mora voice: Playoffs? That seems like a loooong time ago.
The Pirates are failing in their mission, which is, as general manager Neal Huntington has articulated several million times, to “play meaningful baseball in September” most years. This will apparently be the third straight year without such baseball in these parts.
In a way, I suppose, it’s commendable that Nutting so clearly prioritized stability at the top of his baseball operations department. It’s a Steelers-like model, with one slight variance.
The Steelers win.
Joe Starkey: jstarkey@post-gazette.com and Twitter @joestarkey1. Joe Starkey can be heard on the “Starkey and Mueller” show weekdays from 2-6 p.m. on 93.7 The Fan
Can't get enough of our in-depth Pirates coverage?






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.