Welcome to Joe Starkey’s mailbag, where the Post-Gazette columnist and 93.7 The Fan radio host answers your questions about sports, life, Bob McAdoo and everything in between. If you want to ask Joe a question, tweet him @JoeStarkey1 or email him at jstarkey@post-gazette.com. On to the questions …

Jordan Dee, @JDeePGH: Do you think most casual fans realize the #pirates are three games out of a playoff spot?

Starkey: Most casual fans appear to have tuned out, Mr. Dee, at least as ticket buyers. But the better question might be this: Do the Pirates realize they are three games out of a playoff spot?

If so, and if they are indeed looking to add players rather than subtract them, as general manager Neal Huntington insisted Sunday, then you have to wonder if they made a serious run at just-traded reliever Kelvin Herrera. And if not, why not? The price was right, and he seemingly would have been a nice piece for this oft-beleaguered bullpen.

Advertise with us

Instead, Herrera went for precious little return to one of the teams the Pirates stand three games behind in the wild-card standings — the Washington Nationals. He is cheap, and the commitment is minimal (owed a little less than $4 million in the final year of his contract). Despite a declining strikeout rate, he is having a good year (14 saves, 1.05 ERA), and the Nationals plan to use him in the eighth and ninth innings, though for now he will probably move into the eighth-inning role behind closer Sean Doolittle. He would have added some big-game experience, as he has pitched in two World Series (1.26 ERA in 22 postseason games).

Best of all? The Nationals didn’t have to give up anything resembling a top prospect to get him. From a story on ESPN.com:

“The Royals are acquiring outfielder Blake Perkins, third baseman Kelvin Gutierrez and right-handed pitcher Yohanse Morel for Herrera, one of the most desirable bullpen arms available on the trade market. Gutierrez, 23, is the 10th-ranked Nationals prospect, according to MLB.com. He is hitting .274 with 6 doubles, 3 triples, 5 homers, 26 RBIs, 16 walks, 10 stolen bases and 36 runs scored in 58 games with Double-A Harrisburg. Perkins, 21, playing in Class A Potomac, is hitting .236 with 11 doubles, one home run, 21 RBIs, 40 walks and 38 runs scored in 63 games. Morel is just 17 and was signed by the Nationals as a nondrafted free agent in 2017.”

Not exactly a king’s ransom. FanGraphs had a slightly higher grade on Gutierrez and said this of the Nationals’ move: “In the current era of baseball, it’s almost impossible to have too many good relievers.”

So true. And the Pirates don’t have enough of them. Maybe they were dissuaded by that declining strikeout rate. Maybe they feared George Kontos Part II. Maybe they didn’t want to spend the money. But it sure looks like one of their chief competitors just got a piece the Pirates really could have used.

Now to our nationally acclaimed Twitter Poll segment. This week’s question courtesy of Dr. Bob Pompeani, who posed it during his 93.7 The Fan show Saturday:

Advertise with us

Should the DH be implemented across baseball (1,291 votes)?

Yes: 38%

No: 51%

Indifferent: 11%

What we learned: That this is a National League town. But we already knew that. And while I appreciate the fact that the NL game is a more strategic one — and yes, some AL designated hitters struggle from time to time, and some NL pitchers get a hit from time to time — I prefer watching actual hitters hit. In other words, I’d be OK if I never saw Ivan Nova swing a bat again. Did you know he’s 1 for 76 over the past two seasons?

Advertise with us

Rapid-fire …

Joe Rice, @coachjoerice: Is there a human on the planet that truly understands the blocking the plate rule in baseball?

Starkey: None that I know of, Joe. And that would include players and managers. I was just looking at Rule 7.13 again the other day, after Josh Bell was thrown out at home against the Reds, trying to decipher if a collision is ever within the rules. I still honestly couldn’t tell you.

John Knight, @jknight841: Will Travis Swaggerty carry the Pirates on his back to the World Series?

Starkey: Yes. As a DH in 2031.

Advertise with us

Shawn Narry, @lawnman9: Is mullsey having a baby so you guys have a lifetime zerorez spot on the show?

Starkey: Quite possible. Now the real question: Will the kid be named Joe?

Steve C, @Stash0426: Did a wide receiver ever make a quarterback look better than Randy Moss did for Dante Culpepper?

Starkey: You forgot the ‘u’ in Daunte, Steve. But your question sparks a quick list (and you might be right). My five favorite wide receivers of all-time:

5. Paul Warfield

Advertise with us

4. Rick Upchurch

3. Larry Fitzgerald

2. Hines Ward

1. Andre Reed

In college ball, I always had a soft spot for Princell Brockenbrough. And of course for Buffalo-born Derek Kinder, who leveled two West Virginia players with one devastating block to spring Darrelle Revis on that legendary 79-yard punt return in the ‘06 Backyard Brawl.

Advertise with us

Thank you for reminding me.

And thank you, kiddies. Be sure to insult Sean Gentille this week. Also, send me questions (tweet @JoeStarkey1 or email at jstarkey@post-gazette.com).