Welcome to Joe Starkey’s mailbag, where the Post-Gazette columnist and 93.7 The Fan radio host answers your questions about sports, life, Bob McAdoo and everything in between. If you want to ask Joe a question, tweet him @JoeStarkey1 or email him at jstarkey@post-gazette.com. On to the questions …
Carlo Gambino, @Gambino_166: Joe, which Pirate is most likely to be moved at the trade deadline? Nova, Harrison, Freese, Cervelli?
Starkey: Here’s another option, Mr. Gambino: All of them and more.
I mean, the bigger question to me is whether the Pirates are closer to contention or a fire sale. If I had to choose the one player most likely to be traded should they fall completely out of the wild-card race (or even stay somewhat in it), it would be Harrison.
He is 30 and in the last guaranteed year of his contract (two club-option years ahead). He is their second-highest paid player. The Pirates have other options, including middle-infield prospects in Class AAA.
But Harrison isn’t the only one I could easily envision elsewhere. There are others, all in their 30s and coming toward the ends of their deals. Those kinds of players traditionally have short shelf-lives with the Pirates.
Read More
Consider …
• Cervelli, 32, the highest-paid player on the team and has just one more year on his deal. He would net by far the biggest return, incidentally, and the Pirates — if they fall out of contention — might be wise to think about trading him while his stock is high.
• Nova, 31, also has just one more year on his contract.
• Mercer, 31, is in the final year of his contract.
• Freese, 35, has only this season guaranteed (team option next year).
• Sean Rodriguez, 33, will be a free agent at year’s end and is making nearly $6 million — without much return so far.
Finally, there is a log jam in the outfield. The Pirates apparently want us to believe that a “four-man outfield” is perfectly normal and workable. It is not normal. It is not workable. Somebody gotta go. My guess, as much as some would like to see Gregory Polanco moved, is that the guy would be Corey Dickerson.
Of course, the Pirates could change the narrative altogether by winning some games.
Can't get enough of our in-depth Pirates coverage?
Support quality journalism. Subscribe today.
Carlo Gambino, @Gambino_166: Joe, who is the best golfer between you, Zeise, Pompeani, and Bouchette?
Starkey: It’s a doubleheader for the Gambino!
I’m definitely the worst. I don’t golf. I hate every aspect of golf. I wish it would disappear from the face of the earth. If I were president, I would eradicate it.
I’m guessing Ed doesn’t play, either, judging by our text exchange, which went like this:
Me: “Do you play golf.”
Ed: “No.”
Apparently, Ed used to play golf but quit about 15 years ago. That leaves Zeise and Pomp, and Zeise’s response to whom is better:
“Pompeani by a mile. I’m a typical weekend hacker who just enjoys being outside, the beer and the cigars and a few good shots here and there keep me coming back. Pompeani is a real golfer who can score and has a complete game. Pomp, Gerry Dulac, Jeff Hathorn, Richie Walsh and Kevin Kane from ATT Sportsnet are clearly the best golfers in the Pittsburgh media.”
Pomp agrees with that last part, though very humbly says, “If I am better than Zeiser, it’s only because I’ve played for a long time.”
There you have it.
Josh Green, @JoshGreen8771: You sticking with Fleury in game 5?
Starkey: Absolutely. He has more than earned the right to finish this thing out, one way or another.
Tim, @timmshady: It's up to you to choose one person to save humanity; by shooting 10 straight, uncontested 3-pointers. You get to take anyone in their prime. Whether its Ray Allen, Chris Mueller, Steph Curry...ANYONE, from any year. Who is your shooter to save the world?
Starkey: Larry Bird.
ALW, @zoeydog15: What sport do you think it is the hardest to break into professionally from the lower ranks?
Starkey: I don’t have a scientific answer to that question, Mr. zoeydog15, but the numbers tell me it would be the NBA. Fewer people on a team means fewer available jobs. I’m assuming you are talking about the four major team sports. It’s impossible for me to imagine how difficult it would be to make the PGA or LPGA Tours, for example, or break into professional tennis or boxing or some such thing.
SKoTBACoN, @skotbacon213: Hey how’ve you been?
Starkey: Good.
bestmomeverX6, @rmthorn7: will Eli and Saquon pass Ben and Leveon in numbers this season.
Starkey: Thank you for the question, Mrs. bestmomeverX6. It’s a good one. And I’m going to surprise you, I think, by saying Eli and Saquon. Eli has at least one more prolific year in him, and I happen to believe that Saquon Barkley is the next Barry Sanders.
Alex, @HealthyPghNerd: What expectations should Pittsburgh have for the Steelers this upcoming season and why?
Starkey: Super Bowl or bust, as it should be. Why? Because their talent level is superior to nearly every team in the league.
kuhnackl, @C_Murda17: Will the caps choke?
Starkey: Well, if you’d scored instead of hitting the post in overtime of Game 6, Kuhny, the Penguins might still be alive. But to answer you question, no, I don’t think the Capitals choke. I think Vegas has one last shining moment in front of their fans, and then the Capitals go home and win it in Game 6.
And I can’t believe I just wrote that.
Thanks, kiddies. Be sure to insult Sean Gentille this week. Also, send me questions (tweet @JoeStarkey1 or email at jstarkey@post-gazette.com).






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.