On May 17, the Pirates moved to a season-high nine games above .500 at 26-17. They were in first place and appeared poised to make a run against the lowly Padres and Reds. However, the Pirates lost five of those next six games, beginning a downward spiral they haven’t recovered from.
They’ve won only three of 10 games since then. That means the Pirates are 4-12 in their past 16 games and are now 30-29, in fourth place in the National League Central Division and 6½ games behind first-place Milwaukee. They are 4½ games behind the second-place Cubs, three games behind the third-place Cardinals and 3½ games out, behind three other teams, for the second wild-card spot.
It’s officially crunch time for manager Clint Hurdle. The Pirates have been described as young and hungry, but that’s usually a nice way of saying inexperienced and likely to struggle. The Pirates are in the danger zone right now. This is the first time they have faced adversity this season.
Early in the season, when the ball was bouncing their way, the Pirates were loose and bubbly. They showed emotion and were dancing like fools after every win. Their success was contagious, and at one point they had one of the best offenses in baseball.
That isn’t the case now, and it’s up to Hurdle and the few veterans the Pirates have to guide this team out of this funk. It won’t be easy.
The Pirates can get back on the right track, but they have some obvious issues to solve. If Felipe Vazquez is injured, that’s a huge blow, but it’s magnified right now because most of the other relievers are struggling, too. There seemed to be several answers at closer a few weeks ago, but now, there isn’t one.
Read More
The bullpen needs to improve, but one major issue is that there isn’t a single veteran, and that’s on Neal Huntington. George Kontos was pulled off the scrap heap late last year and had moderate success at the end of a lost season. He was then handed the setup role, but to nobody’s surprise, he imploded and was designated for assignment.
Hurdle needs to forget rest and schedules and play the best eight players every single day. It’s one thing to platoon players based on pitching matchups, but Sunday’s lineup was inexcusable for a slumping team searching for a win.
Sean Rodriguez, who has more strikeouts (35) than total bases (31) and is hitting .167, was in the starting lineup at shortstop. Gregory Polanco, who is clearly the Pirates’ worst outfielder at this point, was in the starting lineup. He is hitting .212.
It shouldn’t be a surprise that Cardinals pitcher Michael Wacha nearly no-hit the Pirates, considering he had those two batting seventh and eighth. With the pitcher hitting ninth, that’s essentially three outs in a row handed to Wacha.
There is no justification for that lineup, at least none that makes sense. Corey Dickerson bats left-handed, and Jordy Mercer bats right-handed, the same as Polanco and Rodriguez, so it wasn’t a matter of righty-lefty platoon that those two were not in the lineup. Yes, it was Sunday, but a Sunday lineup made little sense considering the Pirates have Monday off.
Hurdle doesn’t have the luxury to sit his best players, especially right before an off day. They don’t need rest, they need wins, and they need to regain their confidence.
It’s still early, and the Pirates have plenty of time to recover from this slump. They won’t do that, however, if they don’t find a way to pull themselves out before they fall too many games under .500 and too far out of the division race. A more veteran team may be able to find its way back from that, but a young team like the Pirates will be sunk if they don’t at least stay in the race and continue to experience some success.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.