Welcome to Joe Starkey’s mailbag, where the Post-Gazette columnist and 93.7 The Fan radio host answers your questions about sports, life, Buffalo, Billy Bragg and everything in between. If you want to ask Joe a question, tweet him @JoeStarkey1 or email him at jstarkey@post-gazette.com. On to the questions …
Hello fellow earthlings. We’re going to start with our ever-popular Twitter Polls segment today. And then I will become the 11th Post-Gazette columnist to weigh in on James Harrison.
Question: Does James Harrison belong in the Pro Football Hall of Fame? (1,143 votes as of 10:35 a.m.)
— Yes, of course (34%)
— Absolutely not (27%)
— No way Mullsy made nine 3’s (39%)
Read More
What we learned: It’s more what we re-learned — that Mullsy’s outrageous claim continues to carry the polls. I’m also guessing if this question had been asked before Harrison defected to Brady-land, it would be close to 90 percent “Yes, of course.”
And of course all those people would be wrong.
James Harrison does not belong in the Pro Football Hall of Fame. He was a good player for a long time, a great player for a short time and an all-time Steeler. He made the greatest play in Super Bowl history. And he does not belong in the Hall of Fame.
Why?
Simple: His numbers aren’t good enough. He had just three double digit-sack seasons, and let’s be honest: Unless you’re Jack Ham in every aspect of the game, sacks are going to be the primary measuring stick for an outside linebacker such as Harrison.
Let me backtrack: Harrison in his prime was solid against the run in a great run defense. That much is true. But just three double digit-sack seasons?
Khalil Mack already has three of those in his first four years.
Tamba Hali had three double digit-sack seasons (not that I’m comparing him to Harrison as an all-around player, but you get the point).
Terrell Suggs has seven.
Von Miller already has eight.
Harrison contemporary DeMarcus Ware had eight double digit-sack years, including ones with 20 and 19.5. Harrison’s high was 16. His other two in double digits were 10 and 10.5.
Clay Matthews has four double-digit seasons.
LaMarr Woodley had three (and was more prolific than Harrison in the postseason, with 11 sacks in just seven playoff starts, compared to Harrison’s 11 in 12 starts).
Editor’s note: One could argue Woodley benefitted greatly from Harrison’s presence on the opposite side. One could also argue Harrison benefitted greatly from Woodley’s presence on the opposite side.
Then there are the guys with similar job descriptions already in the Hall of Fame.
The late Derrick Thomas has seven seasons of double-digit sacks. Kevin Greene had 10. Lawrence Taylor had seven.
Andre Tippett would be a good comparable, with three double-digit sack seasons, but he had way more career sacks (100) than Harrison (84.5) in 17 fewer starts.
Harrison is the Steelers’ all-time leader in sacks (a stat that was not kept officially during the Steel Curtain era), but the guy he passed up was Jason Gildon, and nobody talks about him for the Hall of Fame. Longevity is a major factor in that record.
Listen, when I think of Steelers defense, Harrison’s skull-bashing style is right up there with the Lamberts and Greg Lloyds of the world. He was a ferocious player. A master of the strip sack (34 forced fumbles). They should waive the waiting period, if one exists, for the Steelers’ Hall of Honor.
The Hall of Fame is a different story.
All right, how’s about a little rapid-fire …
Brett Gray, @Cutch_22: Kyle Busch with two wins in a row now, you think he’ll make it 3 at Richmond next Sunday?
Starkey: Not if Johnny Rutherford has anything to say about it.
1159shadyave, @1159shadyave: Would “The D Bra” for Derick Brassard be the best or worst Penguins nickname of all-time?
Starkey: Close to the worst, Mr. 1159shadyave, but then again, there’s already a guy on the team nicknamed “Horny” so how much worse can it get?
Top five Penguins nicknames of 21st Century (so not including Brian “Spinner” Spencer, Bob “Battleship” Kelly, etc.):
5. “Skillsy” (Hal Gill, who wasn’t very skilled).
4. “Moose” (Johan Hedberg, who played for the Manitoba Moose).
3. “Bibs” (Bob Errey, who played in the 20th Century but is still involved with club and is very much still “Bibs.”)
2. "Crankshaft" (Douglas Murray, who never did reveal the origin of that moniker)
1. "Bugsy" (Ryan Malone, son of Greg Malone, who also went by Bugsy, as did long-ago defenseman Bryan Watson, who once commandeered a hotel courtesy bus and took his teammates for a joy ride).
This That The 3rd, @BruceAllen1979: What do you think Moroff is going to this time around?
Starkey: Probably what he did last time around, which wasn’t much.
Joey Wagner, @TheTruthSwagner: Should Philadelphia rename their city Sid-adelphia because Crosby owns it?
Starkey: No.
Chris Hawthorne, @Hawthornee: Is this pirates team for real?
Starkey: If by “for real,” you mean a legit contender for the NL Central, I’m going to say no, Mr. Hawthorne. Not unless Neal Huntington finds a way to bolster his rotation and bullpen. Pitching wins in the long run. And it’s a looooonnnnng run. By the time this thing ends, the Steelers will have played four or five games.
The Pirates’ pitching is not good enough. Maybe Joe Musgrove helps. Maybe some moves in the bullpen help, but, man, I would love to have seen the Pirates splurge for a starter.
They’re fun to watch at the moment. A likable team. But pitching wins divisions.
Brock Matava, @BrockMatava: Best golf course you’ve played?
Starkey: Schenley. Which is also the only golf course I’ve played, unless you include Stockton Mini Golf in Cape May, N.J. (I’m unbeatable there).
Thanks, kiddies. Be sure to insult Sean Gentille this week. Also, send me questions (tweet @JoeStarkey1 or email at jstarkey@post-gazette.com).




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.