Officially, the NFL’s haphazard and potentially disastrous crackdown on tackling technique falls under “Playing Rule Article 8.”

I’m going to call it the “Shazier Rule” because I believe Ryan Shazier’s horrific injury on “Monday Night Football” four months ago prompted the hasty and secretive call to action.

This was not announced in advance as a possibility at the owners meetings this week in Orlando, Fla., as other potential changes were. Nobody knew of it until the measure passed by 32-0 vote.

The rule reads like this, as explained by NFL spokesman Brian McCarthy: “It is a (15-yard) foul if a player lowers his head to initiate and make contact with his helmet against an opponent. The player may be disqualified. Applies to any player anywhere on the field.”

Advertise with us

Understand, we are not just talking about helmet-to-helmet hits anymore, or hits on “defenseless players.” The goal posts have been moved.

We’re now talking about striking with the crown of the helmet, period. And the uncomfortable truth about Shazier’s injury, if you believe what ex-NFL defensive back Charles Woodson said afterward, is that dangerous tackling technique contributed to it.

That might sound like victim-blaming. It might seem unduly harsh. But I can’t imagine I am the only one who had long feared for Shazier because of his habit of tackling crown-first. It’s an important discussion, and I commended Woodson at the time for speaking up.

Then-ESPN analyst Jon Gruden said the following immediately upon seeing the replay of the hit in Cincinnati: “[Shazier] went in there with his head down, and that’s never a good thing.”

Woodson spoke immediately after the game, on ESPN’s set at Paul Brown Stadium.

Advertise with us

“When you look at the play and you watch the way [Shazier] went in and hit him, this is a lesson to every player that plays the game, whether you’re young or old: Keep your head up,” Woodson said. “The way he came in with his head down, I’ve told players throughout my career that I see that — sometimes into piles and their heads are down — ‘Please, man, keep your head up.’ ”

Alarmingly, it seems more and more players have become torpedo-like tacklers. As Rich McKay, chairman of the league’s competition committee, said Tuesday, “We’re getting to a point where the technique is too dangerous.”

Here’s the problem: While change clearly is needed, it must begin on practice fields at all levels, not during games at the very highest level, where enforcing such a rule could prove impossible and deeply damaging to the sport.

In youth football, change already has begun, actually. About six years ago, USA Football launched its “Heads Up Football” initiative. Mike Tomlin was a spokesman, using the line, “Don’t hit the head. Don’t use the head.”

But in the NFL, where players move at such ridiculously high speeds? How are on-field officials going to judge whether a player struck illegally with the crown of his helmet or legally with the “hairline,” just above the facemask?

Advertise with us

Commissioner Roger Goodell has talked about using replay officials to monitor the change. Does he realize how many plays could be subject to review? Games will never end.

Will the rule be applied to running backs, who often lower their head before contact, and quarterbacks on sneak plays? How about pulling blockers? This is like holding in that one could find an instance of it on dozens of plays per game. Its impact could rival some of the biggest rules changes in football history, and not in a good way.

Are you prepared to throw star players out of games, and what, exactly, will prompt an ejection as compared with a 15-yard penalty?

The NFL tried to crack down on crown-first hits back in 2013. It didn’t work, whether the object was to quiet all the concussion talk or get players to change. This won’t, either.

This is a terrible idea, no matter how well-intentioned it might be.

Joe Starkey: jstarkey@post-gazette.com and Twitter @joestarkey1. Joe Starkey can be heard on the "Starkey and Mueller" show weekdays from 2-6 p.m. on 93.7 The Fan.