Welcome to Joe Starkey’s mailbag, where the Post-Gazette columnist and 93.7 The Fan radio host answers your questions about sports, life, Pink, Buffalo and everything in between. If you want to ask Joe a question, tweet him @JoeStarkey1 or email him at jstarkey@post-gazette.com. On to the questions …
Let’s start again with our ever-popular Twitter Polls segment …
The first question is courtesy of JosABank (@theJoshBanks): If every team that played Pitt in the ACC tournament could only use 4 players at a time, would you pick the Panthers to win the tournament? (837 votes at last check):
• Yes (12%)
• No (88%)
What we learned: One, that our friend Mr. Banks can whip up a nice poll question. Two, that everybody saw Pitt go 0-18 in the ACC and only three times come within double digits ... and make a serious argument as the worst ACC team of all-time.
Read More
Before we dive into that possibility, I’ll say this: I honestly believe Pitt would not win this tournament under the scenario above, which would basically put them on the power play the whole time. I’ll take Duke’s best four, for example, over Pitt’s five. Sad but true.
Now, to the larger question: Is Pitt the worst ACC team of all-time?
Adam Powell of ACCsports.com tackled this question a little more than a month (and many losses) ago:
“Over the entire history of the ACC, there are at least a couple teams out there that this Panthers squad could probably beat. One would have to be Clemson’s initial entries in the ACC in the league’s first two regular seasons of 1953-54 and 1954-55. It’s safe to say that Clemson was invited into the ACC from the Southern Conference because of Frank Howard’s football team, and not because of Banks McFadden’s basketball squad.
The 1953-54 and 1954-55 Tiger squads posted two of the ACC’s seven all-time winless ACC regular seasons, dropping 23 straight league games. Clemson’s streak reached 26 straight ACC losses before the Tigers finally beat Virginia for its first-ever ACC win on December 16, 1955 at the old Clemson Field House.
Georgia Tech went winless in its second full season in the ACC, going 0-14 back in 1980-81. But the Yellow Jackets were soon on the move under Bobby Cremins, winning the ACC Tournament and reaching the Elite Eight just four years later. Wake Forest had an 0-14 season in 1985-86, leading up to Maryland’s collapse the following year following Len Bias’ death and Lefty Driesell’s departure from College Park. Boston College was the latest winless ACC men’s basketball team two years ago.”
So it’s a tough call. That BC team also only came within double digits only three times. But I’ll say this: If Pitt upsets Notre Dame today (at last check, it’s scheduled to be a five-on-five), they will forever escape this painful conversation.
Question (courtesy of 93.7 The Fan): Kevin Colbert says the team isn't interested in trading Martavis Bryant. Do you think they should be shopping him (666 votes)?
• Yes (49%)
• No (51%)
What we learned: That fans are split on Martavis Bryant, and for good reason. Kevin Colbert was asked about making trade calls and couldn’t shoot it down fast enough — adding an “ever” to “never” on whether the Steelers ever made such a call (doth he protest too much?). Some have dismissed the idea of even listening to a trade offer as folly. Why wouldn’t you listen? Bryant isn’t likely to be happy this year, either, because he will likely start as a third option and definitely as the third-most-popular personality among receivers. And he wasn’t exactly Randy Moss on the field last year. Obviously, it’s in his best interests to be a good team player in his contract year and set himself up to make some money on the open market, but this just in: Bryant doesn’t always act in his best interests. Maybe he could fall asleep in team meetings and James Harrison his way out of town.
Scott Markovich, @MakrovichScott: There’s an old saying, running backs coming off of 400 touch seasons usually average more yards per carry the following year. Have you heard that saying?
Starkey: I’m sensing a touch of sarcasm, Dr. Markovich, as it relates to whether you think the Steelers should bring back Le’Veon Bell for big money. You shouldn’t be so harsh. Know why? Because I can give you lots of examples of such a thing happening.
Here we go …
LaDainian Tomlinson had a 400-touch season in 2002 and averaged more yards per carry the next year (also had a 398-touch season in 2001 and averaged more in 2002). … Marshall Faulk had a 400-touch season in 1998 and averaged 1.4 more yards per carry in 1999. … Thurman Thomas had a 400-touch season in 1993 and averaged more per carry the following year. … Eric Dickerson 1983 to 1984. … Emmitt Smith ’92 to 93. … Edgerrin James 1999 to 2000. … Walter Payton ’84 to 85. … Curtis Martin ’98 to ’99. … Terrell Davis ’97 to ’98. Would you like me to keep going?
Didn’t think so.
OK, rapid fire …
Big Ry (TM), @Ryan Schilinski: What’s the over/under on how long after the Pitt game Stallings is fired?
Starkey: 1.5 seconds. Heather Lyke might be at the end of the Notre Dame handshake line with a pink slip in her hand.
Chris Hawthorne, @Hawthorneee: Joe, how do you plan on using your extra hour of daylight starting next week.
Starkey: Whiffleball practice.
Brian Truscott, @Kamjor: Just read Tales from the Locker Room. Loved it! Anything else in the works?
Starkey: Thank you Brian! Not yet — although I would love to write a book on Troy Polamalu or Hines Ward. I also have this wild idea of traveling around the country and doing a book on basketball hoops and the stories behind them — from asphalt city hoops to nailed-on-barn country hoops. Who played there? What did it mean to the people who played? How did their games develop based on the physical circumstance? (for example, I had to arc my shot way over an electrical wire in our driveway, and for a while a tree cut out any shots from right corner, so I went left corner). … Anyway, that one might take some time!
yinz, @chuckybuckle22: After the week in Florida and turning muellsy into the Savy young Newshound do you now expect invitations to all the gatherings at his home?
Starkey: No.
Matt Sabol, @MattTSabol: If bobble heads were made of you and @ChrisMuellerPGH , what would they look like and which would be more popular?
Starkey: His would be converted Yoga balls to encompass both the raw size of his cranium and his massive ego. Mine would be more popular.
Chris Lisowski, @sowski99: would you trade Lev Bell to Cleveland for this years draft pick to get Barkley?
Starkey: Of course. But why would the Browns?
Yes, I know: Because they’re the Browns.
Thanks, kiddies. Be sure to insult Sean Gentille this week. Also, send me questions (tweet @JoeStarkey1 or email at jstarkey@post-gazette.com).




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.