Welcome to Joe Starkey’s mailbag, where the Post-Gazette columnist and 93.7 The Fan radio host answers your questions about sports, life, Pink, Buffalo and everything in between. If you want to ask Joe a question, tweet him @JoeStarkey1 or email him at jstarkey@post-gazette.com. On to the questions …

gingerthug, @gingerthug2: I’ve been arguing on Facebook I say Jesse James is better than McDonald. People think I’m crazy but at least James is there for u every game…what say you?

Starkey: I say you’ve raised a compelling question, Mr. gingerthug2, and I’m wondering if Vance McDonald’s pending $4.3 million cap hit is worth the trouble. The Steelers could cut him by April 1 at no penalty.

Then again, I’m wondering if James’s near-$2 million cap hit is worth the trouble.

Advertise with us

Let’s just say neither guy is Gronk.

But if you’re asking me to compare them, let’s start with the facts: McDonald is a more explosive receiver and a much better blocker. James is a more dependable receiver, and, as you pointed out, more reliable in the health department. James has played all 32 games the past two seasons and played through some major issues this year.

McDonald also battled through injuries, but he missed several games and has never played a full NFL season.

As far as stats go, McDonald made 14 catches in 10 games and had 82 yards after-the-catch (YAC), for an average of 5.9 per, according to foxsports.com. He also had three drops on 24 targets.

James basically tackles himself upon the catch. He had just 180 YAC yards on 43 catches (4.2). But he also had just two drops on 63 targets. You might remember one of those “drops.” It may well have cost the Steelers a Super Bowl trip.

Advertise with us

If you’re telling me both are healthy, I’ll take McDonald. But how often can you tell me he’s healthy?

McDonald practically outdid his whole season in the Jacksonville playoff game, reeling in 10 catches (on 16 targets) for 112 yards. That kind of performance makes one salivate at the possibilities. But he has an injury history that dates to college, when he had two shoulder surgeries and missed three games in his final year on account of a toe issue.

Honestly, I might be looking at the draft for a new and much cheaper tight end. The problem there is the Steelers need help on defense.

So, in the end, Mr. gingerthug2, I get to keep one guy? I keep McDonald (and my fingers crossed).

OK, let’s go rapid-fire …

Advertise with us

Kraig_the_real_409, @the_409: Are you spending quality time outside today? It’s pretty warm out

Starkey: Thank you for the newsflash, Mr. Kraig_the_real_409. Yes I spent time outside walking my dog, Bailey, although he seems to like to run, so we ran short wind sprints with him on a leash. In other words, he walked me.

yinz, @chuckybuckle22: Do you sing to your dog if so what songs?

Starkey: I do. See here in this Facebook video.

Robert Egan, @Robdogg039: the question I have is how many days will the Pirates spend over .500 this season .. I’m gonna say 0

Advertise with us

Starkey: I’m gonna say that sounds reasonable.

MFH, @FakeHoltzy22: What move did Huntington make that you’ll look back on and say that was the move that made them World Series Champions in 2018?

Starkey: Nava (not to be confused with Nova).

BrutallyHonestGamer: Greetings Joe, when do u think “mutton” will make its comeback for the Mueller nickname?

Starkey: Never. Mullsy did not take kindly to it, although it was a brilliant moniker concocted by one Josh Miller. A “mutton” is a lamb chop, described as tough on the outside, tender on the inside, which perfectly describes our friend. But that nickname is as far gone in 93.7 The Fan annals as Vinnie Richichi’s “God willing and if the crick don’t rise.”

Advertise with us

Speaking of which, here is a photo featuring myself, Josh, Vinnie and Chris Resop, one that I have no memory of and I’ll bet you weren’t expected to see today.

Joe D, @jdidomomic: Can distaste for ownership and management have a positive effect on Pirates players’ performance this year?

Starkey: No.

Bob King, @BattleshipBob: Is Tomlin anywhere near being on the ‘hot seat’?

Starkey: Tomlin is as close to being on the ‘hot seat’ as Mullsy is to achieving Dalai Lama-like humility.

Advertise with us

Rob Brugnoli, @RobBrugnoli: Maybe a weird question but here goes. I remember at one time when televising hockey, they would help TV viewers follow the puck with a blue superimposed thing much like they do in following a golf shot. Why not do that today enabling TV watchers a better view of puck play?

Starkey: This reminds me of countless nights watching the Buffalo Sabres and hearing my dad exclaim, at least 30 times per game, “I can’t see the damn puck!” I actually loved the glowing puck, Mr. Brugnoli, but televisions have become so advanced that I no longer have trouble following it. Do you?

Now for our Weekly Polls segment, which is growing in popularity at a rate commensurate to Zach Aston-Reese …

Question 1, courtesy of 93.7 The Fan (625 votes): Would you be willing to trade Daniel Sprong at the deadline this year:

• Yes (60%)

Advertise with us

•  No (40%)

What we learned: That people are itching for Jim Rutherford to make a big deal and do not care if a future 40-goal scorer (maybe) is sacrificed in the process. And you know what? If it means Brassard, I’m not sure I care, either, although I’d rather sacrifice goaltending prospect Filip Gustavsson for a Brassard-like upgrade.

Question 2 (1,556 votes): Mullsy claims the week begins on Sunday, not Monday (although he says the “work week” begins on Monday). The week begins Sunday? Mullsy is ...

• Delusional (32%)

• Correct (68%)

Advertise with us

What we learned: OK, so U.S. calendars say Sunday is the start of the week. Who cares? That’s not what I asked. Everybody knows the week begins Monday. Look, Mullsy was very proud of his win, and the last thing I want to do is ruin his moment. But I will continue to abide by the calendar of my native land, Ireland, and you can see here what’s up with my peeps:

Question 3, again courtesy of 93.7 The Fan (1,758 votes): Pitt fans, who would you rather have a regular rivalry with?

• West Virginia (51%)

• Penn State (49%)

What we learned: PItt fans are smart. I love both rivalries, and both should be played every year (Oh My God, You Can’t Play Two Rivalry Games Every Year And Here’s The List of Excuses As To Why Not), but Penn State would rather play San Jose State, so there’s only so much you can do there. West Virginia, on the other hand, should be the Kickoff Classic every single year for the rest of time. These schools are right up the road from each other with a century-plus of history. It’s ridiculous they don’t play every season. Please get on the phone, Heather Lyke and Shane Lyons, and make this happen.

Thanks, kiddies. Be sure to insult Sean Gentille this week. Also, send me questions (tweet @JoeStarkey1 or email at jstarkey@post-gazette.com).