Todd Haley did a good job here, just not as good as he thinks. I would give him a “B” or “B-” for his six-year run as Steelers offensive coordinator.
Based on remarks from his introductory news conference in Cleveland, Haley would give himself an “A+++.”
Reflecting on his time here, he said, “I was brought in to do a job. I feel I did that job, or more.”
Or more?
Somebody should remind Haley that the Steelers won zero championships in his tenure, and, in a related matter, produced fewer than 20 points five times in seven playoff games.
That’s less, not more. Haley’s offense even had a rare touchdown-free playoff game in Kansas City two years ago.
Somebody also should show Haley the following chart, comparing his postseason resume here to that of his predecessor, Bruce Arians.
Subtracting points for defensive and special teams scores, it reads like this:
Arians, 8 games, 23.6 points per game;
Haley, 7 games, 22.3 ppg.
I’m not suggesting Arians was the better coach, and I realize he enjoyed all the benefits of a much better Steelers defense. But Haley, for the most part, had the benefit of a superior offensive line and better skill players.
Haley’s postseason totals include the most unimpressive 42-point playoff game on record. It was marred by a brutal start and two fourth-and-1 disasters (with no fullback on the field). It was artificially enhanced — at least when rating the coordinator’s performance — by a bunch of spectacular playground plays (fourth-and-long heaves for touchdowns long after the game plan was tossed) and a meaningless touchdown with one second left.
It’s true the Steelers went into several of Haley’s seven playoff games missing key components. But he always had quarterback Ben Roethlisberger. Behold the point totals, in reverse order starting with Jacksonville: 42, 17, 18, 30, 16, 18, 17.
In three of those games, Haley’s offense managed one touchdown or none.
Now let’s look at New England’s past seven playoff games. They also had some injury issues, including the absence of Rob Gronkowski for all of last year’s playoffs: 33, 24, 35, 34, 36, 34, 18.
Haley’s offenses finished in the top 10 in scoring four times in six years, in the top five once. Not bad, but at least what you would expect given the talent on hand. His red-zone offense (touchdown percentage) remained an issue throughout his tenure, never finishing higher than 12th.
Like Arians, Haley had a system that allowed talented players to produce huge numbers. He also helped the Steelers execute their multi-faceted plan to usher Roethlisberger safely into his late-30s.
There is no doubt Roethlisberger gets rid of the ball faster these days and takes far fewer hits. But don’t you think that has something to do with Roethlisberger himself deciding to play differently because he can no longer run around like a maniac?
It also helps to have an offensive line teeming with studs, compared to the one with which Roethlisberger and Arians won a Super Bowl— the one that featured Justin Hartwig, Darnell Stapleton, Chris Kemoeatu, Willie Colon and Max Starks (no offense to any of them).
Haley also seemed to take plenty of credit for developing Antonio Brown.
“When I got there, Antonio Brown wasn’t the Antonio Brown everybody knows,” Haley said. “There was great development there.”
I’m thinking A.B. would have blossomed either way — he’s pretty focused on his craft — but Haley probably had something to do with it.
Just not as much as he thinks.
Joe Starkey: jstarkey@post-gazette.com and Twitter @joestarkey1. Joe Starkey can be heard on the “Starkey and Mueller” show weekdays from 2-6 p.m. on 93.7 The Fan.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.