Welcome to Joe Starkey’s weekly mailbag, where the Post-Gazette columnist and 93.7 The Fan radio host answers your questions about sports, life, Buffalo, Bob Dylan and everything in between. If you want to ask Joe a question, tweet him @JoeStarkey1 or email him at jstarkey@post-gazette.com. On to the questions:
JosABanks, @theJoshBanks: Has the Neal Huntington era run its course in Pittsburgh?
Starkey: No, to use a single word Mr. Banks. But before I elaborate on that, I must ask this: How incredible was it to see positive reaction, even a little, to the Pirates’ do-nothing deadline, which followed a do-nothing four months from management?
Here you have a team 5½ games out of first place, about to embark on an eight-game homestand and still with seven games left against the division-leading Cubs, and it’s OK to crawl under a desk on deadline day?
What?
Whatever happened to competing?
Read More
If the Pirates go 6-2 on this homestand and shave a game or two off the Cubs’ lead, it could get interesting. But are we going to see John Jaso continue to run out to right field? He hasn’t had a hit since Senquez Golson was healthy. And wouldn’t a front-line pitcher with some controllable years (Jose Quintana weeks ago, Sonny Gray the other day) have provided a huge boost?
When the epitaph of the 2017 Pirates is written — and it likely will be written — it must begin with the fact that the players killed the season, starting with Starling Marte, Tony Watson and Jung-Ho Kang. But let it be said that Huntington basically stood there and watched the patient die. He did nothing to help. He has not done one thing to help the 2017 Pirates since Opening Day. It’s amazing.
What’s more amazing is that the bar is so low among the brainwashed that merely keeping the biggest stars on the team (Gerrit Cole, Andrew McCutchen) became reason for praise.
“Hey, Huntington’s best move was no move. That’s how he helped the team!”
How many kegs of Bucco Kool-Aid do you have to guzzle before you start thinking that way?
But here is a truth Bob Nutting must accept: Thousands have escaped the cult. Pirates’ attendance has plummeted for a second consecutive season, on pace for the largest drop since 2002, and TV ratings, while still good compared to the rest of the league, are crashing for a second consecutive year.
Pirates fans are mad as hell, and they’re aren’t going to take it anymore.
PG Live: Pirates deal Watson at MLB trade deadline
Joe Starkey, JoeStarkey1: Yeah, but what about Huntington?
Starkey: Oh yes. Huntington. What an odd dynamic between him and his team.
Let me explain.
The basic question leading up to the deadline went something like this: Can the Pirates convince Huntington that they are a legit contender and thus worthy of supplements? That’s a bad question, because it implies that Huntington is nothing more than a bystander, waiting innocently to see if the team proves something to him. As if he is a separate entity — and it was interesting to listen to his radio show Sunday and hear him refer to the ballclub as “they” a couple of times before correcting himself to say “we.”
The way he has operated this season, “they” would have been more appropriate. Why couldn’t the GM step in and help HIS TEAM convince him it was a contender?
All of that being said, Mr. Banks, I tend to look at the big picture. The entire resume. And it speaks to a GM who tore this organization to the ground and built it back up to become a contender. Next year looks somewhat promising, too. I can’t just blow that off and not extend him if I’m Nutting — especially if I am the one (Nutting) who keeps him in financial handcuffs.
On the other hand, these past two years have not exactly been a resume builder. Huntington was brilliant at last year’s trade deadline. He also built a nice bench last season. But he ruined last year’s rotation at the start and never fixed it. His bullpen acquisitions beyond Felipe Rivero have been questionable. The Jaso signing has not panned out — and he keeps making friends, doesn’t he.
Most importantly, as this year’s team struggled in various capacities, the GM just sat there. He then crawled under his desk at the deadline, at the start of an eight-game homestand with his team 5½ games out with two-plus months left in the season.
Dave Awesome, @Handsomestrangr: To which team do you recommend I switch my baseball allegiance?
Starkey: Well, Mr. Handsomestrangr, I can highly recommend the Blue Jays. They stink, but they still have several ex-Pirates, including Russell Martin, a cozy ballpark flanked by the CN Tower — where I made the mistake of ordering a “Zombie” at my senior prom in 1983 — and a horribly wonderful seventh-inning stretch song:
Plus, they play in Toronto.
Other candidates:
• Cleveland Indians: Terry Francona’s an easy guy to root for, if you can look past the Cleveland thing.
• New York Yankees: Free yourself. Root for the financial behemoth. Don’t be ashamed.
• San Diego Padres: Young and fun. They even run out grounders part of the time, unlike most teams.
• New York Mets: Neil Walker.
• Baltimore Orioles: Nice ballpark, easy drive, still trying to win at deadline.
Eric Conti, @ConMan83: How much of the money saved with Jung Ho and Marte have the Pirates spent?
Starkey: I’m sure they’ll tell you it was spent wisely, Mr. ConMan83. The brainwashed are still praising them for “using the money they saved on Liriano to sign Freese and Nova.”
Do you realize how pathetically laughable that is?
Freese — who has homered once since June 6 and is unqualified to be a cleanup man — and Nova were relatively minor signings by major-league standards. Pittances. Nova is the 53rd-highest-paid starting pitcher in baseball at $7.6 million. Freese makes a million less. The Pirates should have been able and willing to sign both and others of the same ilk whether they unloaded Liriano’s contract or not.
They also should have traded for Jay Bruce when Gregory Polanco went down, but I’m guessing the $4.3 million left on his salary was too much for Nutting to bear.
MFH, @FakeHoltzy22: How will you remember the Seth McGarry era?
Starkey: Fondly, for sure, Mr. FakeHoltzy. You?
Michael Cramer, @mcramer: If you can trade anybody on @937theFan, who would you trade and who would you want back?
Starkey: Mullsy for cash. Or whatever’s in your change drawer.
Thanks, kiddies. Be sure to insult Sean Gentille this week. Also, send me questions (tweet @JoeStarkey1 or email at jstarkey@post-gazette.com).






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.