I have no idea who’ll be discussed in the “builders” category when the 18-member Hockey Hall of Fame Selection Committee convenes June 26 in Toronto — these things aren’t publicized — but if Jim Rutherford isn’t at the top of that list, somebody made a mistake. Somebody needs to put him there.
It’s time.
Rutherford, based on precedent and pure accomplishment, belongs with the great builders of his era. Maybe any era. And he belongs now. He turns 69 next season. Craig Patrick was 55 when he was inducted in 2001. Lou Lamoriello was 66 when he was inducted in 2009. Jim Devellano (four Cups in Detroit) was 66. Bill Torrey (Islanders dynasty) was 61.
Rutherford is the only post-1967-expansion general manager to win Cups with different teams. A mere eight GMs in league history have won more championships than his three. Four of them — Jack Adams, Conn Smythe, Frank Selke and Art Ross — have trophies named after them, and they didn’t have to top 29 other teams.
How about the “Jim Rutherford Award” commemorating the NHL’s trade of the year? Because it’s his expert wheeling and dealing that has led directly to back-to-back Cups.
As much as the GM position has changed, one aspect remains the same, and it is one Rutherford has mastered …
Read More
“The lost art of making a hockey deal,” said USA Today’s Kevin Allen, who believes Rutherford belongs in the Hall ASAP. “I don’t think there’s any question Jim is in the top two traders of this generation of GMs. The only guy in his category is (Nashville GM) David Poile. It seems like Jim has been a guy who makes deals that make both parties happy — but he always seems to benefit the most.”
Before we look at Rutherford’s finest moves here, let’s acknowledge the unsung aspect of his career: his Carolina tenure. Talk about a “builder.” Rutherford made hockey matter in NASCAR country when he chaperoned the Hartford Whalers into North Carolina in 1997.
“It’s tough enough just to bring a hockey franchise to the south,” said Predators assistant coach Kevin McCarthy, who worked for Rutherford in Carolina. “Then you think about success he had so quickly — the Cup finals in 2002, winning a Cup in ’06. They went to the Eastern Conference finals in ’09. That’s pretty impressive for that franchise. I think people tend to forget that.”
Indisputably, Rutherford got off to a rough start here. He hired the wrong coach. He brought in a Rob Klinkhammer here, a Daniel Winnik there, a David Perron here, a Sergei Plotnikov there.
But you know what he specializes in? Coolly correcting his mistakes. Or as Scotty Bowman — a member of the HOF Selection Committee — told me two weeks ago, “He doesn’t get rattled.”
Mike Johnston gave way to Mike Sullivan, Perron begat Carl Hagelin, and so on.
In compiling a list of Rutherford’s best moves, I figured 10 would be too many. I’d be reaching. Turns out I’m leaving the likes of Ben Lovejoy on the cutting-room floor.
I’m not reaching. I’m editing.
So here we go: Rutherford’s Top 10 moves, in descending order, with a big tap of the stick to Penguins CEO David Morehouse, who made the initial contact with Trader Jim three years ago:
10. Ron Hainsey from Carolina for a second-round pick and Danny Kristo: Might have been a Cup clincher. Hainsey was second on the team in playoff ice time (and even threw in the occasional end-to-end rush).
9. Trevor Daley from Chicago for Rob Scuderi: Daley is coming off a hugely effective and consistent playoff. Scuderi plays for the Ontario Reign.
8. Carl Hagelin from Anaheim for David Perron and Adam Clendening. Who cares what Hagelin does in the regular season? Big-game player. Elite speed. I’m guessing you saw him activate the jet packs on that Cup-sealing goal.
7. Ian Cole from St. Louis for Robert Bortuzzo and a seventh-round pick. Unless that seventh-round pick becomes Patric Hornqvist II, this was a monumental heist.
6. Justin Schultz from Edmonton for a third-round pick. Canadian media mocked the deal. Schultz has become a borderline star. This also qualifies as two moves in one, as Rutherford convinced Schultz to stay when he could have signed a bigger deal elsewhere.
5. Matt Cullen from the scrap heap, for one year and $800,000 Aug. 6, 2015. Another two-for-one, as Rutherford waited out Cullen last summer, too.
One more year?
4. Nick Bonino, Clendening and a second-round pick from Vancouver for Brandon Sutter and a third-round pick. Did this actually happen? Bonino became a Penguins legend (and still hasn’t shaved his playoff beard).
3. Phil Kessel from Toronto for a bunch of things. I feel compelled to bring up Peter Karmanos Jr., Rutherford’s old boss in Carolina, and his initial take on the deal, where he tore Rutherford to shreds: “I do not have to take responsibility for Pittsburgh signing Kessel. … Kessel may score as many goals as Alex Semin did [in Carolina].”
Actually, Kessel has scored more playoff goals than any player in the league (18) the past two years, and Toronto’s still paying part of his salary.
Good call, Pete.
2. Hornqvist from Nashville for James Neal and Nick Spaling: “He’ll help in the playoffs,” Rutherford prophetically predicted of Hornqvist, a player who changed the Penguins’ personality on his way to scoring Cup-sealing (last year) and Cup-winning (this year) goals.
Oh, and Spaling was spun into part of the package for Kessel.
1. Mike Sullivan. Best coach in Penguins history.
Rutherford has been so good that even deals he initially regrets (Lovejoy for Simon Despres) work out. So good that he unwittingly helped the Penguins before he got here, sending along Brian Dumoulin from Carolina’s farm system in the Jordan Staal trade. So good that he even makes good deals with fans.
Remember what he said at last year’s parade?
“I’ll try to make one deal with you,” Rutherford said, “We’ll try to meet here at this time next year.”
It’s becoming a habit.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.