I’m not sure what people were watching in Game 4. I saw Phil Kessel creating scoring chances. Doing what he is paid to do. He easily could have had a three- or four-point night.

That was Kessel sending Chris Kunitz on a breakaway with a tape-to-tape touchdown pass.

That was Kessel dancing over the blue line on a second-period power play and deftly leading Sidney Crosby into a grade-A chance.

That was Kessel, too, on that same power play, making a ridiculous cross-rink pass to Evgeni Malkin, who then fed Jake Guentzel for what easily could have been a tap-in.

Advertise with us

And that was Kessel narrowly missing twice with that wicked quick-release shot, part of his team-best eight attempted shots (though only two hit net).

“I think if we get the same shots again,” Kessel said, “it could be a different story.”

I’m betting one of them goes in at a big moment — for Kessel or the person he sets up — before this increasingly tense Stanley Cup final is decided. I’m betting on Kessel, because betting on Kessel in big moments, no matter what his critics tell you, is the smart play.

“He’s like ice,” Malkin said, as only Malkin can.

The critics are chirping, by the way, jumping on the fact that Kessel has no goals in six games and two in 13. I get the distinct feeling some want him to fail. People don’t like to be wrong, and Kessel made a lot of people wrong last spring.

Advertise with us

And he is an easy target. Maybe it’s because he doesn’t look like the typical professional athlete, so people feel like they can pick on him. Maybe it’s the fact he hates talking to the media (though he finally succumbed Wednesday, with a push from the Penguins public relations staff).

One of the more ridiculous criticisms is the one that goes, “Kessel gets paid to score goals, not be a playmaker.”

What?

Kessel led the Penguins in assists this season. He’s a gifted playmaker. There’s a reason he has the puck on that left wall on the power play all the time, and it’s not just to shoot, although he could let it fly more often.

Listening to the complaints, you’d never know Kessel was tied for third in the league in playoff scoring. Or that he is ninth among active players in postseason points per game, just behind Alex Ovechkin and just ahead of Henrik Zetterberg, Jonathan Toews and Anze Kopitar.

Advertise with us

He’s also sixth among active players in postseason goals per game, ahead of Patrick Kane, Crosby and Malkin.

Kessel is flawed. We all know that. He won’t be getting Selke votes anytime soon. He can drive you crazy. The trick is to accept for him for who he is and be happy to have him — especially at this time of year, because he usually saves his best hockey for the right time.

That was true in brief playoff stints in Boston and Toronto. It was true here last season. It was true when he was named the tournament’s best forward at the Sochi Olympics.

Shoot, it was true when Kessel was a kid. Doing research for a Patric Hornqvist piece, I stumbled upon some remarkable numbers from the 2005 World Under-18 Championships. Kessel doubled the next-best player’s output with 16 points (nine goals) in just six games, leading the United States to finish with smashing wins against Sweden and Canada (combined score: 11-3).

“It starts with him doing it since he was 7 years old,” teammate Carl Hagelin said. “I think that’s just part of him, part of the Phil Kessel lifestyle — that when it really comes down to the wire, he’s going to be there for his teammates.”

Advertise with us

Kessel’s take on pressure: “I just kind of do whatever I do, you know? Play my game.”

So as we go into a best-of-3 with the Stanley Cup at stake, let’s remember a few things:

• It’s not just about whether Phil Kessel scores a goal. Or any of the stars. The Penguins won the Cup in 2009 without Crosby or Malkin scoring in the final three games. Depth matters. Conor Sheary (one goal in 20 games), Carl Hagelin (none in nine), Hornqvist (none in five), Bryan Rust (none in six), Matt Cullen (none in six, one in 16), Chris Kunitz, Carter Rowney (none in 18) or anyone on defense is allowed to chip in.

• That being said, with everything on the line starting Thursday, there aren’t many guys on either side I’d take over Phil Kessel.

He’s like ice.

Joe Starkey: jstarkey@post-gazette.com and Twitter @joestarkey1. Joe Starkey can be heard on the “Starkey and Mueller” show weekdays from 2-6 p.m. on 93.7 The Fan.