Welcome to Joe Starkey’s weekly mailbag, where the Post-Gazette columnist and 93.7 The Fan radio host answers your questions about sports, life, Buffalo, Bob Dylan and everything in between. If you want to ask Joe a question, tweet him @JoeStarkey1 or email him at jstarkey@post-gazette.com. On to the questions:
YinzYap @yinzyap: Does Sauce deserve his name on the Stanley Cup?
Starkey: By “Sauce,” Mr. YinzYap, you mean the Penguins’ legendary, yet somehow still unknown video coach, Andy Saucier. And he already has his name on the Cup.
Saucier, in fact, might have won this team a Cup last season and darned if he didn’t make the biggest play of Game 1 of the Stanley Cup final Monday night. And yet, to my knowledge, his name wasn’t mentioned once on the NBC broadcast.
First, the particulars: Saucier last year spotted Jonathan Drouin’s skate a few inches offside after what apparently was the first goal in Game 6 of the Eastern Conference final. He quickly radioed assistant coach Rick Tocchet on the bench. Tocchet relayed the information to coach Mike Sullivan, who asked for a challenge. The rest is history.
We all saw what happened Monday night, with Filip Forsberg playing the role of Drouin. A lengthy review indicated Forsberg’s right skate was in the air as he brought the puck into the zone (please don’t get me started on how replay is ruining sports, or how this is all we’d be talking about if it happened to the Penguins) on a play that led to a P.K. Subban goal.
Read More
Once again, Saucier was right, and less than three minutes later, Evgeni Malkin scored the game’s first goal.
How “Sauce” wasn’t named the first star, I’ll never know.
But who is this man? That’s the question.
I have some answers, which I will cull directly from my now-available book “Tales From The Pittsburgh Penguins Locker Room,” which happens to be available in bookstores, and, as luck would have it, right here:
As it turns out, “Sauce” has some deep Penguins ties. His grandfather Jack Kelley was Penguins president from 1993-98. His uncle Mark Kelley was the Penguins’ long-time European scout who advanced to vice president of amateur scouting for the three-time champion Chicago Blackhawks.
“I went to a couple of (Mark’s Stanley Cup) parties,” Saucier told centralmaine.com, “and was really in awe of the trophy.”
Those likely weren’t the only interesting parties Saucier attended. His uncle David Kelley (Mark’s brother) is an accomplished television writer and producer (”Ally McBeal” “Picket Fences” “Chicago Hope” “The Practice”) who is married to Michelle Pfeiffer.
I can never figure out family relational labels (I was just trying to tell somebody what I was to my wife’s niece’s husband — uncle-in-law? I have no idea), but clearly Andy Saucier is related to Michelle Pfeiffer, and that is a wonderful thing.
Just as clearly, Sullivan was on point when it was suggested to him late Monday that Saucier deserves a statue and he answered, “Well, maybe they’ll have a sandwich named after him or sauce or something, I don’t know. But he does a great job.”
If the sandwich or sauce hasn’t happened yet, it really should. And I will end with this: Saucier’s name is not pronounced “SAUCE-EE-AY” but rather something more like “SOCHER.” Which is kind of disappointing.
Nate Kepler, @Nskepler: How do we solve the Olli Maatta predicament?
Starkey: Which “predicament” might that be, Mr. Kepler? The fact that Olli leads all Penguins’ D-men in the playoffs with a plus-6 rating, plays more than 21 minutes per game and scored two gigantic goals in the Ottawa series?
Come on, man. I know Maatta, like Ron Hainsey, has a penchant for the spectacular mistake, but with both men, I would encourage you to look past that and to the big picture. And the big picture shows that both have played well in these playoffs. Especially at the most critical times.
I’m not sure if you saw my Scotty Bowman piece in the Post-Gazette on Saturday, but I asked Bowman if any under-the-radar Penguins jumped out to him. He immediately mentioned Maatta.
That’s enough for me. And remember, none of these guys would be playing such heavy minutes — and might be matched against lesser players — if it weren’t for Kris Letang’s injury. It’s truly a battle for survival on the blue line, and I happen to love the way guys such as Maatta and Hainsey are battling.
Incidentally, sort of as an addendum to the Andy Saucier name dilemma, I once asked Maatta how to pronounce his last name, and he surprised me by saying it’s actually “MAT-uh” — as in wrestling mat — rather than the popular”MAHD-uh”.
Just thought I would tell you that.
Laces out, Dan! @dkviper: How do your deadlines work when you’re handcuffed by print media? Not like other outlets who have no deadlines.
Starkey: First of all, tremendous handle there with “Laces out, Dan!”
My top three Jim Carrey movies:
• “Ace Ventura: Pet Detective”
• “Dumb and Dumber”
• “Liar, Liar” (an absolute tear jerker, and the scene where he rips everybody in the board room made my mom laugh harder than I’ve ever seen her laugh).
Secondly, I don’t have a deadline on the internet, just like any fan blog or website out there. I can work all night. I have a deadline for the first print edition, sometimes for a second print edition, and then it’s write for as long as I want. Same goes for the rest of the staff, and I can tell that no staff works harder or longer to give Penguins fans distinct and outstanding coverage.
For example, viper, I had plenty of time to write my Game 7 column in D.C. when the Penguins beat the Capitals in an incredible, historic win:
To review: No deadline for internet. Thanks for asking.
DrLabcoat, @DrLabcoatMD: Do you not reunite HBK? Can’t cover 3 lines with 4 defenseman. Plus you need Hags speed.
Starkey: It’s not the worst idea, DrLabcoat, but you probably noticed that when Mike Sullivan put HBK together earlier in the playoffs, it was the worst reunion since the Spice Girls in 2008.
The next question would be this: If you put Hagelin back in, who do you take out?
Patric Hornqvist didn’t stand out in Game 1, but he’s Patric Hornqvist, and he still drew a penalty. Carter Rowney or Scott Wilson? Those two, especially Wilson, had a physical presence, combining for 12 hits.
That said, I agree that Hagelin’s speed (and penalty killing prowess) would be a major asset.
Chris Cline, @Pburgh101Cline: What does “PK” in PK Subban stand for?
Starkey: First, let me say that I really enjoy watching P.K. Subban play hockey — and if you’re interested in his life story, by all means check out ESPN’s “E:60” profile of him from this past weekend. Tremendous stuff. It includes Subban singing a little Johnny Cash at a Nashville bar (side note: one time on a trip home from Wilkes-Barre when the Penguins spent a week of training camp there, Andrew Ference and Steiggy piled into my car, and I believe we listened to “Ring of Fire” 23 times).
As for his name, I present this from Stu Cowan from the Montreal Gazette in 2016: “P.K. got his name (Pernell Karl) because his mother liked Pernell Roberts, an actor on the old Bonanza TV show, and his father (Karl) liked Karl for obvious reasons. But Karl says his son has been called P.K. almost from the day he was born.”
Of course, this only makes me like the Subbans more, because I, too, was a big “Bonanza” fan, and I happen to be able to sing the lyrics to the theme song, written by Lorne Greene. Most people don’t know there were lyrics.
A sampling:
Up in the hills and the rocks and the trees Bonanzaaaa,
Pick a fight with any one of us, you’ve got a fight with me
Hoss and Joe, Adam know every rock and tree
Up in the hills the rocks and the trees Bonanzaaaa …
You can’t find that just anywhere.
jReck, @jason97782: OK OK. Is it true that #Pirates are 3½ games out of first on Memorial Day, closest they’ve been since 2013?
Starkey: Amazingly, Mr. jReck, you are correct: This is the closest to first place the Pirates have been on this date — easily — since they were two games out on May 30, 2013. The caveat, of course, is that they are in last place.
And here’s another treat for you: Since the beginning of the 2014 season, the Pirates have spent precisely five days alone in first place in the NL Central — all in April, all in the first week of the season.
Yinz n’at, @rollingStonesy: If someone told you the Pens would have 12 shots on goal, what would you say their chances of winning would be?
Starkey: About the same as a man throwing a catfish onto the ice at PPG Paints Arena, which brings us to …
Alex @HealthyPghNerd: Where do you hide an entire catfish to sneak it in to PPG?
Starkey: This is a wonderful question, Mr. HealthyPghNerd, and I must refer you to Sean Gentille’s exhaustive piece on just that subject. If this were Watergate, Gentille would be Bob Woodward and Carl Bernstein combined.
Let’s call him Bob Bernstein.
Thanks, kiddies. Be sure to insult Gentille this week. Especially this week. Also, send me questions (tweet @JoeStarkey1 or email at jraystarkey@gmail.com).






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.