The Stanley Cup final is many things — good things, mostly. For all of the league’s problems — all of its incompetence, all of its self-inflicted wounds — there’s something about the playoffs. There’s something about this series. We were lucky enough to start another one here Monday.
For a second, though, forget how pretty the overall picture can look, and marvel at the NHL’s limitless capacity to watch its own dumb decisions fuse with catastrophic luck. It’s funny because it has to be.
Not three hours after commissioner Gary Bettman sat at a table in PPG Paints Arena, praising the efficacy of the coach’s challenge rule for offside calls while skirting around the issue that makes people hate it in the first place, Game 1 of the final turned on that exact rule. It was the sporting equivalent of stepping on a rake and hitting yourself in the face.
Predators defenseman P.K. Subban seemed to score the first goal of the series at 7:31 of the first period, until he didn’t. Teammate Filip Forsberg’s skate was in the air above the ice beyond the blue line before he controlled the puck. It may have been. It probably was — though, throughout the four-minute video replay, nothing looked definitive. The blue line camera had been, apparently, replaced by one that came off an old Motorola Razr.
On the Clock: What to make of the NHL offside rule?
The ruling was the ruling. Debate it if you want. The bigger issue is that the rule is the rule — and it’s a very stupid one. The NHL, for whatever reason, only seems to enforce that particular brand. It’s the same sort of mindset that made concussion spotters unable to pull Sidney Crosby from Game 6 against Washington because his head hit the boards, not another player.
When you come across a stupid rule — one with loopholes or unintended consequences — you change it. It should be that simple for the NHL, but for whatever reason, it isn’t. The biggest reason: The league likes that a player’s skate can be offside when it isn’t on the ice.
Read More
“We hear the commentary, Well, it was just off-sides by a little bit. His skate was in the air,” Bettman said. “The fact of the matter is, it’s our job to make sure the rules are complied with, and the video replay through the Coach’s Challenge on offsides has worked exactly as we hoped it would. The rule is the rule. We enforce it.”
(This is not, for the record, any sort of complaint over Sullivan using the challenge. He’s got a wizard to rely on in video coach Andy Saucier, and he’s trying to win games. There’s a decent chance that Saucier, the brains behind the Jonathan Drouin review last postseason, was the only person in the building who thought Forsberg was offside. Like Sullivan said, he should have a sandwich named after him.)
The end results, though, are the exact sorts of pedantic debates that derail games, turn off casual fans and have enormous impacts on outcomes, all predicated on … what, exactly? Trying to discern literal inches between skates and ice through AOL-era webcam technology? That’s why we’re doing this?
After Subban’s goal was overturned, the Penguins scored three goals in 4:11. The review took longer. Penguins captain Sidney Crosby said the decision “gave us life.” He certainly seemed to be correct, and he wasn’t alone.
Love our Pens coverage? Consider subscribing.
Support journalism. Subscribe today.
“The impact of that moment, then the chain of events that happened after that with the penalty kills, I think changed the course of the game,” Predators coach Peter Laviolette said.
It’s a generally good rule of thumb that, if you have the chance to do something right, you should seize on it. Crosby said as much.
“I think with cameras and the way they have it, you have the opportunity to get it right, so we might as well. With one challenge, it’s one of those things where if you do use it, you lose your time out and get so-called punished in a way,” Crosby said. “But I don’t have a problem with it. As long as we have all the things to get it right, we might as well use it.”
Right. But we may not have all the things to get it right. So if you’re going to keep the coach’s challenge as part of the game — and it certainly seems like the league is committed to that — change the stupid, tough-to-enforce part of the rule. Say a player with his skate in the air is onside.
It’s the sort of decision the NHL could make tomorrow if it had the right vision and PR sensibilities. Instead, we’re all stuck hoping it doesn’t happen again.
Sean Gentille: sgentille@post-gazette.com





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.