Welcome to Joe Starkey’s weekly mailbag, where the Post-Gazette columnist and 93.7 The Fan radio host answers your questions about sports, life, Buffalo, Bob Dylan and everything in between. If you want to ask Joe a question, tweet him @JoeStarkey1 or email him at jstarkey@post-gazette.com.
On to an extended version of the mailbag as Game 7 beckons:
NY Groundhog, @NYGroundhog: If the Caps win the series and go on to win the Cup, will removing opponents from the lineup become even more prominent of a strategy?
Starkey: It always has been part of playoff strategy in the NHL, Mr. NYGroundhog, and I don’t necessarily mean in a Bountygate, premeditated kind of way. I just mean players hit to injure in the postseason. I had an ex-Penguins player tell me as much before the postseason began: Guys are hitting to hurt people this time of year.
Now, does that mean they routinely finish vicious blind-side crosschecks to the skull of an off-balance superstar? Not usually, and it brings up an even more interesting question: Did the Ovechkin/Niskanen ambush of Sidney Crosby prevent a Penguins sweep?
I would argue yes.
Read More
I would also argue the Capitals have outplayed the Penguins, territorially, in every game.
Both statements can be true.
I don’t think it’s much of a stretch, really, to suggest the Penguins would have swept. They did win three of the first four games, and their only loss was in overtime of Game 3 after they were rocked by Crosby’s stunning departure.
Crosby was at the very top of his game at that point, at his counter-punching best. He was brilliant in Games 1 and 2. I think it’s reasonable to suggest he would have been brilliant on home ice in Game 3.
What’s more, he clearly has not been the same since returning to the lineup, a situation compounded by two more blows to the head in Game 6. His pass to nowhere on a late power play was downright disturbing.
But there’s something else here, another clue that tells me the Penguins might well have swept. It also might be the reason the Capitals are, in all likelihood, about to win the series: Washington was getting swallowed up by its tragic playoff history as it returned to Pittsburgh for Game 3, and only by extending the series was it going to be able to contend with the issue.
I believe this Capitals team, unlike others, has embraced and accepted the fact that its history, be it recent or long-term, was poisonous — and was ruining this year’s playoff run. And like addicts who can only deal with a problem once they admit it, the Capitals finally admitted it. And did so quite publicly.
Consider defenseman Kevin Shattinkirk’s stunning quote prior to Game 5: “With the history in this locker room, what’s happened in the past, it can cause you to grip your stick a little bit tighter, cause you to just not make the normal plays that we’re capable of making.”
How about that?
This was T.J. Oshie after Game 6: “I think mentally was the biggest reason we weren’t achieving what we wanted to achieve. Even in the Toronto series, and then a couple games in this series, mentally we weren’t able to stay focused.”
Bingo.
Finally, consider this Barry Trotz quote from after Monday’s game: “We’ve grown through our past a little bit, I guess. I thought we’ve had a calmness since, I don’t know, probably Game 3. ... We’re having fun now.”
There’s no “I don’t know” or “probably” about it. The Capitals are different since Game 3. Yes, they were nearly buried in Game 5, too, but I don’t think they even get that far if Crosby isn’t smashed in the skull.
That hit, whatever you think of it, changed the series.
Jonathan, @jrayhay8: Would a fresh Mark Streit be just the veteran we need in the lineup?
Starkey: I’d put him in, Mr. @jrayhay8. I would consider him in favor of Chad Ruhwedel or perhaps as a seventh defensemen on a unit that appears to have worn down. But I would not consider him any kind of savior.
In 19 games with the Penguins, Streit was minus-2 with a goal and five assists. He had back-to-back disastrous games against Philly and Chicago. He’s 39. I will say this, though: He can move the puck. That alone should get him a hat for Game 7.
Gina Bogaski, @bogaski66: Since they have the momentum, and healthy team, wouldn’t you say pressure is on Caps?
Starkey: Yes, Gina, I would. Problem is, as I mentioned earlier, this Capitals team appears to have embraced the pressure.
But yes, when you’re the franchise that has never won a Cup and has folded numerous times in such situations — and when you’re the top seed playing at home against a wounded and reeling opponent — you better win Game 7.
MSF, @MSFerr1: Is Crosby concussed?
Starkey: I’m beginning to think, in a sadly ironic twist, that the people whose job it is to monitor head injuries are concussed, MSF.
Apparently, there were concussion spotters at PPG Paints Arena and centrally located in New York for Game 6. I cannot imagine what they were looking at when a recently concussed Crosby crashed headfirst into the boards in the first period and was slow to get up. If that’s not a time to remove a player from a game, at least temporarily, I don’t know what is.
Thomas Zielke @ThomasZielke: Can Francisco Cervelli skate?
Starkey: I’m more concerned with whether he can hit, Mr. Zielke. But I’m sure if he could skate, he would play through an injured foot at the World Cup of Hockey.
Dennis, @touchasarcasm: If the Pens game was not bad enough, turned on the Pirates game, want to throw my TV off the Ninth Street Bridge.
Starkey: I feel you, Mr. @touchasarcasm. Monday was a very bad night for Pittsburgh sports fans. But there’s always the Riverhounds.
I hope you talked your TV off the ledge.
Joe Scherer, @joe_scherer24: Hainsey for Game 7? He’s been their worst defenseman the last three games.
Starkey: I wouldn’t disagree, Joe, although Hainsey’s had plenty of competition for that award. The play where Burakovsky knocked him off the puck — and to the ice — was comically painful. But I’m not sure I’d take Hainsey out of the lineup. I’d probably go with seven D-men.
Two other notes on the Penguins’ defense:
• I think it’s pretty clear why Kris Letang could have and maybe should have won the Conn Smythe Trophy last year. Kinda helps when a guy plays half the game and repeatedly breaks out of the zone by himself.
• Justin Schultz has regressed in the playoffs. I think Schultz played way too much in March and April and then became a target for the Capitals and Blue Jackets. He’s a shell of himself.
J.D. Haltigan @JDHaltigan: Joe, if you were stunned the Pens didn’t end it in 5, what are you now? Pens looked outclassed (Monday).
Starkey: I wrote that I was “stunned” in my column from Game 5, because the Penguins led going into the third period and were 76-1-1 in such situations since the start of last season, J.D. (and did you know the Buffalo Bills once had a receiver named J.D. Hill?)
So yeah, combine that with Washington’s precarious mindset, and I was stunned the Penguins didn’t finish.
Now I’d be stunned if they did.
Colby N. Wood @Colbynwood: Has there ever been a goalie to lose three separate series when his team was up 3 games to 1?
Starkey: I’m not sure about that, Colby, but let’s be real here: The Penguins might not have made it out of Round 1 if not for Marc-Andre Fleury, and they might already be gone from Round 2.
Here’s a playoff truth: Goalies almost never “steal” the Stanley Cup. The last two who came close — who overcame the fact their teams were routinely outplayed — were Henrik Lundqvist and Dominik Hasek in Buffalo (Hull was in the crease). The Penguins have relied far too much on their goalie. I felt going into Game 6 that they were going to have to prove they could kick their game to another gear. They couldn’t.
No goalie was going to win Game 6 the way the Penguins played. And considering they have been dominated territorially six times in 12 days by the same hockey team, I’m guessing it’s going to happen again in Game 7. And I’m guessing the Penguins’ only chance is for Fleury to play the game of his life.
Maybe of anybody’s life.
Elmer Sobansky @ElmerSobansky: Have you ever seen a Pittsburgh team of any kind lay down like this or be completely dominated with zero grit or aggressiveness?
Starkey: Listen, Game 6 was shocking to behold, Elmer, but I cannot say the Penguins “laid down.” These are the same guys who won a Stanley Cup, the same guys who gutted their way to a Game 4 win without Crosby. I think they were simply dominated and perhaps have run out of gas.
Tony @bigteecee: During this two-game meltdown, do you think Trotz has gotten the better of Sullivan from behind the bench?
Starkey: Let’s put it this way, Mr. @bigteecee: Trotz’s moves are working. He had the guts to make some significant changes, including demoting the face of the franchise, Alex Ovechkin, to the third line. He also went with seven defensemen. Give the man some credit.
Jonathan @jrayhay8: How did we get on the path that led us to John Jason being an everyday right fielder?
Starkey: I wish John Jason, whoever he is, was the right fielder, Mr. jrayhay8.
Unfortunately, it’s John Jaso.
Thanks, kiddies. Be sure to insult Sean Gentille this week. Also, send me questions (tweet @JoeStarkey1 or email at jstarkey@post-gazette.com).






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.