Welcome to Joe Starkey’s weekly mailbag, where the Post-Gazette columnist and 93.7 The Fan radio host answers your questions about sports, life, Buffalo, Bob Dylan and everything in between. If you want to ask Joe a question, tweet him @JoeStarkey1 or email him at jstarkey@post-gazette.com. On to the questions:
Matt Keeler, @pgh485: Why is Sully not in Jack Adams talk? Huge turnaround from mid point last season and never stops winning.
Starkey: Let’s be honest, Mr. pgh485, the Jack Adams Award for NHL Coach of the Year is like all other Coach-of-the-Year awards: It’s merely a front for the “Most Improved Team” award.
In the NHL’s case, it has become a curse, as well. The five winners before Barry Trotz last year (Bob Hartley, Patrick Roy, Ken Hitchcock, Paul MacLean, Dan Bylsma) all had quick expiration dates.
Consider this: Chuck Noll never won the NFL’s Coach of the Year award while Chuck Knox won it three times (not that I have anything against Knox, who did an incredible job with the Buffalo Bills and in 1982 would have made it to the AFC title game if not for a highly questionable delay of game call on Lou Piccone).
That Buffalo team had a wonderful running back named Joe Cribbs out of Auburn. I suddenly feel compelled to publish a list of my five favorite mostly forgotten running backs before I get back to your question. I apologize:
Read More
5. Joe Cribbs
4. Wendell Tyler
3. Jim Braxton
2. John Brockington
1. Larry Brown (never ran to the sidelines. Never!).
OK, I’m really sorry now, but here are the five best Buffalo Bills running backs of all-time:
5. Joe Cribbs
4. Shady McCoy
3. Cookie Gilchrist
2. Thurman Thomas
1. O.J. Simpson
And while you’re inconvenienced, here are the five best Steelers running backs of all-time, with apologies to Barry Foster, who had one magnificent season.
5. Willie Parker
4. John Henry Johnson
3. Jerome Bettis
2. Le’Veon Bell: He’s the most talented of the bunch but needs to put together one full season (you know, where he starts and finishes the same year) and more of a playoff resume before he usurps the next guy …
1. Franco Harris
What was your question? Oh yes, the Jack Adams Award. Sully absolutely should be in the discussion. You can see what I think of his stellar work here. But you and I know the award will go to John Tortorella or Mike Babcock or maybe Bruce Boudreau or Todd McLellan — and not without good reason for any of those men. I just think Sully has a real case.
So we agree.
Joe Starkey, @JoeStarkey1: Here’s a better question: Where does Sully rank among the best Penguins coaches of all-time?
Starkey: I’m glad you asked. He is third.
The top five:
5. Michel Therrien. Nudges out his spiritual predecessor, Kevin Constantine, who did a remarkably underrated job before he was basically blackballed from the league (save for a brief and very weird stint in New Jersey under Lou Lamoriello).
4. Dan Bylsma. Won a Cup, and lots of games, so he’s automatically in the top four.
3. Mike Sullivan. Did a Bylsma redux in year 1 and is having a fabulous year two under extremely adverse circumstances.
2. Scotty Bowman. Won the Cup in first year, had longest winning streak in hockey history in second, although it didn’t end well.
1. Badger Bob Johnson. Helped to change the culture of hockey in this town, and there is no time like the first time as far as championships go. Do yourself a favor and read this recent story by George Johnson on the 25-year anniversary of Badger Bob’s passing. It is one of the finest sports stories I have ever read, literally from the beginning to the incredible final paragraph.
I suppose we should nominate the worst Penguins coach of all-time, too, and the winner in my book is Pierre Creamer. True, he had a winning record (36-35-9) in his only season but he also missed the playoffs despite Mario Lemieux’s MVP season (70 goals, 168 points) — and most notably did not realize his team needed to win its second-last game of the season in order to keep its playoff hopes alive.
I will refer here to a chapter from my book, “Tales From the Penguins Locker Room,” which is newly updated, by the way, and available on Amazon.
Creamer thought his team needed only a tie and failed to pull his goaltender as time wound down in a 6-6 deadlock with the Washington Capitals.
“We were on he bench and (forward) Dave Hunter was yelling to Pierre, ‘We need to win!’ ” winger Rob Brown recalled. “We were all turning around, saying ‘Are you going to pull our goalie?’ (Creamer) was calling upstairs and was convinced we needed a tie but somebody told him that was wrong.”
Finally, Creamer called timeout — and proceeded to speak French with Lemieux while the other five players on the ice stared blankly at each other.
“We’re like, ‘Ah, Pierre, we don’t speak French,’ ” Brown recalled. “I’m sure he said to Mario, ‘Go end to end and win the game’ and that’s exactly what happened.”
Upon his firing, Creamer told the media, “They wanted to find a big dummy for not making the playoffs, and they found me.”
Jeff Meyer, @jj_meyer18: Over/under 5% chance Pitt gets an on-campus stadium within the next 5-10 years.
Starkey: Way under. Right around 0.0.
Big Large, @BigLarge2: Choose only 4, what's your Pitt Mount Rushmore?
Starkey: I’m assuming you speak of basketball here, Mr. Big Large, and I’m going to stick to the 21st Century. So picture these faces carved into Mt. Washington.
■ Ben Howland: He resuscitated a dead program and made Pitt a nationally recognizable brand. He also brought along Jamie Dixon.
■ Brandin Knight: It all began with him. A leader in every sense of the word.
■ DeJuan Blair: What a great story. Local kid puts Pitt on precipice of Final Four. Him flicking Hasheem Thabeet like a gnat was an all-time highlight.
■ Jamie Dixon: His program faded by the end — one forgettable NCAA tournament victory in his last five years, but he won a ton of games and kept Pitt in a position of national prominence for much of his time here.
Jake Neech @Big_Neech_: My wife thought the bullpen was actually called the Bulls Den. I kinda like that tho, think it could catch on?
Starkey: No. But I like it, too.
Nate the Great, @BurghRambler909: Shouldn’t the FBI have better things to do than help Tom Brady find his missing jersey?
Starkey: You mean like investigate one of Brady’s buddies for treason? Turns out they might have sufficient manpower for both.
Thanks, kiddies. Be sure to insult Sean Gentille this week. Also, send me questions (tweet @JoeStarkey1 or email at jstarkey@post-gazette.com).






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.