Welcome to Joe Starkey’s weekly mailbag, where the Post-Gazette columnist and 93.7 The Fan radio host answers your questions about sports, life, Buffalo, Bob Dylan and everything in between. If you want to ask Joe a question, tweet him @JoeStarkey1 or email him at jraystarkey@gmail.com. On to the questions:

Coral Grimes @Swagman_79 : Murray #1 goalie now?

Starkey: First, Mr. @Swagman, if it’s true that brevity is the better part of valor, then you are a role model. A four-word question including an abbreviation? Tremendous.

In your honor, I present a brief answer: Yes.

Advertise with us

That doesn’t mean Marc-Andre Fleury will rot on the bench or be excluded from the competition. He did, after all, start his third consecutive game last night. Mike Sullivan has been mostly true to his word that performance will dictate who plays. Remember this: Things change amazingly fast with goalie situations.

But when you look at the overall numbers, it’s startling — and one of those stands out to me: The number of times either goalie gives up four goals or more, which of course makes it difficult for the team to win (except for last night). Murray has one such game in nine starts, a loss. Fleury has eight such games in 18 starts (the Penguins are 2-6).

Go back to March 1 of last season, when Murray was recalled for the second time from the AHL, and consider this: He has given up four goals just four times in 42 starts. Never five. That hasn’t happened yet, although Murray was pulled after giving up four through two periods of Game 4 against Tampa Bay, you’ll recall.

The numbers this year are heavily in Murray’s favor, even if it’s a small sample size:

Murray: 8-2-0, 2.01 GAA, .931 save pct

Advertise with us

Fleury: 8-5-3, 3.42, .900

A popular theory is that the team plays a looser game in front of Fleury. Anecdotally, that seems true. Consider Monday night’s madness (enjoyable though it was). But I checked with my friend Jesse Marshall, a man so steeped in analytics that he is often in danger of drowning, and this is what he said:

“Let’s start with scoring chances against per 60 minutes.

Fleury: 19.56

Murray: 19.41

Advertise with us

No difference there at all. But we can actually take a closer look and filter this so we’re only looking at high-danger scoring chances against. These are shots taken from the home plate area directly in/around the crease:

High-Danger Chances against per 60:

Fleury: 9.7

Murray: 9.21

The differences here are negligible, Joe.”

Advertise with us

The Penguins haven’t been real good defensively in front of either man. They have scored way more goals in front of Murray, which could be random but could also be attributed, as Marshall suggests, to playing with a lead as opposed to battling from behind. Scoring becomes more difficult when you’re behind because of the way the other team plays.

Joe Starkey, @JoeStarkey1: So would you keep Fleury?

Starkey: Yes, Joe, I would. And I didn’t always feel this way. I just like the idea of having that insurance policy in case Murray is injured, and I believe having two good goalies gives the Penguins a competitive advantage in a compressed season. The key is whether Fleury can adjust to his new role. If he can’t by the trade deadline, and if the right deal comes along, go for it.

But I would again issue the reminder: Things change quickly. If Fleury had played great last night, he might have made a fourth consecutive start Thursday in Florida.

PixBurghKid, @tuitepgh: Which historic sporting event would you like to have seen in person?

Advertise with us

Starkey: That’s an easy one, PixBurghKid: Game 7 of the 1960 World Series. I never tire of the stories. I recently heard a good one from Rex Johnston, the only man who ever played for both the Steelers and Pirates. Johnston was on the Steelers at the time, staying with the team at the Roosevelt Hotel downtown. He recalled walking out of the hotel to find the biggest outdoor party he’d ever seen. Or ever would. He didn’t make it a block before he was randomly kissed “two or three times,” and he’ll never forget people abandoning their cars on bridges to join the fun.

For my money, Mazeroski’s home run was a top-five sports moment of the 20th Century — and there cannot have been a more dramatic Game 7 in any sport, anywhere.

Kraig Riley, @KraigRiley: Did your career take a hit after getting married, like many athletes?

Starkey: Hi Kraigers. Do you mean my athletic career? It wasn’t very prolific to begin with and went straight downhill upon marriage, although I will say this: I chose my proposal night based on whether I could make a game-winning shot in a pickup basketball game at Sacred Heart in Shadyside. I was feeling lucky. I swished it from just inside the 3-point line. I drove right over to Susie’s house and popped the question. She said yes.

She said no, however, to me playing Andrew Filliponi — 21 years younger than me — in a one-on-one five years ago. I should have listened. I snapped my left Achilles Tendon in Game 2 of a three-game series (I won Game 1 and was leading Game 2, 17-14). I was carried out of LA Fitness on an orange gurney and nobody seemed to care, but that’s beside the point.

Advertise with us

I’m really not sure what the point is. My media career has not suffered from marriage. I talk on the radio and write columns and answer mailbags and just finished the latest edition of my Penguins book (“Tales From the Penguins Locker Room,” newly updated with three new chapters and a new foreword from Mike Lange ... and available for pre-order on Amazon.com, I might add ).

I am a strong proponent of marriage, Kraigers, although it ain’t easy. Mostly because of me.

Nich Olas, @NHaas88: Best song on My Aim is True?

Starkey: First off, St. Nich, “My Aim is True” is one of the top five albums of all-time, and I could never be the friend of someone who doesn’t at least like “Less Than Zero.” Only bad people don’t like that. I used to listen this album while sipping (OK, guzzling) Genny Cream Ale. Me and my friend Marshall Rhinehart. Quite the name, yes?

Top five songs:

Advertise with us

5. Alison

4. Welcome to the Workin’ Week

3. Miracle Man

2. (The Angels Wanna Wear My) Red Shoes

1. Less Than Zero

Advertise with us

Incidentally, I saw Elvis Costello & Dylan play the Petersen Events Center a few years back. Costello was amazing. Dylan played like Pitt against Duquesne the other night. I did not understand a single word he said or sang. And yet he still put on a helluva show.

Thanks, kiddies. Be sure to insult Sean Gentille this week and send me questions throughout the week (tweet @JoeStarkey1 or email at jraystarkey@gmail.com). We’ll talk on Tuesday.