COOPERSTOWN, N.Y. — The similarities are hard to ignore.
They could hit a baseball as hard and far as any of their contemporaries. They also had to wait entirely too long for this moment.
Dave Parker and Dick Allen thrived while playing for Chuck Tanner and produced stretches where they might’ve been the best in the game. They also endured racism and a bunch of unfair criticism.
In many ways, it was fitting they were enshrined together into the National Baseball Hall of Fame and Museum in Cooperstown on Sunday, Parker and Allen now forever remembered among the greats of the game.
Another unfortunate similarity between the two: Neither was here to enjoy it.
Allen — who grew up in Wampum in Lawrence County and was nicknamed “the Wampum Walloper” — passed away at age 78 on Dec. 7, 2020.
Read More
“This means a lot to the whole Allen family,” said Dick’s widow, Willa Allen, who gave his induction speech Sunday. “We waited a long time for this moment. The only sad part is that Dick isn’t here to enjoy it.”
As much as Pittsburgh has celebrated Parker for his many accomplishments, we should really stop and appreciate Allen’s fascinating story, one that neatly preceded Parker’s dominance but also wasn’t without some controversy of its own.
Among the basics for Allen:
• He played 15 years for five teams (Phillies, White Sox, Cardinals, Dodgers and Athletics), hitting .292 with 351 home runs, 1,119 RBIs and a .912 OPS.
• Allen won the National League Rookie of the Year with the Phillies in 1964 and became the American League’s Most Valuable Player while with Chicago in 1972.
• A right-handed hitter who swung a massive bat, Allen led his league in OPS four times and slugging percentage three times, among several other accomplishments.
“To many of us, Dick was already a Hall of Famer,” Willa said Sunday. “Not just for how he played, but for who he was.”
The who-he-was element is an undeniable part of Allen’s story, as he was traded five times in a six-year stretch (1969-75).
Allen was certainly peculiar. I remember Bruce Tanner, Chuck’s son, telling me after Allen died how his dad would certainly bend some rules for Allen. It wasn’t uncommon for Allen to arrive for spring training at 6 a.m. and run, hit and field by himself before going home for the day.
Similar to Parker, Allen was also treated unfairly due to the color of his skin.
While playing for Triple-A Arkansas in 1963, white supremacists picketed the ballpark. Fans regularly hurled racial epithets at Allen and threatened him. It wasn’t much better with the Phillies, who were one of the last National League teams to integrate.
In 1965, after a teammate (Frank Thomas) swung a bat at Allen, causing a fight, the fallout painted an unfair picture. The Phillies released Thomas while putting a gag order on Allen, creating a narrative at the time of a Black player costing a white player his job.
Parker’s car was vandalized at Three Rivers Stadium. He had people break into his home, and Allen and Parker both had things thrown at them on the field. Yet they persevered and kept crushing baseballs.
“He loved the game,” Willa Allen said of her late husband. “But more than that, he loved the people in it. Baseball was his first love. He used to say, ‘I’d have played for nothing.’ I believe he meant it.”
Speaking of money, another crazy parallel: Allen became the highest-paid player in baseball in 1973, and Parker followed in 1979.
There were also the tape-measure homers, bombs that make me wish Statcast had existed. (OK, I lied. It was more fun actually watching games.)
One great story involving Allen unfolded in May 1965, when he hit what’s believed to be a 529-foot home run off Larry Jackson of the Cubs, clearing the roof in left-center field of Connie Mack Stadium.
“Now I know why they boo Richie all the time,” Willie Stargell was quoted as saying. “When he hits a home run, there’s no souvenir.”
Both had to wait entirely too long for this honor — Allen 47 years, Parker 33 — but the last thing we need to remember involves the slices of dominance they both produced.
Parker owned the mid-to-late 70s. Prior to that, the Wampum Walloper walloped. A lot.
Among the numbers:
• From 1964-74, Allen accumulated the sixth-most Wins Above Replacement among position players, per Baseball Reference (58.3). The five above Allen: Hank Aaron, Carl Yastrzemski, Roberto Clemente, Ron Santo and Brooks Robinson. Willie Mays was one spot behind.
• Over his first 11 full seasons (1964-74), nobody had a better wRC+ than Allen (163).
• Also in that span, only Aaron, Harmon Killebrew, Stargell and Willie McCovey hit more home runs.
• Parker had his own incredible run, finishing second in average (.321), third in slugging (.532) and OPS (.909) and leading MLB in outfield assists (72) between 1975-79. The Cobra retired as one of only five players with at least 2,700 hits, 300 home runs, 500 doubles and 150 stolen bases.
Allen and Parker were clearly among the best players of their era, trail blazers who were never properly appreciated. As Parker said in his induction poem, it’s about damn time those flaws have been corrected.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.