Privately and publicly, Bob Nutting has wanted to avoid creating a distraction, believing the Pirates are close. Instead, the team owner’s lack of action continues to create headaches.
What the Pirates are doing with general manager Ben Cherington remains impossible to understand, especially with Sunday’s news that the Nationals fired GM Mike Rizzo and Dave Martinez.
So … you can do that during a season?
Just not here evidently, as Nutting told me on May 9 that firing Cherington along with Derek Shelton would’ve been counterproductive and “distracting” when it came to preserving the 2025 season.
“I think that would get us off track,” Nutting said. “My focus has to be on getting this fixed and getting it fixed as fast as we can.”
Nutting, of course, is wrong.
Read More
While manager Don Kelly has certainly been an improvement and the pitching staff has been mostly solid, the Pirates are hardly on track.
What they’re doing makes little sense, seemingly kicking the can on anything serious or somehow tolerating a loss total that’ll probably fall in the mid-90s.
The issues are compounded with the MLB draft and trade deadline approaching. But to fully understand the magnitude of those things, let’s rewind to last offseason, when Cherington and Shelton were retained.
As much as anything, that misguided or blind loyalty has governed the Pirates’ problems.
After last season, Nutting believed — again — the Pirates were close enough to winning that blowing it up would be more trouble than it was worth.
Someone, probably Cherington, convinced him that the Pirates could take that last step.
And Nutting, though frustrated at the Pirates’ 2024 tailspin, again succumbed to one of his shortcomings: being way too patient with things that aren’t working.
In addition to the over-arching missteps, retaining Cherington and Shelton meant a couple smaller things.
The first, amid a rotten start, led to a way-too-slow reaction, as the Pirates stumbled their way to a 12-26 record after 38 games. It took Nutting intervening to finally make the necessary personnel moves.
“I felt it was critically important that we move now — certainly no later than now — because I believe we can still make a real impact in 2025,” Nutting told me.
Aside from allowing the slow start to essentially sink their season, bringing Cherington and Shelton back — in the Pirates’ mind — also meant they’d oversee the draft and trade deadline ... which, again, continues to make zero sense to me.
Rizzo and Martinez, World Series winners with Washington, were shown the door.
What has Cherington done with the Pirates to earn additional staying power?
Certainly not add bats at the trade deadline. Or any time.
Since 2020, Cherington has made 11 trades within a week of the deadline, and those deals have netted a total of 14 hitters, eight who’ve made it to the big leagues. Their combined production: 0.3 bWAR.
If you examine the 10 best position players via FanGraphs’ WAR during Cherington’s tenure, the top four (Bryan Reynolds, Ke’Bryan Hayes, Oneil Cruz and Jacob Stallings) were acquired by Neal Huntington, along with 97% of No. 5 Adam Frazier.
Cherington’s top entrant on said list, Jack Suwinski, is currently with Triple-A Indianapolis, while No. 7 (Andrew McCutchen) was more of a Nutting move the others tolerated than anything.
What are we clinging to here?
The Pirates’ reluctance to make the necessary moves this offseason turned into their reluctance to make the necessary moves in May, and now we’re staring at a July edition of their reluctance to make the necessary moves — one featuring huge events on the MLB calendar that are somehow being treated as part of admission to the park.
Washington made its moves because it felt plenty was wrong. Nobody would fault Nutting for doing the same here.
The problem is ignoring the elephant in the room and instead allowing Cherington to go through processes where he’s found scant success.
What’s perhaps most confounding or frustrating is what the trade deadline should mean for the Pirates.
They have players on expiring contracts such as Frazier, Andrew Heaney, Caleb Ferguson, Isiah Kiner-Falefa and Tommy Pham. Though they likely won’t net blockbuster returns, all could be tradable. There’s value en masse.
There is also an array of second-cut moves the Pirates could make involving Mitch Keller, David Bednar, Dennis Santana or Ke’Bryan Hayes. I’d hate to see any of the first three traded, believe me, but it’s pretty darn obvious — especially after their scoreless-in-Seattle weekend — that the Pirates need more offense. Have to give to get.
The problem is that Cherington has done one far better than the other. Clay Holmes for Hoy Park and Diego Castillo? Jameson Taillon for three guys they DFA’d and a 23-year-old with a .712 OPS in Double-A (Maikol Escotto). Joe Musgrove netted Bednar, but the offensive components (Endy Rodriguez, Hudson Head) have been disappointing.
For the Pirates to aggressively address their offensive shortcomings, they either need to spend to add players or make a series of smart trades to add it from other teams.
Sure hope you’re not holding your breath on the first one. You’d think that if you’re not going to spend, smartly handling the deadline would be a requirement.
Not here.
Staying the course this offseason meant either Cherington or an interim — both limited on what they’re allowed to do — would run the deadline, further delaying the Pirates’ progress.
For a group that likes to talk about urgency, they’ve sure done a poor job of displaying it.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.