It’s more likely the Steelers start the 2025-26 season 6-0 than 0-6.

Which is to say, really, neither will happen despite former NFL quarterback Dan Orlovsky warning on ESPN the Steelers could be staring at six consecutive losses to open the year should Aaron Rodgers not sign with them.

It’s absurd on a number of levels.

First and foremost, the Steelers aren’t a bad team. They might not be a very good one and they’re certainly not elite. But bad? Probably a little overdramatic there.

Advertise with us

The 0-6 nonsense also doesn’t track if you look at the Steelers’ opponents. The Jets and Patriots are far from world beaters, and the Browns have become Backup Quarterback University. Plus, that game will be played in Pittsburgh.

It honestly wouldn’t shock me if the Steelers started 4-2 or 5-1, though that wouldn’t really tell me anything about their season. After what happened in 2024, we should know to wait far longer before concluding anything.

For now, the bigger issue is how they finish and, within that, the four-week stretch that includes a home game against Buffalo, at Baltimore, at home vs. Miami and in Detroit.

Tua Tagovailoa on a cold December night in Pittsburgh sounds like a winning recipe, but the other three will obviously be difficult.

The Nov. 9 game in Los Angeles and a Week 18 flex game at home against the Ravens are far from layups, and I’m slightly concerned about the Steelers going to Cincinnati on a short week for that Oct. 16 tilt against the Bengals.

Advertise with us

But again, as frustrating as they might be with some things, the Steelers aren’t an 0-6 team. I can’t even see that happening if Mason Rudolph winds up as the Week 1 starter, either because Rodgers retires, plays elsewhere or joins the circus.

With Rodgers, the Steelers might reach 10 or 11 wins. It could get them to the postseason — again, best-case scenario here — but they won’t crack the upper-echelon cluster of the Chiefs, Ravens or Bills. They might not even be with the Broncos, Chargers or Bengals.

But it’s impossible for me to see them hanging with the Browns, Titans, Jets or Raiders, AFC teams with far more questions than answers.

The Steelers this offseason have actually done some smart things.

DK Metcalf represents a WR1 upgrade over George Pickens. I also think it could be addition by subtraction when it comes to trading Pickens to the Cowboys. The more that leaks out about Pickens’ behavior, on top of what we already knew, zero issue with the move.

Advertise with us

I do have concerns about the remaining depth, as Calvin Austin III and Roman Wilson are much more palatable as third or fourth options than bona fide No. 2’s.

Whether it’s Chris Olave, Gabe Davis or Allen Lazard, the Steelers must sign or trade for someone to operate opposite Metcalf, probably after they figure out where things stand with Rodgers.

(Yes, it’s perfectly logical for him to want one of his own guys and get that wish, especially when there’s already a need.)

Broderick Jones should hopefully be better on the left side, and Troy Fautanu, if healthy, profiles as a significant upgrade at right tackle. The offensive line isn’t as bad as it looked at the end of the year, and there’s more depth at running back.

The outside-zone abilities of Iowa’s Kaleb Johnson are especially appealing, as those types of runners have typically had more success in offenses like the one Arthur Smith tried to run last year.

Advertise with us

Again, not saying everything is perfect or the Steelers shouldn’t be questioned. They aren’t, and we should. But they’re frustratingly similar to what they’ve been: stuck in the middle and not discernibly doing one thing or the other.

An 0-6 start, as unlikely as it would be, might produce the dud year they’ve needed, the ability to recalibrate and pick high in the 2026 NFL draft. They wouldn’t have to forfeit a bunch of assets to land a quarterback, either.

Really thinking crazy, those wanting to see a coaching change might embrace 4-13 or 5-12 in a way that could push Mike Tomlin out the door, and I also don’t think that would be the worst thing for the Steelers.

I just don’t see any of it happening.

The Steelers actually drafted well and addressed key needs with defensive linemen Derrick Harmon and Yahya Black. Their run defense should improve upon what it became last year. Malik Harrison and Jack Sawyer figure to bring physicality at the second level.

Advertise with us

Question marks exist with depth and potential injuries, especially in the secondary. The optimistic view of Darius Slay Jr. is he was a productive veteran on a Super Bowl-winning team, the perfect piece to complement Joey Porter Jr.

Pessimists will note he’s 34 with plenty of miles on the tires. Will the Steelers use Minkah Fitzpatrick properly or trade him? Can DeShon Elliott replicate his impressive 2025 season? What becomes of Brandin Echols and Juan Thornhill?

There are things to stress test all over the place, areas the Steelers may have fixed and other parts where it’s fair to worry if they’ve left themselves spread thin. Offensive line, for example.

But this idea they’re possibly going to start 0-6 if Rodgers doesn’t sign here is foolish. Rodgers obviously isn’t his elite-level, four-time NFL MVP former self. That’s easy to discern.

However, he can be moderately effective in the right offense, where he’s getting rid of the ball quickly, there’s a running game and he has people capable of catching the football, plus a defense we can expect to finish within the top 12 when it comes to points and yards allowed.

Advertise with us

How many of the Steelers’ first eight opponents check those boxes? Two? Three?

It wouldn’t shock me if the Steelers started 4-2 and got to 5-3 before flying across the country to face the Chargers. Ditto for when the dust settles and the Steelers wind up with another 10-7 mark on their ledger.

Jason Mackey: jmackey@post-gazette.com and @JMackeyPG on X.