Offense has been at a premium around these parts, especially when it involves a bat and a ball, although nobody bothered to tell the Robert Morris softball team.
The hot-hitting Colonials have a WPIAL-heavy roster and seemingly can’t stop launching home runs, including one in walk-off fashion to secure the program’s first-ever Horizon League tournament title over the weekend.
Bound for an NCAA tournament appearance Friday, with a regional game against fifth-seeded Florida State, Robert Morris (30-16) has been an awesome story this season for a variety of reasons, starting with its high-powered offense.
“Our offense has just been insane,” said freshman Mary Brant, whose two-run homer in the bottom of the eighth Saturday sealed the Colonials’ first trip to the national dance since 2005. “We all lean on one another. That’s when we score the most runs. We just hope to keep that going.”
It’ll be a tall task against the Seminoles, who have the ninth-lowest ERA (2.23) in the country, but you never know. Anything can happen — as coach Jexx Varner’s team has shown.
Led by Mount Pleasant product Courtney Poulich, Brant and several other impressive hitters, Robert Morris paced the Horizon League in pretty much every offensive category this season, including batting average (.308), on-base percentage (.379) and slugging (.512).
Read More
Not only that, the Colonials set single-season program records for home runs (48), doubles (75), stolen bases (74) and RBIs (255).
“Home runs and offense, that’s the fun part of the game,” Poulich said. “We have a lot of power on this team.”
And talented players familiar to area softball fans.
Along with Poulich, a redshirt junior, Anna Resnik (Elizabeth Forward), Alaina Koutsogiani (Peters Township) and Jess Matheny (Southmoreland) are all seniors hitting at least .305. Koutsogiani leads the team in steals with 21.
Meanwhile, redshirt freshman Sequoia Dunlap (Uniontown) tied Saturday’s title game with a homer in the bottom of the seventh to force extra innings. In the circle, sophomore Kaitlyn Molitoris (Montour) has gone 9-5 with a 3.67 ERA in 20 appearances.
The collection of local talent is absolutely intentional, Varner said. And it’s been essential to further the family environment Varner says has existed for years with Robert Morris softball.
“There’s a lot of great softball in this area,” Varner said. “We want to make sure we provide the opportunity to play at a high level here.
“There’s such a value of being home. It creates a really tight-knit atmosphere that leads into a positive team culture.”
That’s certainly what Poulich has found.
Along with a long-overdue run of good health for the transfer from Liberty University who was named the MVP of the Horizon League tournament.
Poulich accomplished a lot in high school, helping Mount Pleasant win WPIAL and PIAA titles, but she never found a fit with the Flames. Having known Resnik and Koutsogiani since around age 9, that helped facilitate her summer 2022 transfer.
That fall, however, Poulich suffered a serious hamstring injury, which required surgery, and missed the entire 2023 season. Even in 2024, Poulich only felt like herself during various pockets.
This year, she’s finally found her stride (and swing).
Poulich has slashed .340/.418/.785, with 30 of her 49 hits going for extra bases. She also now owns program records for home runs (15) and RBIs (52) in a single season. Perhaps most incredible: Poulich had three homers in three playoff games this year and has five in her past seven overall.
“She’s a freak athlete who’s really strong and has a great approach at the plate,” Varner said. “It’s just awesome to see her out there doing her thing.”
Same for the whole program, honestly.
Prior to 2005, Robert Morris softball made it to NCAAs in 1994 and ’98. There’s also some unfinished business here, as this year’s seniors were freshmen when RMU reached the Horizon League title game but lost to Oakland by a run.
“Everyone on our team has been dreaming of this,” Poulich said.
The other impressive thing about Robert Morris softball has been an ability to win different ways, which will be needed against Florida State and the rest of the bracket (more on that shortly).
In addition to the incredible offense — the Colonials had 120 more total bases than anyone else in the Horizon League — there has also been some strong pitching, headlined by senior Madison DeVault.
After pitching in relief earlier in her career, DeVault (14-7, 2.41 ERA, 131 strikeouts in 139 2/3 innings) has become an ace, throwing every inning of the Horizon League tournament while allowing just six earned runs and striking out 17 in 21 innings.
“This year, she’s taken the ball and kind of run with it as that No. 1 starter,” Varner said.
Friday won’t be easy. Florida State (46-9) ranks in the top 10 nationally in most team stats. The Seminoles are third in hits (523), fourth in runs (425) and have the ninth-lowest ERA (2.23), using that combination to win 10 of 16 against ranked opponents.
If Robert Morris can pull off the upset, the winner of South Florida (43-14-1) and Auburn (32-22) awaits. If the Colonials fall, they’ll have to navigate the loser’s bracket to reach Sunday’s regional final.
The Tallahassee Regional is one of 16 sites across the country. From there, it’s on to Super Regionals (best-of-three at campus sites) and finally the College World Series in Oklahoma City.
They’re lofty goals but also now strikingly real.
“It’s kind of surreal,” said Brant, who has 11 homers this season and was named the Horizon League’s freshman of the year. “This is what we’ve been working for all season.
“As a school, Robert Morris has won five championship this year (men’s basketball, soccer and lacrosse, as well as softball and women’s cross country). We hope to represent our university well and make program history.”
It wouldn’t the first time for what I learned this week is a really fun group, one that can certainly put the ball over the fence but also that does this for the right reasons.
To represent their hometowns, high schools and university; to pass around a hilarious WWE-style belt; to further the program and because they genuinely like each other.
“It’s just our culture,” Poulich said. “We’re a hard-working group. We trust each other and know that if someone is having a bad game, someone else will pick ’em up. When we’re in big-time moments, we’re going to pull through because everyone just loves competing together.”






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.