The Pirates’ home-opener Friday was preceded by a flyover.
No, not the helicopters. The one where a small plane circled PNC Park for several hours with a banner exhorting owner Bob Nutting to sell the team.
There were also introductions before Mitch Keller’s first pitch against the New York Yankees. Paul Skenes and Andrew McCutchen received hearty ovations from the crowd of 36,893, while manager Derek Shelton most certainly did not, the boos impossible to ignore.
After a long, frustrating winter, baseball finally returned to the North Shore, and with it came an opportunity for the Pirates to quiet the noise created by their slow start in Florida.
That didn’t happen.
Unfortunately for them, the dial moved a few clicks to the right.
Read More
In fact, the volume surrounding this team feels a lot like what was directed at Shelton — certainly tied to his own performance, but also because general manager Ben Cherington, president Travis Williams and Nutting weren’t introduced.
Eight games in, it’s already pretty darn loud.
"Their frustration is they want to win," Shelton said when asked about fans’ pregame booing. "I want to win. Our players want to win. We have to keep focusing on that."
That the Pirates were nowhere near competitive in 9-4 loss was one thing. However, their issues aren't isolated to a single game, as ugly as this might’ve been.
Is this a slow start or a bad team?
How warm are the seats underneath Cherington and Shelton?
What must happen to get this fixed?
Fair questions, all of them.
And Nutting — he’s hardly blameless — made his feelings on the Pirates known during a pregame interview with the Post-Gazette’s Noah Hiles by saying: “I think I’ve done everything I can to provide the tools and resources to the team. There is a point where it becomes execution.”
Get as mad as you want about what Nutting said. However, his comments confirm a dynamic I’ve suspected: Right or wrong, Nutting thinks he’s done and spent enough to see winning baseball.
While the Pirates certainly should’ve done more this offseason, I sort of understand the spirit of what Nutting is trying to convey here: They have enough talent, the issue has been putting everything together.
I also don’t expect that to placate Pirates fans who several times chanted for Nutting to sell the team.
Regardless, the salient point here is this: Poor fundamental baseball can’t occur as frequently as it has for a team like the Pirates to have success, their margin for error too small.
More basic miscues occurred again Friday, too, with Oneil Cruz and Alexander Canario misplaying balls in the outfield, four walks and two hit batters from Keller and Isiah Kiner-Falefa getting picked off.
"That loss is completely on me," Keller said, bemoaning his inability to consistently find the strike zone.
"We’ve got to play better defensively in the outfield," Shelton added. "We’ve played well defensively in the infield. We have not played well defensively in the outfield to start. We have to clean that up. The thing with IKF, that just can’t happen. In a 7-1 game, you can’t get picked off."
Keller, again: "That's the message — we need to play clean baseball.”
It’s hardly unreasonable for Nutting to expect that. The Rays do it with a smaller payroll. The Guardians are only one spot higher. Winning in the margins was cited throughout the winter as a potential area of improvement, and their performance with that sort of stuff has been … well, marginal.
It’s true there are 154 of these left, but the process hasn't been good, which reflects poorly on Cherington or Shelton.
That Keller (3 2/3 innings, 7 earned runs) struggled was … whatever. He was good last time out. Individual performances will fluctuate. But the sum total simply shouldn’t look like this.
Not in year six, not with the urgency Nutting and others have outlined.
“Ben understands how important this season is,” Nutting said. “Shelty understands how important this season is. … I have high expectations this year. The organization knows we have high expectations, and I know the fans have high expectations.”
Yeah, they do. Fans have voiced that. A few different ways.
And they’re well within their rights to demand winning baseball. It’s been more than long enough.
The million-dollar question rests with the owner — what he sees and how much of this he’s willing to tolerate.
With the plane overhead, the billboards, the chants, the open rebukes of the job Nutting has done as an owner, not to mention the ugly way the Pirates finished last year, I can’t imagine he’s overflowing with patience.
Nor should he be.
Look, I’m not saying to fire Shelton and Cherington into the sun after eight, nine or 10 games. It’s baseball, the ultimate sample-size sport. Patience is required.
But there’s a difference between patience and misguided devotion or indifference — and it’s getting harder and harder to tell what we’re looking at here.
Give these results two months to normalize, and there’s a good chance it’ll be too late, the Pirates' lot cast. It must be sooner.
If this season matters as much as Nutting says it does, his tolerance for lousy baseball should be exceedingly low, the possibility of the Pirates’ wasting two of Paul Skenes’ six team-control years scary.
After all, three of the club’s best hitters — Bryan Reynolds, Oneil Cruz and Andrew McCutchen — have ties to other regimes, though at least this group brought Cutch back in 2023. (Like that was hard.)
There have been strides made on the pitching side, sure, but the inability to construct a quality bullpen represents another way these Pirates have deviated from the small-market success enjoyed in Cleveland and Tampa.
That along with poor drafting and development, a lack of international talent and free agent signings and trades that haven’t netted nearly enough production.
While he’s most frequently the target of vitriol, there are plenty of fair questions for Nutting to ask at this point — about the process, the plan, those poor fundamentals, why there’s not more offense here or in the minor leagues, on and on.
But the biggest must be internal: If this year truly matters, if Nutting cares the way he says he does, how much longer can he afford to tolerate the lackluster product the Pirates have delivered thus far?
Jason Mackey: jmackey@post-gazette.com and @JMackeyPG on X.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.