The Steelers solving their quarterback problem dominated much of team president Art Rooney II’s meeting with reporters on Monday afternoon. For good reason, too. They have nobody under contract for 2025. It’s also the most important position in team sports.
Yet before Rooney said it would be Russell Wilson or Justin Fields and likely not both, or that he wanted matching skill sets and that age would play a factor (hint hint), there was a question about the head coaching elephant in the room.
“Why does Mike [Tomlin] remain the right guy to lead this group?” Will Graves from the Associated Press asked.
Before anyone launches their pitchforks, Graves framed the question perfectly. Whether you agree or not, Rooney has shown us through his actions — or lack of them — that he believes Tomlin is the right guy for the job. It’s our job to ask why he feels that way, not shake him until the answer changes.
How Rooney responded: “When you look at how many games Mike has won in this league, you don’t win that many games if you’re not a good coach. I know he’s frustrated, like we all are, in terms of not being able to take that next step. We still feel good about him being the leader. Still think he has the strengths that he always had in terms of being able to lead a team.
“The other side of the coin is, when you look at the fact that we have six, seven or eight teams a year that turn their coaches over, when you have a good coach, you just try to keep building with him.”
Read More
Bookmark that, please. We’ll come back to it.
The other part of Rooney’s session I found interesting — OK, terrifying — was this: “It’s fair to question it after losing five in a row,” he said to a question from ESPN’s Brooke Pryor on whether Rooney still feels like Tomlin’s message is getting through. “But when I talk to the players, I think they still want to play for Mike. I’m not concerned about his message or that kind of an issue.”
I didn’t expect Rooney to have a change of heart and fire Tomlin in the middle of the conference room. At the same time, I also wasn’t thrilled with much of the above.
It felt like we’re in store for more of the mediocre, mushy middle.
It also sounded like an owner who doesn’t want to pay the remaining balance on a $50 million contract extension, so instead he has convinced himself that not having a losing season matters more than not winning a playoff game.
Isn’t the standard the Super Bowl?
Isn’t this a results-oriented business, where if you don’t win games in crunch time, there are consequences?
That’s what happened to Andy Reid in Philadelphia after the 2012 season, when his Eagles went 4-12. It concluded an eight-year stretch where Reid won three playoff games and lost four.
Think about that for a second.
When the bar around the NFL has been raised to ludicrous levels, we’re supposed to believe that Tomlin remains the best choice for the job because he won nearly a decade ago and his 80-50 regular season record over the past eight seasons should outweigh his 0-for-6 mark in postseason play?
No bleepin’ way.
So many times in pro sports, especially baseball, you pay for future projection, not past results. The Steelers remaining in this marriage because it once was good feels like a couple that has fallen out of love but remains together for the sake of the kids.
Which might actually be true considering the idea that Tomlin’s players love playing for him, a topic that I actually broached over the summer — but with a twist.
“Can’t say enough good things about him,” Pat Freiermuth told me.
“When he talks to you,” Patrick Queen added, “it’s almost like a father-son type of thing.”
Great. That also wasn’t my point. I wrote that if Steelers players loved Tomlin so much, it was time they started showing it with their performance, which wasn’t exactly how this season played out.
Instead, it continued the trend of lousy finishes. The Steelers lost at least three times in December for the fourth time in the past five seasons. They were flat-out demoralized in Baltimore. Since last winning a playoff game, Tomlin’s teams have gone 24-26 from December through the end of the postseason.
But the players allegedly love playing for Tomlin.
Also, since when was this a prerequisite?
I’m only 41 and will never try to speak as an authority on Chuck Noll. However, I have a hard time believing everyone loved playing for him. They likely valued the experience because he challenged them, brought a group of adults together for a common goal, and they won.
My best comparison would be Mike Sullivan with the Penguins and what I observed while covering back-to-back Stanley Cup runs. Sullivan was (and remains) intense. I used to love when they practiced downtown because you could hear every word of Sullivan’s expletive-laden tirades when energy or attention to detail lacked.
That’s also not to say Tomlin loafs around the South Side, cracking jokes with players. Far from it. You saw “Hard Knocks.” There’s plenty to like and respect about how Tomlin comports himself. It just hasn’t produced requisite results.
Which is why I wish Rooney would step in and realize or admit that things have grown stale, that the message isn’t resonating the way it used to and the standard has slipped. It shouldn't be about whether the players want to play for Tomlin.
It should be about what's best for the organization, everything else be damned.
Among other reactions:
• If you have two similar skill sets for quarterbacks, why in the name of Kent Graham would you employ two pocket passers in this era of the NFL?
• Whether the Steelers coaching staff has 18, 22 or 47 members, the bigger issue is delineation of duties. Get a clock management/game situation guy and let Teryl Austin run the defense the way he sees fit. No more Tomlin crossover.
• Did the Steelers learn anything from the Kenny Pickett experience? “I’m not sure there’s a lot to be learned from that,” Rooney said. If the Steelers president had a mulligan Monday, here’s guessing he would use it here.
• The quarterback comments pointed me toward Fields, Rooney adding they’d prefer to sign someone for multiple years. Wilson would cost more and offer a shorter shelf-live. Fields brings value but comes with more risk (and upside). Rooney also referenced drafting a quarterback. Heck of a time to get your franchise guy: April 2026 in Pittsburgh.



Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.