They are the highest-paid and most-visible members of their respective schools. They’re also both now into double digits when it comes to their respective tenures at Pitt and Penn State — and those contracts run through the early part of next decade.
Pat Narduzzi and James Franklin are both under plenty of pressure, albeit for slightly different reasons.
The Panthers stumbled to a 3-9 record in 2023, their worst season since dropping nine of 11 in 1998. Franklin, meanwhile, guided the Nittany Lions to at least 10 wins for the fifth time ... and it felt a little hollow because Penn State once again struggled against the Big Ten’s best.
Who’s under more pressure this college football season is tough to say. The real answer is that both schools will be looking for more out of their respective football leaders.
“You're talking about a program where you can win 10 or 11 games, and people are not satisfied," Franklin said at Big Ten media day. "We totally get that and embrace that.”
While I’d argue that Narduzzi is probably under more pressure to prove the 2023 struggles were a fluke and Pitt’s more the program that won 20 games between 2021-22, there’s no shortage of expectations for Franklin in Happy Valley.
Read More
With the introduction of the 12-team College Football Playoff, the national net has now been widened to the point where it should theoretically include Penn State, the Nittany Lions finishing in the top-12 of the final polls six times in the past eight seasons.
Franklin’s team returns seven starters on each side of the ball but has new coordinators in Tom Allen (defense) and Andy Kotelnicki (offense). More than that, the Nittany Lions enjoyed the third-best scoring defense (13.5 points per game) among FBS teams in 2023 and led the nation in sacks (49).
Whether Penn State can remain dominant on that side of the ball should determine plenty, as the Nittany Lions must replace 10 players (in total) who are now with NFL programs.
Before getting too far into who could make a difference for Penn State, the issue remains whether Franklin can get his team over the hump, with a 3-11 record against Michigan and Ohio State since 2017 and a 12-26 mark against ranked teams during his tenure at the school.
While defending national champion Michigan did not make it onto Penn State’s schedule this fall — the Wolverines also appear to be rebuilding — an Oct. 12 visit to USC ramps up the competition before Ohio State arrives at Beaver Stadium on Nov. 2.
“We've got to play our best when our best is needed most," Franklin said.
For Penn State to do that, it will need second-year quarterback Drew Allar to take a step forward after he completed nearly 60% of his passes for 2,631 yards and 25 touchdowns (with just two interceptions) last season.
Allar has proven to be accurate and smart with the football. At the same time, Penn State must open up the playbook and throw downfield more in Year 2 of the Ohio native starting.
Nick Singleton and Kaytron Allen provide an impressive backfield punch — trailing only Ohio State when it comes to Big Ten running backs — while a deep offensive line could rotate as many as eight guys.
On defense, keep tabs on converted edge rusher Abdul Carter, who’s been racking up plenty of preseason accolades, including an All-American nod. After recording 48 tackles (25 solo) with 4.5 sacks in 2023, much more is expected out of the 6-foot-3, 259-pound junior as he moves out of his linebacker spot.
Kobe King and Dominic DeLuca remain important players in the middle, while Jaylen Reed is the only starter returning in the secondary.
For Penn State to erase the narrative that has dogged Franklin since winning 11 games and the Big Ten title in 2016 and make some noise in the CFB playoff, the margin for error will obviously be thin.
In Oakland, the big talk surrounding Narduzzi’s team has been Kade Bell’s uptempo offense and the Panthers wanting to play fast and produce points.
Nate Yarnell and Alabama transfer Eli Holstein will likely both see time under center, while Pitt must fix an offense — specifically a running game — that was the ACC’s worst in 2023.
Pitt averaged just 20.2 points per game, a number Bell hopes to at least double. Western Carolina transfer Desmond Reid will team with Rodney Hammond Jr. in the backfield, while the Panthers have talent on the receiving end of things: Konata Mumpfield, Daejon Reynolds and Kenny Johnson out wide, plus Gavin Bartholomew at tight end.
The defense was siphoned by the transfer portal and graduation, most notably Dayon Hayes bolting for Colorado and Pitt’s top three cornerbacks heading to the NFL. Linebacker and leader Brandon George returns and should hear his name called plenty.
Anchored by Donovan McMillon (Peters Township), Javon McIntyre and P.J. O’Brien, safety will be a position of strength. Steel Valley product Cruce Brookins is another to watch there.
A strength throughout Narduzzi’s tenure, the defensive line remains a sizable question mark. Nobody with more than three sacks returns, as the Panthers — routinely one of the best pressure defenses in FBS — registered their worst sack total (31) since 2017 last fall.
“We have a lot to prove,” Narduzzi said. “A lot of people have gone, ‘Where’s Pitt? Back where they used to be.’ That’s not the case. We have a lot to prove.
“I think this football team has got an attitude. I think they're hungry. I think they're determined to go out and play football the way we're expected to play.”
Despite his failures in big games, Franklin has enough to comfortably make the 12-team playoff — even if Penn State can’t topple Ohio State or USC. That should theoretically be enough to appease the fan base.
When it comes to Pitt, unless the Panthers can bounce back and win seven or more games in what should be a manageable ACC, the pressure on Narduzzi will be louder and more intense than whatever is heard in the middle part of the state.
Jason Mackey: jmackey@post-gazette.com and @JMackeyPG on X.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.