Some years ago I hooked a 10-inch trout on Pine Creek near one of the Rte. 8 bridges. Landing it, I noticed a foot of monofilament line sticking out of its mouth, a curiosity I had seen before on other fish.

What really surprised me, however, was another foot of line sticking out its back side. With the hook still attached.

Ouch!

Weeks before, apparently, the trout had taken live bait and the hook was set deep in its throat. The line snapped and despite the injury, the hardy fish had continued feeding. The hook and line traveled completely through its digestive system. Presumably, in the weeks after I released the fish, it continued feeding and the line continued passing through.

Advertise with us

Despite the delicate nature of many fish species, some survive with an impaled hook. And though they endure the hook-up, the fight and time out of the water many die from the consequences of mishandling by the conservationist anglers who released them. Biological and fungal infections, broken bones and suffocation are a few of the ways catch-and-release anglers kill fish.

Last week, special no-harvest regulations kicked in on 20 Southwest Pennsylvania lakes, streams and river sections designated Stocked Trout Waters Open to Year-Round Fishing.

Greensburg spin fisherman Doug Leichliter worried about poorly handled trout that won’t make it to opening day. He posted his concerns at The Fishing Hole, a public comment board on the state Fish and Boat Commission website.

“I've had a lot of pre-season fun at a number of area lakes, especially Mammoth and Twin Lakes here in Westmoreland County,” he wrote. “... That said, I've become very concerned with how I've observed other anglers catch fish and then release them during this early-season opportunity. I've seen entirely too many instances where the trout have been treated like some farm pond bluegill or bass — hooks pulled out and fish summarily tossed back into the water without much care or concern given to its long-term survival and the chance the fish will be caught again.”

Leichliter’s message caught the attention of Fish and Boaat Coldwater Unit leader Tom Greene.

Advertise with us

“As you pointed out, hooking mortality can occur if anglers don't take some basic precautions when releasing their catch,” he replied. “This not only applies to the March 1 to opening day period on these lakes but anytime during the year when anglers intend to release their catch.”

Greene noted that fish-handling guidelines were published in the Summary of Fishing Regulations and Laws booklet provided with fishing licenses from 1991 through 2015. Perhaps through an oversight, he said, the best-practices chapter didn’t make it into the 2016 Summary Book. Search for keywords “fish handling” at fishandboat.com for advice on how to release fish without causing additional injury.

“Hooking mortality really depends on what bait you’re using, where the fish is hooked and how you’re handling it,” said Greene, in a subsequent interview. “Bait anglers often hook deeper in the mouth regions and there’s potential there for higher hooking mortality — 5 to 25 percent when using bait.”

Typically, he said, fish caught on flies and lures have lower mortality rates of 2 to 4 percent.

But those statistics may be misleading. Greene said it isn’t necessarily the hook that kills the fish, it’s often how the hook is removed and the way the fish is handled.

Advertise with us

Yet, from a population perspective, he said, hooking mortality from bait, flies or lures is practically irrelevant compared to the sky high annual rates of natural fish mortality. Some 35 to 75 percent of freshwater fish die off every year. Wild brook trout die naturally at a rate of 40 to 50 percent per year, and the annual mortality of less hardy hatchery trout is substantially higher.

Clearly, the longer anglers can keep fish alive the more opportunity they’ll have to catch them.

“It starts when you land the fish,” said Fish and Boat fisheries biologist Mike Depew. “Grabbing it by the lip can be bad, especially if it’s a big fish. Putting all of its weight on the jaw could break the bone and the fish would starve.”

Depew said he banks his fish or scoops them into a wet, fine mesh net. With the trout still in the net in the water, he removes the hook with forceps and shakes the net to free it.

If the fish is bleeding or hooked deep, he says, snip the line as close to the hook as possible. The fish is more likely to survive the hook than the attempt to remove it.

Advertise with us

Be careful how you hold the fish. Keep those fingers away from the delicate gills, and wet your hands before touching it.

“There’s a protective covering — call it a slime — that can come off a lot more easily if you have dry hands,” said Depew. “Without the slime, a variety of bacteria, fungi and other pathogens can get into the fish.”

Letting it flop around on dry ground or a boat deck, he said, can be just as damaging.

When it’s time for the fish’s close-up, make it fast. Holding it out of the water for more than 30 seconds can hurt it. Parading a trout around for a minute or more can cause it to suffocate, or the gills could dry out or freeze.

Big fish present a special handling problem.

“When I start getting trout in the 15- to 16-inch range or bigger, I’ll hold it firmly with one hand in front of and around the tail and the other hand slides up the fish’s belly to just behind the gills,” he said. “That’s probably the safest way to hold a large fish — support the majority of its weight where the organs are, in the center of the body.”