In some urban neighborhoods deer are an overbrowsing pest. Throughout most of Allegheny and Philadelphia counties deer are healthy and plentiful, dodging cars but protected behind No Hunting signs on many private properties.

The state Game Commission claims that after years of intentional reductions in deer numbers, and with population stability largely maintained, whitetail numbers are going up.

But 14 years into the agency’s embrace of “quality deer management,” hunters in northcentral Pennsylvania continue to complain that the plan has removed too many deer from those mountainous deep-woods counties.

“In my experience, having a camp in the Northern Tier, I’m seeing a few more deer [than in recent years], but certainly not in the numbers we had years ago,” said Randy Santucci of Robinson. “I don’t see evidence of an increase in deer sign. If there’s no sign of deer, they’re not there.”

Advertise with us

Santucci’s interest in deer is more than personal. This week he steps down as president of Unified Sportsmen of Pennsylvania, a statewide hunter organization that has challenged the state’s whitetail game plan. He’ll become the group’s chairman of the board.

“Quality deer management” is a conservation strategy that seeks to determine deer population, health and sex ratio through qualitative analyses of habitat, head counts at deer processing centers, tallies from hunter report cards and other means. Deer populations in specific regions are manipulated by controlling the harvest, and the most effective of several tools is the allocation of antlerless deer permits.

At last week’s meeting of the Board of Game Commissioners, discussion centered on doe tag allocations, which have in recent years been significantly reduced in some of the state’s wildlife management units. Commission vice-president Brian Hoover of Philadelphia said the reductions have increased the deer population in some areas. Commissioners discussed the possibility of further increasing license allocations.

“I don’t know, we came off a pretty low deer harvest last year,” said Santucci. “This one-size-fits-all management plan doesn’t work. It’s part and parcel of why you have some areas that are good for deer hunting and some cold spots where there just aren’t enough deer.”

Biologist Wayne Laroche, former head of the Vermont Department of Fish and Wildlife, is still settling into his new job at the helm of the Pennsylvania Game Commission Bureau of Wildlife Management. Throughout his decades in conservation, he’s learned at least one thing:

Advertise with us

“There will always be some people who don’t see a deer,” he said. “Maybe it’s someone who’s hunted from the same stump for 40 years and didn’t see one this year. Well, things change. I heard 65 percent of people are pretty happy with deer hunting in Pennsylvania [according to a Game Commission survey]. In my experience, that’s about as good as you can get.”

Vermont, too, uses a quality deer management approach, but Laroche said he’s noticed stark differences in deer-hunting culture since he left New England.

“In Vermont there are mandatory check stations where every deer is weighted and the antlers counted. There’s a tradition of people taking deer to those stations and the weight is real important -- they get their pictures in the paper,” he said. “Things are different in Pennsylvania. First, we’re dealing with tremendously more deer here. In Vermont, we were seeing 8,000-9,000 deer -- here we’re dealing with 300,000.”

Antlerless allocations have been slowly rising for a few years. The 2015-16 Deer Population Report -- a collaboration of the Game Commission, U.S. Forest Service, Pennsylvania Department of Conservation and Natural Resources, Pennsylvania Cooperative Fish and Wildlife Research Unit at Penn State University and Responsive Management -- found population trends increasing in just two WMUs (2D and 5D). But in the same period, allocation increases were recommended in 21 WMUs. Allocations stayed the same in 5A and dropped in 5D.

In 2B, the WMU surrounding Pittsburgh, deer are considered “stable.” Doe tags sold out quickly last year, and the allocation rose from 60,000 in 2014-15 to 61,000 in the current hunting season. But in the urban unit with liberal hunting seasons, a place where the Game Commission would like to see fewer deer, the harvest estimate has dropped (2013-14 4,800 antlered, 16,000 antlerless, 20,800 total; 2014-15 4,300 antlered, 13,000 antlerless, 17,300 total).

Advertise with us

Laroche noted that another indicator suggests that deer numbers are going up. The annual State Farm Insurance collision claims estimates, released Thursday, show Pennsylvania retaining its dubious distinction as No. 1 in deer-vehicle collisions with an estimated 126,275 in 2014-15, up from 105,876 in 2005-06. No. 2 in deer collisions, Michigan, has dropped from 82,962 in 2005-06 to 72,109 in 2014-15.

On his way out at Unified Sportsmen, Santucci said his beef with the Game Commission has mostly concerned “bad management of deer on public land.”

“Landowners do a better job,” he said. “When they want more deer, they just let fewer guys in.”

On his way in at the Game Commission, Laroche said there’s always room for improvement.

“I think it’s a pretty good system, and I’m confident in the deer harvest,” he said. “But there are always little ways to improve the process or the methodology. I’m going to ask if we can experiment and tweak and maybe make things better on a continuous basis.”