A legislative effort originally intended to give game animals a sporting chance could soon be flipped on Second Amendment grounds.
Pennsylvania’s long-held prohibition on hunting with semi-automatic rifles and handguns is not a Game Commission regulation, it’s a state law passed to restrict hunters’ firepower and facilitate fair chase.
Last week at a meeting of the House Game and Fisheries Committee, legislators considered bills that would permit hunters to use the increasingly popular “military style” semi-automatic firearms, which automatically reload after each shot — one trigger pull, one shot.
Currently, semi-auto rifles and handguns are legal in the state, but not for hunting. Semi-automatic shotguns plugged to three shells are legal for turkeys, small game, waterfowl, crows, coyotes and furbearers. Unplugged semi-auto shotguns loaded with rifled slugs are legal for deer and bears in some special regulations areas.
Citing the right to bear arms, two representatives filed similar bills that would expand the hunting use of semi-autos. Rep. Rick Saccone, R-Elizabeth Township, would permit semi-auto firearms for all forms of hunting. A bill sponsored by Rep. Curtis Sonney, R-Erie, would permit their use only in hunting coyotes, foxes and groundhogs. The Pennsylvania Federation of Sportsmen’s Clubs, which represents about 200 clubs, has endorsed the Sonney plan.
Matt Hough, executive director of the state Game Commission, told the committee his agency supports a slow roll-out of semi-automatic rifles for varmints only, but not for the hunting of deer, bear and other game.
Hough said he was concerned about the public perception of hunters in camouflage carrying military-style weapons. Some landowners, he said, will post their properties if the use of semi-automatics for hunting is made legal.
Game Commission spokesman Travis Lau said semi-auto use on coyotes and woodchucks, which have yearlong hunting seasons and unlimited take, would probably have no effect on resource management.
“As for law enforcement, I don’t see much of an impact at all,” he said. “Semi-autos would need to be compliant with magazine-capacity, ammunition restrictions, etc., just as other sporting arms are, and routinely would be checked in the field by our officers, just as the case is now.”
Reaction to the proposals from outside the hunting community has been limited, but some hunters are opposed.
“Ethical sportsmen want a fair chase,” said Dave Levdansky of Forward. “In so many quarters of the hunting community, hunters are going to muzzleloaders and flintlocks.
“Two or three shots at an animal is more than enough.”
A lifelong hunter, Levdansky served in Harrisburg for 26 years as a Democratic legislator, ending his career as an influential chairman of the House Finance Committee and member of the Game and Fisheries Committee.
His signature legislative achievements included increasing Game Commission accountability, opening new areas for hunters and habitat protection.
“I suspect this is coming up now because gun manufacturers are trying to re-label ‘semi-auto’ with ‘modern sporting arms’ so they appear to be weapons that hunters will want to use,” he said. “These are not sporting rifles. They are assault rifles that have camo paint on them.
“They were not designed to shoot game, they were designed for warfare.”
Both bills remain in committee.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.